Before I Fall is not the only young adult novel to deal with complicated themes of life, death, rebirth, and examining one’s life and choices carefully.
If I Stay, a 2009 novel by Gayle Forman, tells the story of Mia, a teenage girl who is the only member of her family to survive a catastrophic car accident (
Before I Fall also revolves largely around a fateful car accident.) Mia is left in a coma, and through an out-of-body experience she is able to watch her friends and family deal with the fallout of the accident, and must decide whether to return to her loved ones on Earth and live on without her parents and her brother, or join them in the afterlife but leave behind the chance at an earthly future. Additionally, the repetitive structure of
Before I Fall mirrors the plot structure of the popular Bill Murray movie
Groundhog Day, in which Phil Connors, a newscaster who is disappointed to have been assigned to cover the titular holiday alongside his beautiful coworker, must repeat the events of Groundhog Day over and over, eventually learning lessons of empathy, compassion, and self-reflection. Sam even mentions
Groundhog Day when she realizes what is happening to her, and in the end it is Sam’s examination of her life choices—and her desire to subvert her past cruelties and make a difference in the lives of those around her—that delivers her from her time loop, just as Phil Connors was delivered from his through self-reflection, love, and goodwill toward others.