Prior to this, Autumn’s thoughts have characterized her brother positively, emphasizing the way he cares for her. However, this disturbing moment of violence seriously undermines her stated opinion on her brother. It’s notable that she doesn’t actually say how this betrayal made her feel; even though she intellectually understands what happened, she’s not able to emotionally process her brother’s abuse. Autumn’s memories also make it clearer than ever that Tyler’s violent behavior has been building over time.