On the Genealogy of Morals

by

Friedrich Nietzsche

Ascetic ideals Term Analysis

Ascetic ideals are values that advocate withdrawing, abstaining, or rejecting bodily, emotional, and material aspects of everyday life. Nietzsche says the Christian motto of “poverty, chastity, humility” is an ascetic ideal because it suggests that people need to abstain from material wealth, sensual urges, and emotional or egotistical feelings. Nietzsche also thinks that many nonreligious people practice the ascetic ideal. Any social practice that advocates withdrawing from life’s messy day-to-day components also embodies the ascetic ideal. For example, philosophers and scientists need peace and quiet to think, so they tend to withdraw from life, or be ascetic, in that sense. Philosophers also privilege rational or intellectual thinking and depict feelings and bodily urges as inferior and primitive—in other words, they champion the ascetic ideal. An ascetic priest is a person who endorses the ascetic ideal.

Ascetic ideals Quotes in On the Genealogy of Morals

The On the Genealogy of Morals quotes below are all either spoken by Ascetic ideals or refer to Ascetic ideals. For each quote, you can also see the other terms and themes related to it (each theme is indicated by its own dot and icon, like this one:
Good and Evil Theme Icon
).
What Do Ascetic Ideals Mean? Quotes

What is the meaning of ascetic ideals?

Related Characters: Friedrich Nietzsche (speaker), Ascetic priest, Richard Wagner , Arthur Schopenhauer , Immanuel Kant
Page Number: 83
Explanation and Analysis:

At any rate, this should be the case with all mortals who are sound in mind and body, who are far from regarding their delicate balance between ‘animal’ and ‘angel’ as necessarily an objection to existence—the brightest and most insightful of them, such as Goethe and Hafiz, have even seen in this another of life's charms. Such ‘conflicts’ actually make life all the more enticing.

Related Characters: Friedrich Nietzsche (speaker), Richard Wagner , Parsifal , Johann Wolfgang von Goethe , Hafiz
Page Number: 84-85
Explanation and Analysis:

He suddenly realized that more could be effected by the novelty of the Schopenhauerian […] notion of the sovereignty of music, as Schopenhauer understood it; music set apart from and distinguished from all the other arts, music as the independent art-in-itself, not like the other arts, affording images of the phenomenal world, but rather speaking the language of the will itself, straight out of the ‘abyss,’ as its most personal, original and direct manifestation.

Related Characters: Friedrich Nietzsche (speaker), Richard Wagner , Arthur Schopenhauer , Parsifal
Page Number: 89
Explanation and Analysis:

But, as I feared, the contrary was always the case and so, from the very beginning, we get from our philosophers definitions upon which the lack of any refined personal experience squats like a big fat stupid worm, as it does on Kant's famous definition of the beautiful. ‘That is beautiful,’ says Kant, ‘which pleases without interest.’

Related Characters: Friedrich Nietzsche (speaker), Immanuel Kant
Page Number: 90
Explanation and Analysis:

Without interest?! Compare this definition with this other one, made by an ‘artist,’ an ‘observer’ truly capable of aesthetic appreciation—by Stendhal, who once called the beautiful une promesse de bonheur.

Related Characters: Friedrich Nietzsche (speaker), Immanuel Kant , Stendhal
Page Number: 90
Explanation and Analysis:

Schopenhauer has described one effect of the beautiful—the calming of the will—but is this effect the usual one?

Related Characters: Friedrich Nietzsche (speaker), Arthur Schopenhauer , Stendhal
Page Number: 91
Explanation and Analysis:

Every animal […] strives instinctively after the most favourable conditions: those under which it can exert its full strength, and experience its greatest feeling of power; every animal also instinctively abhors (and with an acute sense ‘surpassing all reason’) any kind of disruption or hindrance which obstructs or could obstruct his path to this optimum (it is not his way to ‘happiness’ of which I speak, but his path to power, to action, the most powerful action, and in point of fact in many cases his way to misery).

Related Characters: Friedrich Nietzsche (speaker), Arthur Schopenhauer , Immanuel Kant
Page Number: 93
Explanation and Analysis:

We know the three great catch-words of the ascetic ideal: poverty, humility chastity; and if we look closely at the lives of all the great productive, creative intellects, we will find these present again and again, in some measure.

Related Characters: Friedrich Nietzsche (speaker), Arthur Schopenhauer , Immanuel Kant
Page Number: 94
Explanation and Analysis:

There is only a seeing from a perspective, only a ‘knowing’ from a perspective, and the more emotions we express concerning a thing, the more eyes, different eyes, we train on the same thing, the more complete will be our ‘idea’ of that thing, our ‘objectivity.’

Related Characters: Friedrich Nietzsche (speaker), Immanuel Kant
Page Number: 106
Explanation and Analysis:

Look into the background of every family, of every institution, of every community; you will see everywhere the struggle of the sick against the healthy[.]

