The Pickwick Papers

by

Charles Dickens

The Pickwick Papers: Chapter 47 Summary & Analysis

Summary
Analysis
Benjamin and Bob sit in Bob’s surgery, eating and discussing Bob’s future as a doctor. Bob complains that while he has plenty of patients, most of them are poor, so his income remains small. Benjamin, seeing Bob’s frustration, suggests that he should marry Arabella, who has a thousand pounds waiting for her upon marriage or when she comes of age. He urges Bob to propose immediately, but Bob points out that Arabella doesn’t like him. Benjamin dismisses this, claiming she doesn’t know her own mind. Once again, he threatens violence against any man who might have stolen her affections. Bob agrees, promising to act if such a man exists.
Benjamin and Bob’s conversation points to the transactional mindset that Benjamin applies to relationships, as he views Arabella’s marriage as a solution to Bob’s financial problems. The way Benjamin dismisses Arabella’s preferences indicates a sense of entitlement and disregard for her autonomy, believing he knows what’s best for her. Although Benjamin speaks as if he is acting honorably, really his behavior is deeply selfish, not to mention impractical.
Themes
Marriage and Courtship Theme Icon
Quotes
Meanwhile, a carriage driven by a man named Martin arrives at Bob’s house, carrying Arabella’s aunt. Arabella’s aunt nervously asks Martin to stay by her side, then she enters the house, where Ben and Bob greet her warmly. After asking for a private moment with Bob, she confesses that Arabella has left home and gotten married. Bob, stunned, runs to tell Benjamin. Benjamin, who is half-asleep and only half understands what Bob says, reacts by attacking Martin. Martin remains calm and knocks Benjamin down just as Pickwick and Sam arrive. Sam watches the chaos with amusement. Pickwick, however, intervenes and separates the men. Upset, Benjamin, grabs Pickwick’s hand and tells him that Arabella is married.
Benjamin’s immediate reaction to the news—attacking Martin before he even understands the situation—illustrates his impulsiveness and inability to control his emotions. The fight between Benjamin and Martin makes for another farcical situation, much to Sam’s amusement. Pickwick’s intervention, as usual, brings a sense of order, though Benjamin’s emotional outburst suggests that the news of Arabella’s marriage strikes a deep blow to his ego.
Themes
Marriage and Courtship Theme Icon
As Benjamin calms down, Sam notices that Arabella’s aunt fainted during the commotion. Bob and Benjamin help revive her while Pickwick explains that Arabella has married Winkle. Benjamin and Bob react angrily, with Bob vowing to challenge Winkle to a duel. The aunt, equally outraged, accuses Sam of helping Arabella sneak away, but Sam defends himself, insisting he only followed orders. Pickwick calms everyone down and explains that Arabella’s marriage was her choice, which he urges Benjamin to respect. Arabella’s aunt steps in and says that what’s done is done, suggesting that Benjamin should move on and accept Arabella’s decision. Benjamin, still upset, swears he’ll never forgive his sister, though Arabella’s aunt suggests that he will with time.
Benjamin’s anger and Bob’s desire for a duel suggest that their pride is wounded, as both view Arabella’s marriage as a betrayal of their plans. Pickwick’s calm explanation encourages Benjamin to accept what he cannot change, an attitude that Benjamin’s aunt is quick to adopt. Even though Benjamin does not want to accept that his sister refuses to marry Bob, his suggestion that he will never forgive her seems hyperbolic as soon as it comes out of his mouth. By the time Pickwick gets done talking with him, Benjamin already seems to start accepting what has happened.
Themes
Male Friendship Theme Icon
Marriage and Courtship Theme Icon
Generosity and Forgiveness Theme Icon
Bob and Pickwick retreat to another room, where Bob drinks himself into a more cheerful mood. Returning to the group, he apologizes for his earlier behavior and proposes a toast to Arabella and Winkle’s happiness. Though reluctant, Benjamin joins in the toast, and the mood lightens. Pickwick then prepares to leave. Before he goes, he makes plans for Benjamin to accompany him on his trip to see Winkle Sr. the next morning. Afterward, Pickwick and Sam leave and head for the Bush Inn. At the inn, Pickwick runs into the same bagman that he met back in Eatanswill. The bagman offers to tell Pickwick another story about Tom Smart, and Pickwick excitedly agrees to listen.
Bob’s willingness to toast Arabella’s happiness signals a reluctant acceptance, though it feels more like a moment of surrender than genuine goodwill. Benjamin’s participation, even with reluctance, is a first step toward reconciliation. As always, alcohol helps smooth the process, as Bob and Benjamin begin to forget their sorrows and enjoy their company.
Themes
Male Friendship Theme Icon
Marriage and Courtship Theme Icon
Get the entire The Pickwick Papers LitChart as a printable PDF.
The Pickwick Papers PDF