Fresh Fruit, Broken Bodies

by

Seth Holmes

Structural Violence Term Analysis

The term structural violence efers to the way that social hierarchies create physical and mental suffering and sickness.

Structural Violence Quotes in Fresh Fruit, Broken Bodies

The Fresh Fruit, Broken Bodies quotes below are all either spoken by Structural Violence or refer to Structural Violence. For each quote, you can also see the other terms and themes related to it (each theme is indicated by its own dot and icon, like this one:
Social Hierarchy and Violence Theme Icon
).
Chapter 1 Quotes

I attempt to portray and analyze the lives and experiences of Macario and my other Triqui companions in order to understand better the social and symbolic context of suffering among migrant laborers. I hope that understanding the mechanisms by which certain classes of people become written off and social inequalities become taken for granted will play a part in undoing these very mechanisms and the structures of which they are part. It is my hope that those who read these pages will be moved in mutual humanity, such that representations of and policies toward migrant laborers become more humane, just, and responsive to migrant laborers as people themselves. The American public could begin to see Mexican migrant workers as fellow humans, skilled and hard workers, people treated unfairly with the odds against them. I hope these recognitions will change public opinion and employer and clinical practices, as well as policies related to economics, immigration, and labor. In addition, I hope this book will help anthropologists and other social scientists understand the ways in which perception, social hierarchy, and naturalization work more broadly.

Related Characters: Seth Holmes (speaker)
Page Number: 29
Explanation and Analysis:
Chapter 3 Quotes

Over the course of my fieldwork, many of my friends and family who visited me in the labor camp quickly blamed the farm management for the poor living and working conditions of berry pickers.
[…]
The stark reality and precarious future of the farm serve as reminders that the situation is more complex. The corporatization of U.S. agriculture and the growth of international free markets squeeze growers such that they cannot easily imagine increasing the pay of the pickers or improving the labor camps without bankrupting the farm. In other words, many of the most powerful inputs into the suffering of farmworkers are structural, not willed by individual agents. In this case, structural violence is enacted by market rule and later channeled by international and domestic racism, classism, sexism, and anti-immigrant prejudice. However, structural violence is not just a simple, unidirectional phenomenon; rather macro social and economic structures produce vulnerability at every level of the farm hierarchy.

Related Characters: Seth Holmes (speaker)
Page Number: Chapter 3: Segregation on the Farm: Ethnic Hierarchies at Work52
Explanation and Analysis:
Chapter 4 Quotes

The suffering of Triqui migrant laborers is an embodiment of multiple forms of violence. The political violence of land wars has pushed them to live in inhospitable climates without easy access to water for crops. The structural violence of global neoliberal capitalism forces them to leave home and family members, suffer through a long and deadly desert border crossing, and search for a means to survive in a new land. The structural violence of labor hierarchies in the United States organized around ethnicity and citizenship positions them at the bottom, with the most dangerous and backbreaking occupations and the worst accommodations. Due to their location at the bottom of the pecking order, the undocumented Triqui migrant workers endure disproportionate injury and sickness.

Related Characters: Seth Holmes (speaker), Abelino, Crescencio , Bernardo
Page Number: 109
Explanation and Analysis:
Chapter 5 Quotes

Years later, Abelino still tells me that he has knee pain and that "doctors don't know anything" (los medicos no saben nada).
After considering in some detail the course of Abelino's interactions with health care institutions, this common statement makes more sense. Several assumptions were made along the way, from the absence of stomach problems to his first return to work being "light duty," from his ability to read English to his being paid as an hourly worker, from his incorrect picking as the cause of his injury to his faking of the pain, from the importance of "Objective" biotechnical tests to the disqualification of his words and experiences.

Related Characters: Seth Holmes (speaker), Abelino (speaker)
Page Number: 124
Explanation and Analysis:
Chapter 7 Quotes

If health professionals responded to sickness by treating not only its current manifestations but also its social, economic, and political causes, we could create a realistically critical public health and a "liberation medicine." This latter term alludes to liberation theology, in which a reflective engagement with those who are poor and suffering leads to new ways of thinking and practicing theology in order to achieve social justice. While there is genuine need for the skills of narrowly trained, competent biomedical physicians, I am convinced this is not enough.
As shown by the health care experiences of Abelino, Crescencio, and Bernardo, medical skills practiced without recognition of the social structures causing sickness are doomed to address only the downstream, biological and behavioral inputs into disease. This leads to ineffective health care at best and complicit, injurious health care at worst.

