Previous
Part 3, Chapter 3
Themes
Key
LitCharts assigns a color and icon to each theme in Harlem Shuffle, which you can use to track the themes throughout the work.
Crime, Class, and Social Mobility
Identity and Duality
Community, Change, and Loyalty
Systemic Racism, Injustice, and Power
Betrayal, Vengeance, and Integrity
Summary
Analysis
In his office, Carney uses a letter opener to open the leather briefcase in his safe. Its monogram suggests it belonged to Linus. Inside are personal papers and an enormous emerald necklace shaped like a bird. He decided to open the briefcase after Aunt Millie’s house was ransacked. Surveying the thorough destruction at Aunt Millie’s, Carney knew the perpetrators were searching for something specific. Aunt Millie was furious and worried it had something to do with Freddie, though Carney denied knowledge of his cousin’s whereabouts. Now, Carney wonders if the emerald necklace is some Van Wyck heirloom or stolen from someone like Chink Montague. He feels trapped by his association with Freddie.
The Van Wyck necklace, like Lucinda Cole’s, is a liability to whoever possesses it—even Carney, who has come upon it by accident. Carney is motivated by his concern for Aunt Millie, in sharp contrast to Freddie, who has not even contacted his mother. Freddie’s irresponsible actions have unintentionally brought harm to his family, making Carney question his loyalty to his cousin.
Themes
Carney puts Rusty and Marie on paid leave, pretending to be worried about further rioting. Munson visits and Carney rides with the detective on his route to collect payments from various business owners. Munson collects from a newspaper stand which apparently hosts the longest-running craps games in Harlem. Carney’s ignorance of this fact makes him feel like an outsider in his own city. He confronts Munson for failing to warn him about the officers investigating Linus’s death. Munson blames the riots. He was running surveillance on activists, and when the violence began, he rounded up protesters with the rest of the police. He feels comfortable telling Carney about putting Black and Jewish cops undercover at protest meetings because Carney is “not political.”
Unlike Freddie, Carney considers how others might be affected by his criminal involvement. Munson’s route shows Harlem in a different light, exposing how pervasive crooked behavior is in a society that prioritizes financial wealth. Carney’s sense of alienation calls his identity into question in a new way, as if he does not know his own home. He is irritated at Munson for not giving him a heads-up about the officers, which he should have done as part of their protection agreement. Though Munson thinks Carney is “not political,” Carney does care about the riots and racial injustice, even if his business takes precedence in his mind. That Munson does not see the ways systemic racism affects all Black people betrays a lack of societal awareness.
Themes
Thanks to the riots, Munson is behind on collecting his protection payments. Had he known other officers were questioning Carney, he would have told them he was “a solid citizen.” Munson collects from a cake shop while Carney thinks bitterly about Mr. Gibbs, who hasn’t returned his calls. Remembering how his and Pepper’s hunt for Miami Joe felt like opening doors to the underworld, Carney feels that Munson’s route is revealing well-known establishments as fronts for crooked dealings. Knowing he is part of this criminal underworld masking itself as everyday business, Carney feels trapped in a city of secrets. When Munson returns, he tells Carney he’s on his own with the detectives, as the Van Wyck case is too high-profile.
Munson is primarily concerned with his own payments, demonstrating how capitalism can erode human empathy. His reassurances to Carney ring hollow, as they do him no good as hypotheticals. Considering the city’s criminal underworld and the role he plays in it, Carney’s identity feels more precarious, and he seems weary of the strange ways in which his own home has betrayed him. Munson’s inability to help Carney with the Van Wycks demonstrates that even the law is limited in the scope of action it can take against people of such wealth and power.
Themes
Munson shows Carney a newspaper article about Linus’s death, the cause still unknown. The Van Wycks are putting pressure on the mayor, looking for Freddie and whatever he stole. Carney plays dumb, realizing Munson is trying to discover what he knows. The detective tells him a jewelry store that conducts an illegal side business similar to Carney’s was ransacked, though the owner insists nothing was stolen. Munson theorizes that someone is trying to send a message to fences around the neighborhood. Carney walks back to the store and finds the front door unlocked. Freddie, who has a key, is waiting in his office, seeming untroubled. He quips that it’s a good thing Carney never gave him the safe’s combination.
Not only will Munson not help Carney with the Van Wyck situation, but he also seems to suspect Carney’s involvement and be actively working to incriminate him. Probably because of the necklace, fencing businesses are now under particular suspicion, making Carney a primary target. Freddie’s reappearance and flippant demeanor are infuriating given the trouble Carney has been to on his cousin’s behalf, testing the limits of familial loyalty.
Themes
Get the entire Harlem Shuffle LitChart as a printable PDF.
