A girl whom Lindsay bullied in fourth grade. Lindsay nearly ruined Vicky’s reputation forever by calling her fat. Though Vicky overcame the bullying and now is on the fridges of Lindsay and Sam’s social circle, no one has ever forgotten Lindsay’s cruel words about her. As Sam, Lindsay, Elody, and Ally crash their car on the night of Cupid Day, Sam finds herself shocked by the fact that she doesn’t see her life flash before her eyes in the moments before death, but rather sees only Vicky Hallinan’s miserable face on the day that Lindsay first bullied her publicly.