Previous
Part 5, Chapter 1
Themes
Key
LitCharts assigns a color and icon to each theme in The Silent Patient, which you can use to track the themes throughout the work.
Empathy, Identification, and Boundaries
Tragedy and Destiny
Honesty vs. Deception
Childhood Trauma
Silence vs. “The Talking Cure”
Summary
Analysis
On Stephanie’s orders, Indira and Theo are cleaning out Alicia’s room at the Grove; it is unlikely she will ever wake up. Theo sorts through Alicia’s belongings, hoping to clear away any incriminating evidence. He also notices some sketches, quick and brilliant. One of the sketches is of Indira. Theo admires the picture of Indira, reflecting how much he hates the painting Alicia did of the two of them in a burning building.
Once again, Alicia uses her painting to communicate the feelings she does not want to give voice to. By creating such a flattering portrait of Indira, then, Alicia shows that there was one therapist she actually did think fondly of. It is probably not a coincidence that, given how much men dismissed Alicia, she really only trusted the one woman in the clinic.
Themes
Theo makes it clear that he did not intend for Alicia to kill Gabriel; he merely wanted to “awaken” her to the reality of her marriage, as he had been “awakened.” He had been unaware of Alicia’s personal history when he pointed the gun at Gabriel. So after the murder, Theo became obsessed with Alicia—he wanted to know her past, to understand why she had resorted to such violence. And what better way to learn than through a job at the Grove?
Now that readers know the full truth, Theo tries to justify his actions—but rather than making himself seem empathetic, he ultimately reveals his obsession with Alicia to be more self-involved (more “narcissistic”) than anyone could have imagined.
Themes
In fact, Theo really did believe that he was the only one who “knew how to help her.” And in Cambridge, he had understood the psychological link between Vernon Rose’s behavior and Alicia’s rage at Gabriel. But once Theo realized Alicia knew his true identity, his life and career were in jeopardy. So he injected Alicia with morphine (the “hardest thing” he had ever done), and blamed Christian for the whole thing.
The timelines, deliberately twisted for much of the book, have been straightened out. At last, readers can see that Theo has stayed with Alicia for six full years following her betrayal; in other words, he has flouted Ruth’s advice completely. Instead, Theo has tried to use Alicia to make sense of his relationship with Kathy, seeking professional validation where he no longer finds romantic comfort.
Themes
Indira has finished packing up the room. Frantically, Theo realizes that he has been distracted and has failed to find the diary. Without it, there is no evidence to convict Christian—but Theo has no clue where it is, no matter how hard he searches.
As the book hurtles towards its final, tragic end, Michaelides injects a great deal of tragic irony into the plot: readers know that Alicia has condemned Theo in her diary, but Theo is not yet clued into that fact.
Themes
Get the entire The Silent Patient LitChart as a printable PDF.
