Fay Keenan is the mother of Sky and daughter of Marjorie and Don. Peter Dyson’s childhood lover, Fay is a willful, difficult, and often mean-spirited personality. While not a bad person, she is driven by her desires and often acts impulsively and destructively, hurting both herself and the people around her. She is a recovering heroin addict and has left her daughter to be raised primarily by her parents. Fay attempts to renew her sexual relationship with Dyson, begging him to have sex with her when he refuses. She attempts to blackmail him, threatening to reveal to her religious parents that she aborted her and Dyson’s child as a teenager and implying that this is the source of her struggles with addiction. When Dyson still refuses to have sex with her, she leaves without another word.