What Men Live By

by

Leo Tolstoy

Bread Symbol Analysis

Bread Symbol Icon

Bread, which characters share with one another throughout the story, symbolizes the reciprocal nature of generosity. Matryona spends the beginning of the story deliberating about whether to bake her family another loaf of bread or try to make the one they have last. So, when Semyon comes home with Mikhail and suggests that they feed him dinner, Matryona is incensed—she doesn’t believe they can afford to part with any food given that they have so little. But when Semyon asks if there is “no love of God within [her],” Matryona softens and shares their last piece of bread with Mikhail. In the Bible, communally breaking bread is an act of fellowship and represents sharing in God’s divine love, so Matryona’s decision to break bread with Mikhail despite her family’s hunger represents a symbolic shift within her from selfishness and spiritual corruption to selflessness and godliness.

Though Matryona frets about their family going hungry after this and resentfully wonders why people never help them in return, the next day, a neighbor shares some bread with them. The fact that Matryona’s selfless gesture toward Mikhail is seemingly rewarded with another selfless gesture is an example of the old adage that “God helps those who help themselves”—or, in this case, God helps those who help other people. In other words, the sharing of bread represents the idea that those who extend love and generosity to others are emulating the “love of God,” and that they will be rewarded in the long term for this, even if they go without in the short term.

Bread Quotes in What Men Live By

The What Men Live By quotes below all refer to the symbol of Bread. For each quote, you can also see the other characters and themes related to it (each theme is indicated by its own dot and icon, like this one:
Mystery Theme Icon
).
Chapter 4 Quotes

‘We’re always giving, but why does nobody ever give us anything?’

Related Characters: Matryona (speaker), Semyon, Mikhail
Related Symbols: Bread
Page Number: 132
Explanation and Analysis:
Chapter 10 Quotes

“‘Children cannot live without a father or mother,’ she pleaded. So I did not take that woman’s soul.”

Related Characters: Mikhail (speaker), The Gentleman, Marya
Related Symbols: Bread
Page Number: 141
Explanation and Analysis:
Get the entire What Men Live By LitChart as a printable PDF.
What Men Live By PDF

Bread Symbol Timeline in What Men Live By

The timeline below shows where the symbol Bread appears in What Men Live By. The colored dots and icons indicate which themes are associated with that appearance.
Chapter 3
Rationality vs. Generosity Theme Icon
...sits at the kitchen table trying to decide whether she should bake another loaf of bread or try to make the final slice of the old loaf last for a few... (full context)
Chapter 4
Mystery Theme Icon
Rationality vs. Generosity Theme Icon
Selfless Love Theme Icon
...feels her anger leave her. She gets out dinner, kvass, and the last slice of bread. Then Matryona, Semyon, and the stranger divide the food between them and eat together at... (full context)
Rationality vs. Generosity Theme Icon
Selfless Love Theme Icon
...first, she frets about the fact that she gave the stranger their last piece of bread, and now they won’t have anything to feed their children the next day. But when... (full context)
Chapter 5
Mystery Theme Icon
Rationality vs. Generosity Theme Icon
The next morning, while Matryona is borrowing bread from a neighbor, Semyon asks the stranger what kind of work he can do. The... (full context)