The Glass Hotel

by

Emily St. John Mandel

The Glass Hotel: Chapter 16: Vincent in the Ocean Summary & Analysis

Summary
Analysis
In a series of fragments, Vincent describes her final moments on earth, instructing herself to “begin at the end,” with a depiction of her falling off the ship with her camera. She revises her previous statement, beginning “twenty minutes earlier,” instead, when she is sitting in her room onboard the Neptune Cumberland with Geoffrey Bell. It’s December 2018, and they’ve been a couple for years, though things aren’t perfect. Geoffrey has wanted to marry Vincent, but she refuses to be dependent on anyone ever again, and she never wants to return to land.
This chapter bears the same title as the novel’s opening chapter, which officially confirms that the unnamed narrator featured in Chapter 1 was Vincent. Vincent’s refusal to be dependent on anyone again might be seen as her attempt to atone for the way her dependency on Alkaitis indirectly implicated her in his Ponzi scheme and, by extension, the destruction of many investors’ lives.
Themes
Complicity and Interconnectedness Theme Icon
Guilt and Responsibility  Theme Icon
Fraud and Constructed Identity  Theme Icon
Greed, Delusion, and Self Interest  Theme Icon
Alienation and Self-Knowledge  Theme Icon
Regret and Disillusionment  Theme Icon
Tonight, in particular, there is tension between the two of them because Geoffrey is mad at Vincent for walking on deck during hazardous weather when the crew had been instructed to remain indoors until the storm subsided. Vincent broke the rules last night to go outside to film the sea. Geoffrey insists he’s not ordering her around to control her, but to protect her. Vincent accuses Geoffrey of “being melodramatic,” but he refuses to back down. They lay in bed and watch Vincent’s suitcase move back and forth across the room as the sea sways underneath the boat.
Geoffrey’s concern is warranted, given the sea’s treacherous conditions. Vincent’s pathological need to be independent prevents her from seeing Geoffrey’s concern as authentic, and she distorts this concern, transforming it into a nefarious attempt to control her.
Themes
Fraud and Constructed Identity  Theme Icon
Greed, Delusion, and Self Interest  Theme Icon
Suddenly, Vincent rises from the bed and walks onto the C deck and into the storm. She loves the feeling of the rain, the violent flashes of lightening. She walks to the blind spot corner of the C deck, turns on her camera, and records the storm. Vincent clutches the railing with one hand, but she lets go for a moment to steady the camera. Suddenly, she thinks she sees someone at the other end of the deck but realizes she must be alone, since she thought she saw a woman, and she’s the only woman on this ship.
Vincent’s need for complete independence leads her to venture outside to film the storm, disregarding Geoffrey’s sincere feelings of concern for her wellbeing.  It's possible that the woman Vincent thinks she saw was her mother. The fact that Vincent associates her mother with water and the open sea supports this idea.
Themes
Greed, Delusion, and Self Interest  Theme Icon
Alienation and Self-Knowledge  Theme Icon
But Vincent realizes she wasn’t mistaken: there is a woman there, illuminated with each flash of lightning. The figure is not fully human, more “a disturbance of the air” that appears and fades with each lightning strike. Suddenly, Olivia Collins is standing beside Vincent at the railing, though she’s “younger” and “less substantial” than she was the last time Vincent saw her. Vincent is still holding the camera over the ship’s railing. As Olivia turns to speak to Vincent, Vincent loses her grip on the camera, and it slips from her hands into the water. Vincent reaches for it, but she bends too far, loses control, and falls overboard, feeling “weightless” as she tumbles through the air into the water.
Seeing Olivia’s ghost is a reflection of the guilt Vincent feels over the financial devastation Olivia experienced when Alkaitis’s Ponzi scheme collapsed. Though Vincent wasn’t directly complicit in the scheme, the defrauded money funded her lifestyle. That Vincent feels “weightless” as she falls from the ship suggests that dying will rid Vincent of the burdens of guilt, grief, and remorse she’s carried with her over the years.
Themes
Complicity and Interconnectedness Theme Icon
Guilt and Responsibility  Theme Icon
Fraud and Constructed Identity  Theme Icon
Alienation and Self-Knowledge  Theme Icon
Regret and Disillusionment  Theme Icon
Get the entire The Glass Hotel LitChart as a printable PDF.
The Glass Hotel PDF
The narrative breaks down into more fragmented, surreal pieces as Vincent splashes into the “annihilating” cold of the water. She is a small child holding hands with her mother and gathering mushrooms in Caiette. Now she exists in “the moment before sleep,” in a state of subconsciousness, and then she is sputtering and drowning in the seawater. Olivia apologizes to Vincent, explaining that she was thinking of Vincent, of that time on the yacht with Jonathan, and suddenly she was standing beside her. Vincent describes the two of them as existing “in some in-between space.”
The narrative explores the common trope that a person’s life flashes before their eyes when they die. That Olivia could indirectly cause Vincent’s death from beyond the grave suggests that people have the ability to irreparably alter the course of other people’s lives. It asks the reader to imagine a world in which every mistake a person makes has consequences, even if such consequences are unintended.
