Breakfast at Tiffany’s

by

Truman Capote

Breakfast at Tiffany’s Summary & Analysis

Summary
Analysis
The unnamed narrator remembers his first New York City apartment, a brownstone he lived in during the early 1940s. It wasn’t a particularly nice apartment, but it made him feel like he had the space he needed to become a true writer, which is what he was primarily focused on during the time. And yet, despite his trade, he never considered writing about his neighbor, a woman named Holly Golightly. In fact, he might never have written about her if it hadn’t been for Joe Bell, the owner of a bar that the narrator and Holly used to frequent. Years after the narrator last saw Holly, Joe Bell calls him and tells him to come to the bar, and the narrator senses right away that Joe must have news about Holly. After all, their friendship with Holly is the only thing they’ve ever had in common.
At the very outset of Breakfast at Tiffany’s, Capote’s respective interests in privacy, wealth, and independence emerge, as the narrator notes that his apartment—though unglamorous and cheap—gave him a sense of artistic and intellectual freedom when he first moved to New York. To that end, having a space to himself allows him to feel like a legitimate writer, somebody who will be able to focus on his craft without any interruptions. It doesn’t matter to him that he doesn’t have a fancy, expensive apartment. All that matters, it seems, is that he has a place to grow into himself—a place he belongs. 
Themes
Female Independence and Freedom Theme Icon
Wealth, Happiness, and Belonging Theme Icon
Privacy and Obsession Theme Icon
Joe Bell makes the narrator a strong drink and tells him that a photographer named Mr. I. Y. Yunioshi, who used to live in Holly and the narrator’s building, was recently traveling in Africa when he came upon a curious piece of art. Saying this, Joe hands a picture to the narrator. The picture shows an African man holding a woodcarving of a woman’s face, and the narrator admits that it looks exactly like Holly. Joe insists it must be her, and then he tells the narrator what Yunioshi told him—namely, that the woodcarver claimed that a woman and two men came to the village of Tococul on horseback. The men were sick and needed a place to rest, so the group stayed in Tococul until they recovered. During this time, the woman took up with the artist, who made the sculpture of her.
It’s not yet clear why the narrator and Joe Bell are so interested in Holly and her whereabouts. The only thing readers can piece together at this point is that neither of them have been in touch with Holly herself, despite the fact that they’re evidently so concerned about her. This, in turn, hints at the unyielding fascination in Holly’s life that seemingly all of the characters in the novella adopt, demonstrating even at this early stage that people tend to obsess over the details of her private life.
Themes
Female Independence and Freedom Theme Icon
Privacy and Obsession Theme Icon
Finishing his story, Joe Bell notes that he doesn’t believe Holly would really have slept with the woodcarver, though he believes the rest of the story. This, in turn, means Holly must be in Africa. This is the first news both he and the narrator have heard of her in years, though the narrator doesn’t know what to make of it. He says she’s probably never even been to Africa, so Joe asks him where he thinks Holly is. In response, he posits that perhaps Holly is dead or in a “crazy house.” Or, he says, maybe she’s married and living right here in New York. Joe disagrees, maintaining that he would have seen her if she were in New York. After all, he looks for her wherever he goes, thinking only of her when he’s walking the streets.
As the narrator and Joe speculate about Holly’s whereabouts, it becomes increasingly obvious that they are rather obsessed with her. Furthermore, it’s also clear that Holly is a mysterious, elusive figure, the kind of person who attracts attention but manages to confound the people who want to know the details of her life. As a result, people don’t know what to think of Holly, assuming that she must be “crazy” simply because she wants to preserve her independence. At the same time, though, it’s worth noting that readers don’t know what, exactly, has happened to make Holly disappear, thereby endowing her with an even greater sense of mystery that effectively puts readers in the same position as people like the narrator and Joe Bell, who are so eager to find out what has happened to her.
Themes
Female Independence and Freedom Theme Icon
Privacy and Obsession Theme Icon
The narrator says he didn’t know Joe Bell was in love with Holly, and this comment unsettles Joe, who focuses on putting the photograph away. The narrator gets up to leave, but Joe stops him and says he did love Holly but that it didn’t have much to do with a physical sense of lust, though he has indeed fantasized about her in that way. The older he gets, he says, the more he thinks about sex, as if not being able to act on his urges has made it harder to ignore them. Just before the narrator leaves, Joe asks if he believes Holly was in Africa, but the narrator doesn’t answer, instead simply saying that—either way—she’s gone. 
