At this point, the night has turned upside down. Rather than a night of revelry, it has turned into an evening of horror. Meanwhile, whereas Caroline and Mr. Morley were supposed to fall in love, they are now bitter enemies. Whether Caroline’s claims about Gyp’s passivity should be taken as the truth is unclear. On the one hand, he typically seems like a happy-go-lucky dog. On the other hand, the Ayerses rarely have company, especially children, and it is possible that Gyp might not be as kind to those he is not familiar with.