Related Characters: Friedrich Nietzsche (speaker)
Related Symbols: Sickness and Health
Page Number: 110
Explanation and Analysis:

‘I suffer: someone is to blame’—all sick sheep think this. But his shepherd, the ascetic priest, says to him, ‘Quite so, my sheep, it must be the fault of someone but you yourself are that someone, you alone are to blame—you yourself are to blame for yourself;’ that is bold enough, false enough, but one thing is at least attained thereby, as I have said: resentment is—diverted.

Related Characters: Friedrich Nietzsche (speaker), Ascetic priest
Related Symbols: Sickness and Health
Page Number: 114
Explanation and Analysis:

The hypnotic sensation of nothingness, the peace of deepest sleep, anaesthesia in short—this is regarded by the sufferers and the absolutely depressed as their supreme good[.]

Related Characters: Friedrich Nietzsche (speaker), Ascetic priest
Page Number: 119-120
Explanation and Analysis:

No! This ‘modern science’—mark this well—is now the best ally for the ascetic ideal, and for the very reason that it is the least conscious, least spontaneous, least known of allies!

Related Characters: Friedrich Nietzsche (speaker)
Page Number: 137
Explanation and Analysis:

Man will desire oblivion rather than not desire at all.

Related Characters: Friedrich Nietzsche (speaker)
Page Number: 145
Explanation and Analysis:
Get the entire On the Genealogy of Morals LitChart as a printable PDF.
On the Genealogy of Morals PDF

Ascetic ideals Term Timeline in On the Genealogy of Morals

The timeline below shows where the term Ascetic ideals appears in On the Genealogy of Morals. The colored dots and icons indicate which themes are associated with that appearance.
Third Essay: What Do Ascetic Ideals Mean?
The Repression of Human Nature Theme Icon
1. Nietzsche wonders about the significance of ascetic ideal s, which celebrate self-control and holding back from material, emotional, and bodily desires—similar to the... (full context)
Art, Beauty, and Emotions  Theme Icon
...Nietzsche wishes that Wagner intended to create a parody or satire exposing how perverse the ascetic ideal is, but Wagner didn’t. Nietzsche says that when Parsifal is taken seriously, the character hates... (full context)
Art, Beauty, and Emotions  Theme Icon
5. Nietzsche decides that when artists address the ascetic ideal in their work, they’re really just reflecting the views of society, their patrons, or a... (full context)
The Repression of Human Nature Theme Icon
Art, Beauty, and Emotions  Theme Icon
...hostile to sensuality—Schopenhauer just exposes that tendency most visibly. Philosophers also tend to praise the ascetic ideal , which advocates self-control against material or bodily desires. This makes sense to Nietzsche: because... (full context)
The Repression of Human Nature Theme Icon
8. Such philosophers assume that the ascetic ideal —which champions “poverty, humility, chastity”—is universally virtuous and morally good. Nietzsche emphasizes that philosophers confuse... (full context)
The Repression of Human Nature Theme Icon
...attitude to life helps intellectuals to do their work, they’ve never been impartial about the ascetic ideal . In fact, Nietzsche thinks that modern life is foolish: we’re arrogant and reckless in... (full context)
The Repression of Human Nature Theme Icon
...a way to justify their radical break with society’s preference for proactive, warlike behavior. The ascetic ideal serves intellectuals well, as it justifies the philosophers’ tendency to withdraw from society. Philosophers have... (full context)
The Repression of Human Nature Theme Icon
13. Nietzsche revisits the ascetic ideal , which advocates severe withdrawal from material emotional, and bodily aspects of everyday life—or, as... (full context)
The Repression of Human Nature Theme Icon
20. Such people intend to use the ascetic ideal to alleviate emotional pain—but only covers up symptoms rather than providing a cure. Their methods,... (full context)
The Repression of Human Nature Theme Icon
...makes people emotionally volatile (rather than free from the burden of feelings). To Nietzsche, the ascetic ideal is the worst possible path for Europeans’ health. (full context)
The Repression of Human Nature Theme Icon
...Testament loses its “Jewish” feel and becomes pedestrian, hysterical, and shallow. Nietzsche concludes that the ascetic ideal is an education in bad taste and bad manners. (full context)
The Repression of Human Nature Theme Icon
23. Nietzsche continues disparaging the ascetic ideal . He thinks it’s damaging in many other ways, but already the extent of its... (full context)
The Repression of Human Nature Theme Icon
...people who claim to be areligious (such as scientists, atheists, skeptics) try to reject the ascetic ideal . They believe in intellectuality over faith and see themselves to be freethinkers, but they... (full context)
The Repression of Human Nature Theme Icon
Art, Beauty, and Emotions  Theme Icon
25. Nietzsche is doubtful that there’s any social practice in European culture that challenges the ascetic ideal or that provides an alternative to it. Nietzsche sarcastically extolls the virtues of Europe’s great... (full context)
The Repression of Human Nature Theme Icon
...humankind, and it’s the big one: the meaning of our existence. Nietzsche thinks that the ascetic ideal fills the void for a while—it makes us think that we suffer, but that we... (full context)