The fact that Joe Bell loves Holly and fantasizes about her in a sexual manner suggests that the obsessions men develop about her often have to do with romance and lust. This, it seems, is largely why Joe is so interested in what has happened to her. However, it’s notable that the narrator himself doesn’t mention any kind of romantic interest in Holly—a sign that their relationship wasn’t defined by attraction or desire.
Themes
Companionship, Love, and Sexuality Theme Icon
Privacy and Obsession Theme Icon
Quotes
Get the entire Breakfast at Tiffany’s LitChart as a printable PDF.
Breakfast at Tiffany’s PDF
The narrator thinks back to when he first became aware of Holly. It’s the early 1940s, and he has been living in the brownstone for a week when he notices she has an interesting card affixed to her mailbox. “Miss Holiday Golightly, Traveling,” it reads, causing the narrator to wonder why she added the word “traveling,” since she’s clearly not away. He knows this because he’s awoken one night by the sound of Mr. Yunioshi yelling at her. Because Holly lost her key, she buzzes his apartment whenever she comes home late and needs to be let in. For this, Yunioshi admonishes her, but she mollifies him by saying that she’ll let him take scandalous pictures of her if he stops complaining, though she evades him when he asks when, exactly, this will happen.
That Holly adds the word “traveling” on her card presents her as the kind of person who doesn’t like to settle down. Although she is living full-time in the brownstone, she presents herself as if she’s always on the move, perhaps because she doesn’t feel like she has truly settled down. On another note, the fact that Holly quells Mr. Yunioshi’s anger by promising to pose nude for him indicates that she knows how to use her sexuality to her own advantage, well aware that she can lord her beauty over men in order to make her own life better.
Themes
Female Independence and Freedom Theme Icon
Wealth, Happiness, and Belonging Theme Icon
Companionship, Love, and Sexuality Theme Icon
The narrator creeps into the hall and peers downstairs to see Holly entering the building with a man, though she quickly says goodbye to him and closes her apartment door before he can get inside. Immediately, the man complains to Holly through the door, reminding her that he paid for her and her friends’ dinner and that he therefore deserves to come in. However, she doesn’t reply, so he angrily prepares to knock down the door, though he drops this idea and turns to leave. Just before he exits the building, Holly pokes her head out and calls after him, saying that the next time a woman asks him for some “powder-room change,” he should give her more than 20 cents.
In this scene, readers see that Holly is quite capable of using her sex appeal to her own benefit. By fraternizing with this man, Holly manages to eat a free meal. More importantly, she doesn’t do anything she doesn’t want to do, ultimately refusing to have sex with the man regardless of what he thinks he “deserves.” In turn, Holly demonstrates her power and independence without making any sacrifices. On another note, it’s worth keeping in mind that the narrator watches this entire scene play out without Holly’s knowledge. This is yet another indication that the people surrounding her are so drawn to her that they obsess over—and encroach upon—her private life. 
Themes
Female Independence and Freedom Theme Icon
Companionship, Love, and Sexuality Theme Icon
Privacy and Obsession Theme Icon
Holly starts buzzing the narrator’s door when she comes home late instead of Mr. Yunioshi’s. Although the narrator lets her in, they have yet to actually meet. One time, he sees her in a fancy restaurant surrounded by a group of men, and though the narrator is excited to be in such an expensive restaurant (a relative of his is paying for his meal), he watches Holly let out a bored yawn, which diminishes his excitement. During this period, he sees a beautiful and lavish birdcage in a storefront window and fantasizes about owning it, though he knows he’ll never be able to afford it because it costs $350.
When the narrator starts letting Holly in at night, he becomes part of her life in a small, fleeting way. Although they have yet to meet, Holly now depends upon the narrator in a certain regard, counting on the fact that he’ll let her into the building. That she never questions whether or not the narrator will do this is a testament to her ability to convince people to do things for her—a skill that seemingly comes quite easily to her, considering that she doesn’t even do anything to persuade the narrator to help her in this way. What’s more, the narrator’s interest in the birdcage shows readers that there are certain monetary limitations that keep him from living the life he’d like to have, though he otherwise seems unbothered by his lack of money.
Themes
Female Independence and Freedom Theme Icon
Wealth, Happiness, and Belonging Theme Icon
Holly remains largely unaware of the narrator, though he’s intensely focused on her life. Becoming something of an “authority” on her comings and goings, he reads scraps of letters from soldiers that Holly rips up and leaves in the trash outside her apartment. He also learns that she reads tabloids and astrology columns, smokes Picayune cigarettes, has a cat, and likes to play the guitar on her fire escape on nice days. When she does this, he listens from above, noting that she enjoys showtunes in addition to several folksy songs that seem incongruous with her otherwise metropolitan persona.  