Related Characters: Seth Holmes (speaker), Abelino, Crescencio , Bernardo
Page Number: 193-194
Explanation and Analysis:
Get the entire Fresh Fruit, Broken Bodies LitChart as a printable PDF.
Fresh Fruit, Broken Bodies PDF

Structural Violence Term Timeline in Fresh Fruit, Broken Bodies

The timeline below shows where the term Structural Violence appears in Fresh Fruit, Broken Bodies. The colored dots and icons indicate which themes are associated with that appearance.
Chapter 2: “We Are Field Workers”: Embodied Anthropology of Migration
Social Hierarchy and Violence Theme Icon
...of Migrant Farmwork. Holmes wants to show how migrants suffer because of a combination of structural violence and symbolic violence. Structural violence is the way that social inequalities physically injure and... (full context)
Chapter 3: Segregation on the Farm: Ethnic Hierarchies at Work
Social Hierarchy and Violence Theme Icon
Global Pressures and Individual Choices Theme Icon
...or invest in remodeling the labor camps. This, Holmes says, is a clear example of structural violence. (full context)
Chapter 4: “How the Poor Suffer”: Embodying the Violence Continuum
Social Hierarchy and Violence Theme Icon
...in her body, and another reports that he can’t run anymore. This is example of structural violence, or the way social hierarchy creates physical suffering. Anthropologists Nancy Scheper-Hughes and Philippe Bourgois... (full context)
Social Hierarchy and Violence Theme Icon
Bias in Healthcare Theme Icon
...diagnosed with tendonitis. Clearly, it’s a result of his physically traumatic job. This shows how structural violence functions: economic policies forced Abelino to migrate, put repeated stress on his joints, and... (full context)
Social Hierarchy and Violence Theme Icon
Holmes points out that structural and symbolic violence are working together in a cycle to cause Crescencio’s pain. Crescencio suffers... (full context)
Social Hierarchy and Violence Theme Icon
Global Pressures and Individual Choices Theme Icon
Labor and Immigration Policy Theme Icon
Holmes explains that Bernardo’s suffering is also the result of structural violence: global economic policies impoverished Oaxacans and led to the local conflict over land, and... (full context)
Social Hierarchy and Violence Theme Icon
Global Pressures and Individual Choices Theme Icon
...of” all the violence they have suffered. This includes violent armed conflicts as well as structural violence, like the implosion of Oaxaca’s rural economy due to economic polices and the ethnic-citizenship... (full context)
Chapter 5: “Doctors Don’t Know Anything”: The Clinical Gaze in Migrant Health
Social Hierarchy and Violence Theme Icon
Bias in Healthcare Theme Icon
...But by combining them, scholars have examined how patients tell stories about illness and how structural violence causes it. Holmes wants to show how both these things also apply to healthcare... (full context)
Social Hierarchy and Violence Theme Icon
Global Pressures and Individual Choices Theme Icon
Bias in Healthcare Theme Icon
...needs, and reported symptoms. Second, doctors blamed Abelino for his pain rather than seeing the structural factors behind it. Finally, because of the market forces in the U.S.’s for-profit healthcare industry,... (full context)
Social Hierarchy and Violence Theme Icon
Bias in Healthcare Theme Icon
...conforms to the racist stereotype of a violent, alcoholic Mexican domestic abuser. This reinforces the structural and symbolic violence that caused his headaches in the first place. (full context)
Social Hierarchy and Violence Theme Icon
Bias in Healthcare Theme Icon
...effective treatment. But Holmes’s research shows that healthcare’s culture is the real problem. He proposes “structural competency” instead. When they don’t understand structural violence, doctors tend to reinforce it. They also... (full context)
Chapter 6: “Because They’re Lower to the Ground”: Naturalizing Social Suffering
Social Hierarchy and Violence Theme Icon
...appear justified. This is a powerful kind of symbolic violence, which justifies and sometimes multiplies structural violence. For instance, the crop manager Scott justifies exposing  pickers to dangerous pesticides by saying... (full context)
Chapter 7: Conclusion: Change, Pragmatic Solidarity, and Beyond
Social Hierarchy and Violence Theme Icon
Anthropology and Activism Theme Icon
...to exploit their workers. This shows that the political, social, and economic forces that cause structural violence are extremely powerful. These forces justify the inequalities they create through symbolic violence and... (full context)
Social Hierarchy and Violence Theme Icon
Anthropology and Activism Theme Icon
Holmes cites the sociologist Pierre Bourdieu, who explained how unequal social structures reproduce themselves through structural and symbolic violence. Specifically, social structures give people certain kinds of bodily habits (or habitus)... (full context)
Social Hierarchy and Violence Theme Icon
Anthropology and Activism Theme Icon
...research can help fight the militarization of the U.S.-Mexico border and health professionals’ complicity in structural violence. (full context)