Previous
Chapter 24
Themes
Key
LitCharts assigns a color and icon to each theme in The Pickwick Papers, which you can use to track the themes throughout the work.
Male Friendship
Predatory Social Institutions
Social Class and Inequality
Marriage and Courtship
Generosity and Forgiveness
Summary
Analysis
As Pickwick and his companions are taken to the magistrate, Sam cannot help but voice his frustration, offering bold insults to Grummer and challenging the entire group of officers. His irritation gives way to curiosity when they arrive at the courtyard where he previously encountered Trotter. His surprise only grows when the group halts at the very gate from which Trotter emerged, and Grummer pulls the bell to summon entry.
Sam’s insults toward the officers aren’t just for comedic effect—they also signal how Sam operates outside the usual social hierarchies. He respects Pickwick but refuses to grant the same deference to figures like Grummer, showing that loyalty to individual people matters more to him than respecting social or legal institutions.
Themes
Inside, they are led up the steps and are ushered into the presence of Nupkins, the magistrate. Nupkins, sitting behind an enormous table looks imposing as he scrutinizes the group. Grummer identifies Pickwick as the lead prisoner, prompting Sam to step forward with irreverent charm and speak on the behalf of the Pickwickians. Sam introduces his companions and suggests that Nupkins punish his officers because of how poorly they have treated the Pickwickians.
The contrast between Nupkins’s formal authority and Sam’s playful boldness makes this encounter feel like a battle of opposites: bureaucracy versus wit, power versus personality. While Nupkins relies on intimidation, Sam uses humor to disrupt the expected power dynamic. Sam’s suggestion that the officers should be punished reflects his sense of fairness—justice, in his view, should cut both ways.
Themes
Nupkins demands to know who Sam is, and Grummer identifies him as a dangerous character who tried to rescue the prisoners. Sam’s cheeky responses infuriate the magistrate, who accuses him of being a vagabond. The situation escalates as Nupkins accuses one of the special constables of being drunk, despite the man’s protests of sobriety. This leads to a farcical scene in which Nupkins threatens to commit the special constable, only to relent when advised against it.
This chaotic exchange lays bare the absurdity of authority when it becomes more focused on appearances than practical solutions. Nupkins is clearly out of his depth, grasping at control but getting tangled in petty accusations. Dickens injects humor here to highlight the instability of systems built on status alone, showing that those in power often act out of insecurity rather than competence.
Themes
Once the exaggerated formalities are completed, and after a confusing testimony from Grummer, Nupkins finally delivers his judgment. He fines Sam and the others for their involvement in the alleged assault. Pickwick interrupts Nupkins’s judgment, insisting on his right to be heard. He asks Nupkins if they can speak in private so that he can explain why he has come to Ipswich. After a tense exchange, Pickwick is granted permission to speak to Nupkins in private. As such, Pickwick reveals his true purpose: to expose Jingle as a fraud and an impostor. Sam backs him up, revealing that Trotter is also complicit in the scheme.
Pickwick’s interruption demonstrates his growing frustration with the farcical nature of the proceedings—he knows that reason won’t cut through without persistence. His insistence on privacy shows his sensitivity to the social stakes at play. By handling the matter discreetly, Pickwick protects both Nupkins’s reputation and his own dignity. This revelation shifts the balance of power, bringing the truth to light and forcing Nupkins to confront his own gullibility.
Themes
Get the entire The Pickwick Papers LitChart as a printable PDF.
The revelation stuns Nupkins, who realizes that the charming “Captain Fitz-Marshall” (Jingle), a regular guest of his family, is in fact a conman. Concerned about the social repercussions Nupkins and his family experience a crisis of reputation. Mrs. Nupkins laments the disgrace, placing much of the blame on Mr. Nupkins for introducing her to Jingle. After some debate, Mrs. Nupkins agrees that it would be best to quietly handle the matter without public exposure. The Nupkins family invites Pickwick and his friends to dinner, along with Jingle. Before the dinner, Sam is sent downstairs to spend time with the kitchen staff. Sam quickly charms the ladies, and during their lively conversation, Trotter unexpectedly appears. Recognizing Sam, he tries to back out, but Sam refuses to let him leave.
Nupkins’s shock at Jingle’s deception is less about the fraud itself and more about the social embarrassment it brings. For the Nupkins family, maintaining appearances takes priority over holding Jingle accountable—an attitude that reflects the Victorian obsession with reputation. Their decision to resolve the issue privately highlights how power operates behind closed doors, shielding the elite from public shame. Meanwhile, the shift to the kitchen offers a glimpse into a different social world—one that’s freer and more grounded than the formal dinner upstairs.
Themes
Sam mocks Trotter for his misdeeds, and one cook attacks Trotter in a fit of rage, pulling out handfuls of his hair because Trotter spread rumors that they were going to get married. Before the situation escalates further, a bell summons them upstairs. In the drawing room, Pickwick confronts Jingle while the Nupkins family looks on in horror. Jingle remains unperturbed, even as Pickwick delivers a scathing rebuke of his character. In response, Jingle calmly dismisses the accusations with his usual nonchalance and then makes a quick exit with Trotter.
Trotter’s attempt to flee suggests that deceitful characters like him thrive only when they’re not confronted. Sam’s refusal to let Trotter leave shows his determination to see justice done, even if it means handling matters informally. Meanwhile, Jingle’s indifference to Pickwick’s confrontation reinforces his shameless nature; he knows that accusations alone won’t stop him, so he simply leaves.
Themes
With the confrontation over, Pickwick and his friends prepare to leave. Nupkins thanks Pickwick for warning him about Jingle, whom he plans to steer clear of from now on. As Sam retrieves his hat from the kitchen, he shares a flirtatious moment with Mary, a housemaid, who helps him find it in an awkwardly small corner. The two share a kiss, marking the beginning of Sam’s first romance.
The brief romance between Sam and Mary offers a sweet, human moment amid all the chaos. This encounter signals a new chapter for Sam, whose flirtation with Mary expands his character beyond his role as Pickwick’s loyal servant. Their kiss is understated but meaningful, as it provides them with a moment where their class status—which is their defining trait—fades into the background.
Themes
