Previous
Part 1, Chapter 9
Themes
Key
LitCharts assigns a color and icon to each theme in The Silent Patient, which you can use to track the themes throughout the work.
Empathy, Identification, and Boundaries
Tragedy and Destiny
Honesty vs. Deception
Childhood Trauma
Silence vs. “The Talking Cure”
Summary
Analysis
Theo goes to meet Kathy at a café with her friends; all of them, Kathy included, are actresses. When Theo shows up, Kathy is telling the story of how they met: both of them were seeing other people at the time, and their respective partners had organized a double date. Despite this obstacle, however, Kathy confesses that she and Theo fell in “love at first sight.” Theo privately remembers how much lust he felt for Kathy that first night.
Structurally, there is something interesting about the way Kathy is introduced: as soon as Yuri mentions her, Theo goes to meet her, almost as if she has been willed into presence by Yuri’s comment. Also, the first two things readers learn about Kathy suggest that she is not always honest: she is an actress by trade, and she is unfaithful in her personal life.
Themes
Theo’s girlfriend at the time had gone home, upset that Theo was unwilling to join her; Kathy and her boyfriend had had a fight, and he had left in a huff. Soon enough, Theo and Kathy were drinking and flirting. Kathy kept calling herself crazy, but Theo feels that she is “the least crazy person [he has] ever known.” He is consistently impressed by her confidence and vitality.
Unlike Alicia, with whom Theo feels intense similarity, Kathy is attractive because she is everything Theo is not. And while Alicia is known for her silence, it is clear even in these first moments that Kathy is endlessly chatty, filling her life and Theo’s with sound.
Themes
That night, Kathy and Theo made love for hours on end. Kathy scoffed that she had already forgotten the man she’d come to the bar with. The next morning, Theo called his then-girlfriend to end things—though it was a brutal call, he felt it was “the only honest action to take.”
As he has done several times already, Theo reminds readers that he prioritizes “honest[y]” above almost everything else; rather than betray his then-girlfriend, he comes clean to her, telling her the painful truth that he has fallen for someone else.
Themes
On their first date, Kathy had brought Theo to the sweltering, tropical greenhouses at Kew Gardens. In the warm light, Theo felt as if he was waking up for the first time: Kathy “was my invitation to life,” he sighs. Kathy made Theo feel brave and virile; they had sex all the time, but he also felt that this was his first true experience of love.
Whereas Theo’s childhood made him seek out death, Kathy seems to break him out of his personal history, as he craves “life” for the first time. Moreover, Kathy’s association with warmth—both metaphorical and literal—presents a completely opposite kind of happiness than the snowy childhood memory Theo cherishes.
Themes
Get the entire The Silent Patient LitChart as a printable PDF.
That December, Kathy moved in with Theo, and soon after he proposed marriage to her. After Kathy said yes, Theo brought her to Surrey, to meet his parents for the first time. His father was cold and hostile, insulting Theo and disappearing for large swaths of time; his mother was depressed and unsteady on her feet. Theo was dismayed, but as they left, Kathy hugged him and whispered, “I understand it all. I love you so much more now.”
Actors, like psychotherapists, are deeply concerned with understanding why humans behave in certain ways. Kathy’s claim that she “understand[s] it all” thus suggests that despite their differences, she and Theo have one big thing in common: a belief that childhood experiences are essential to understanding grown-up people.
Themes
The pair got married in April, without Theo’s parents. At the altar, Theo privately thanked God for bringing Kathy into his life—here was his chance to feel the love he had never felt from his parents. In the present, he reflects on the difference between Kathy (“light, warmth, color, and laughter”) and Alicia (“depth,” “darkness,” “sadness,” “silence”).
Now, the implicit distinction between Alicia and Kathy is made explicit. But again, why does Theo associate these two women in his mind—and why does the book begin not with his wife, who should be the central woman in his life, but with his patient?
Themes
