The Nightingale

by

Kristin Hannah

The Nightingale: Chapter 15 Summary & Analysis

Summary
Analysis
It’s 1941, and Isabelle is on her way to Paris. Vianne, meanwhile, is alone with Sophie and Beck. One day, Beck brings Vianne a fish he caught and presents it to her as a gift. Vianne is unsure whether she should take it. She doesn’t want to owe Beck another favor. Seeing that Vianne is hesitant, Beck assures her that he got the fish by legitimate means. Eventually, Vianne accepts the fish and begins prepping it for dinner.
Vianne has to reevaluate what she thinks about Beck constantly. Although she wants to like and appreciate him, she can’t get over the incident with the list, and she doesn’t want to have to perform more uncomfortable favors for Beck in the future.
Themes
Morality and Impossible Choices Theme Icon
When Vianne finishes cooking, she brings the fish to the table and sees that Beck is sitting in the same chair that Antoine always used. When Beck sees that the fish is ready, he offers Vianne an expensive bottle of wine, which she accepts. As Sophie, Beck, and Vianne eat together, Vianne notices that Beck is talking more than normal. She realizes that this might be because Isabelle is gone so there is less tension in the house.
Again, Beck is seemingly filling Antoine’s role, which Vianne notices but does not remark upon. Without Isabelle, the Mauriacs and Beck almost behave like a typical, happy family.
Themes
Gender Roles Theme Icon
Meanwhile, Isabelle arrives in Paris with her bicycle. When she gets off the train, she bikes to Julien Rossignol’s store. Isabelle reaches the store and finds it in chaos; it looks like it is closed down and has not been tended to as of late. Concerned, Isabelle heads to her father’s apartment, only to find out that he is not there, either. Not knowing where else to go, Isabelle makes herself comfortable and decides to wait for her father to come home. While she waits, she thinks about the best way to convince Julien to let her stay.
Julien’s life has radically changed since Isabelle went away. It seems he is no longer tending to the store he once loved, and this underscores the devastating effects of war. 
Themes
Morality and Impossible Choices Theme Icon
Later, Julien Rossignol comes home and sees Isabelle. Immediately, he is angry. When Isabelle tells him that she would like to live with him, Julien tells her that she shouldn’t have left Vianne and Sophie alone with a Nazi. He tells Isabelle that she must go back to Carriveau immediately. However, Isabelle refuses. She tells Julien that Paris is her home, and she plans to live there no matter what he says. 
Julien’s response is exactly what Isabelle expected. But Isabelle doesn’t tell her father the truth and instead lets him think poorly of her, just like she did with Vianne. Isabelle’s behavior here shows that she is maturing; she has more discretion and no longer says whatever is on her mind.
Themes
Morality and Impossible Choices Theme Icon
Get the entire The Nightingale LitChart as a printable PDF.
The Nightingale PDF
The conversation turns to Julien Rossignol’s current job. Since he is not running the bookstore anymore, Isabelle wants to know what he is doing. Julien tells Isabelle that he is working for the Germans at the Hotel de Crillon. This news deeply angers Isabelle. In her eyes, yet another one of her family members is aiding and abetting the Nazis. She tells Julien that he is cowardly. In response, Julien tells her that she cannot judge him because she doesn’t know the full details of his past. Additionally, he says that if Isabelle wants to stay in Paris, then she must follow all of his rules. Also, she must find a job. Although she is disappointed with her father, Isabelle promises to do what he says.
As it turns out, Isabelle left one Nazi-supporting household for another. She is deeply ashamed of her family and cannot understand why they do not resist authority as she does. It’s especially hard for her to accept this behavior from Julien, who fought the Germans in World War I. In Isabelle’s mind, he is supporting the people who crushed his spirit and destroyed their family. Nonetheless, Isabelle knows that she has to make it work with her father; she has no other choice.
Themes
Morality and Impossible Choices Theme Icon
After speaking with Julien Rossignol, Isabelle goes and looks at her old room. Everything is just as she left it, although it clearly hasn’t been tended to in a while. Next door, Isabelle can hear Julien drinking and swearing. Isabelle knows that Julien is not happy that she is here, but she is proud of herself for standing her ground. While listening to her father next door, Isabelle reflects on her relationship him. She feels as though he resents her no matter what she does.
Julien’s demons have not gone away; he still drinks and has a foul temper. However, Isabelle has changed; she’s matured, and for the first time, she does not let her father stand in the way of what she wants to do. Unfortunately, their relationship remains broken.
Themes
Morality and Impossible Choices Theme Icon
Moments later, Julien Rossignol knocks on Isabelle’s door and tells her he is leaving. While he is gone, he wants her to pick up his daily rations. Isabelle agrees to do as Julien says. After Julien leaves, Isabelle realizes that she needs to complete the mission she was sent to Paris to do. She gets dressed and then leaves with a handbag, which contains the secret message.
Julien and Vianne treat Isabelle the same way; she is their errand girl who must stay out of trouble. Isabelle is happy to perform this role, however, because it gets her out of the house where she can help the French rebellion. 
Themes
Morality and Impossible Choices Theme Icon
Next, Isabelle walks to the agreed-upon meeting place. Isabelle is nervous; she knows that any mistake could result in her death. She sits down on a bench, just as she was told to do. Right after she sits down, a woman comes and sits down next to her. Isabelle, says, “Do you think I’ll need an umbrella today?” This phrase is a secret code, which the woman sitting next to Isabelle responds to correctly. Isabelle realizes that she has found the right woman, so she attempts to give her the secret message. However, the woman stops her and says that they should go to a café before anything is exchanged.
This is the most dangerous mission Isabelle has taken on yet, and she is inexperienced. However, she seems to have identified the right woman, and the fact that the conversation takes place in code gives her further protection. Isabelle slips up by trying to hand off the secret message publicly. However, her interlocuter ensures that doesn’t happen as yet another security measure.
Themes
Morality and Impossible Choices Theme Icon
Isabelle and her new colleague get up and go to a nearby café. There, Isabelle gives the woman the secret message. The woman thanks Isabelle and warns her that she must be wary of French people who are working for the Germans. She tells Isabelle that she shouldn’t trust anyone, even her own father. Additionally, she informs Isabelle that the other members of the resistance group want to meet her. She gives her a place and a time when that can happen. Satisfied with her success, Isabelle gets up and leaves the café. She feels like she is doing something meaningful to fight back against the Nazis.
Yet again, Isabelle is warned not to trust anyone. Indeed, throughout World War II, many French citizens and members of law enforcement worked for the Germans—it was the only way to survive for some people.
Themes
Morality and Impossible Choices Theme Icon