Themes
Complicity and Interconnectedness Theme Icon
Guilt and Responsibility  Theme Icon
Vincent’s consciousness flashes back to her teenage graffiti: “sweep me up.” Next, she flashes to the moment when Geoffrey kissed her on the C deck and told her he loved her. She repeated the words back and meant them for the first time. Vincent moves forward in time, to the moment when Geoffrey leaves the ship at the Port of Rotterdam, despite Mendoza’s warning that it makes him look guilty. He looks “so alone and so bereft,” and Vincent wants to comfort him but cannot. 
Vincent unintentionally ends up hurting Geoffrey in a way that parallels how her mother’s death hurt her. Vincent spent her life haunted by the uncertainty of whether her mother’s death was an accident or a suicide, and it’s plausible that Geoffrey will suffer the same uncertainty after Vincent’s death.
Themes
Complicity and Interconnectedness Theme Icon
Guilt and Responsibility  Theme Icon
Now, Vincent is in a hotel in Dubai. She sees Jonathan in the lobby and greets him. She tells him she’s “just visiting,” but doesn’t say from where, as she’s distracted by the sight of Faisal and Yvette Bertolli walking past the window. Vincent’s consciousness flashes much further into the future; she sees Paul sitting in the doorway in Edinburgh. Next, she sees Mirella sitting alone in a loft somewhere, but Mirella doesn’t see her.
Vincent’s final interaction with Alkaitis gives the couple some closure, though most things remain unsaid between them. That Vincent’s spirit visits Mirella one last time shows that Vincent still feels a nagging guilt over the role her complicity in Alkaitis’s fraud played in Faisal’s suicide. Though Vincent previously wanted to tell Mirella she knew nothing of Alkaitis’s fraud, it’s clear this isn’t entirely true—that, perhaps, she had doubts about Alkaitis but chose to ignore them.
Themes
Complicity and Interconnectedness Theme Icon
Guilt and Responsibility  Theme Icon
Fraud and Constructed Identity  Theme Icon
Greed, Delusion, and Self Interest  Theme Icon
Regret and Disillusionment  Theme Icon
Now, Vincent’s at Le Veau d’Or with Jonathan as he speaks to Lenny Xavier, one of her least favorite investors. Lenny makes his covert remark about the scheme of Jonathan’s company, and Vincent recognizes that she’d known then that something was off with Jonathan’s business, but that she’d “chosen not to understand.”
Vincent finally comes to terms with the fact that she was more complicit in Alkaitis’s scheme than she’d allowed herself to believe—that she’d merely “chosen not to understand” because the comfortable life she’d made with Jonathan was too good to give up.
Themes
Complicity and Interconnectedness Theme Icon
Guilt and Responsibility  Theme Icon
Fraud and Constructed Identity  Theme Icon
Greed, Delusion, and Self Interest  Theme Icon
Vincent visits Paul once more, only this time he’s in the desert, standing outside smoking a cigarette. When he sees her he drops his cigarette, asking if she’s “really there.” Vincent tells him that she “[doesn’t] know how to answer either of those questions.” Paul tells her he was just speaking about her with his counselor. He looks like he’s been crying. He apologizes to her for everything, but Vincent comforts him, explaining that she “was a thief too,” that they “both got corrupted.” Paul doesn’t understand Vincent’s words, and suddenly she wants to be someplace else, so she journeys back to Caiette.
When Vincent says she and Paul “both got corrupted,” she’s referring to the way greed and self-preservation encourage people to act selfishly, often at the expense of others. In truth, they’ve both behaved opportunistically throughout their lives. Paul stole Vincent’s video recordings to elevate his music career. Vincent indirectly stole from Alkaitis’s investors when she chose to ignore her suspicions about the Ponzi scheme. Paul and Vincent make peace with each other in this scene, but there’s a tragic element to the fact that they weren’t able to repair their relationship during Vincent’s lifetime. This underscores the novel’s theme of regret and disillusionment.
Themes
Complicity and Interconnectedness Theme Icon
Guilt and Responsibility  Theme Icon
Fraud and Constructed Identity  Theme Icon
Greed, Delusion, and Self Interest  Theme Icon
Regret and Disillusionment  Theme Icon
Quotes
Now, Vincent is on a beach in Caiette. Her mother sits on a log in the distance as though she is waiting. She’s 36 years old. In this moment, Vincent knows her mother’s death was an accident: “of course it was, she would never have left me on purpose. She has waited so long for me. She was always here. This was always home.” Vincent calls her mother’s name, “and [her mother] looks up in amazement.”
In the complete isolation and mental clarity death affords her, Vincent finally makes peace with her mother’s death, realizing that her mother “never would have left [her] on purpose.” With this realization, Vincent lays to rest the uncertainty that has haunted her for her entire life. When Vincent says, “this was always home,” she implies that the truth about her mother had always existed, but Vincent had been too caught up in the struggles and suffering of daily life to access it. That Vincent is only able to discover the truth about her mother in death suggests that uncertainty is an inevitable part of life.
Themes
Guilt and Responsibility  Theme Icon
Alienation and Self-Knowledge  Theme Icon
Regret and Disillusionment  Theme Icon