Simply put, the narrator apparently has no problem violating Holly’s privacy. This is because he has developed something of an obsession, wanting nothing more than to know about her and the way she lives her life. This is perhaps because he himself is a rather lonely man, though it might also have something to do with the fact that Holly is a very magnetic, fascinating person. In all likelihood, the narrator’s fixation on her is a combination of both these things.
Themes
Privacy and Obsession Theme Icon
Quotes
The narrator finally has his first in-person encounter with Holly in September. While reading in bed and drinking whiskey, he senses that he’s being watched. Just then, he realizes Holly is on the fire escape and knocking on his window. After spilling his whiskey, the narrator lets Holly in, and she explains that she brought home a very drunk man she wants to avoid. Normally the man quite charming, she says, but he’s terrible when he’s drunk, so she came upstairs to wait until he falls asleep. She also notes that the narrator looks like her brother, Fred, and decides to call him by that name. Going on, she says that she and her three siblings used to sleep in the same bed, and Fred was the only one who let her snuggle close to him for warmth. When she asks if the narrator thinks she’s crazy, he says no.
The beginning of Holly and the narrator’s official friendship is quite strange, though it completely fits with Holly’s personality and, for that matter, the narrator’s passive nature. Because he’s so interested in her, he hardly minds that she has just climbed through his window in the middle of the night. Instead of getting upset, he’s enthralled by her vibrant spirit, clearly relishing her presence. When the narrator lets Holly choose a name for him, readers see how willing he is to give up his own agency in order to please Holly. He will, it seems, do whatever she wants.
Themes
Companionship, Love, and Sexuality Theme Icon
Privacy and Obsession Theme Icon
Looking around, Holly asks how the narrator could possibly live in such a small, depressing apartment, and he says it’s easy to get used to. In response, she says she never gets used to anything. In fact, she believes that anyone who gets used to something “might as well be dead.” Seeing a stack of books on a desk, Holly asks what the narrator does, and he says that he writes. Hearing this, she says she thought most writers were old, though she doesn’t mind this because older men can be quite appealing. When she asks if the narrator has ever sold a piece of writing, he shyly admits that he hasn’t, so she tells him that she’ll help him with his career.
Holly’s assertion that anyone who gets used to things “might as well be dead” underscores her overall restlessness. For the same reason that she adds the word “traveling” to the card on her mailbox, she abhors the idea of becoming accustomed to a certain way of life. This suggests that Holly wants to be in a state of constant motion, preferring change over consistency.
Themes
Female Independence and Freedom Theme Icon
Wealth, Happiness, and Belonging Theme Icon
Quotes
Holly asks for a drink and then urges the narrator to read her one of his stories. He obliges, but is quite hurt when it’s clear at the end of the story that she didn’t find it particularly interesting. She says she likes lesbians but doesn’t find stories about them interesting—a comment that surprises the narrator, who hadn’t intentionally written a story about lesbian women. Nonetheless, he doesn’t correct her, thinking that it would be even more embarrassing to have to explain the story to her. Moving on, Holly asks the narrator if he knows any lesbians because she wants to find a roommate. According to her, lesbians are “wonderful homemakers” and therefore make the best roommates. 
Homosexuality plays an interesting role in Breakfast at Tiffany’s. Capote never identifies any of the characters as gay, but the topic arises frequently throughout the novella, as if homosexuality is almost constantly on their minds. Of course, Capote himself was gay, and many readers see the unnamed narrator as something of a stand-in for the author. As such, it makes sense that the narrator might write a story about homosexuality, though this argument is flawed, since anybody—regardless of their sexual orientation—might write a story like the narrator’s. All the same, these fleeting mentions of homosexuality are worth tracking as the novella progresses, since sexuality in general is one of the book’s primary concerns, as is the interestingly unromantic but fiercely close nature of Holly and the narrator’s relationship.
Themes
Companionship, Love, and Sexuality Theme Icon
Looking at the clock, Holly can’t believe it’s already 4:30 in the morning. She asks the narrator what day it is, and he tells her that it’s Thursday—an answer that thoroughly disturbs her. When he asks why she dislikes Thursdays, she says she doesn’t, except for the fact that she never remembers when they’re coming. Going on, she explains that she goes every Thursday to Sing Sing prison. By this point, the narrator is too intrigued by Holly to remember that she insulted him by responding negatively to his story.
It’s important to note that the narrator is very sensitive about his writing. In his eyes, Holly can seemingly do no wrong, considering that he has no problem with the fact that she climbed into his apartment unannounced in the middle of the night. However, Holly manages to upset the narrator by insulting his story. And yet, the narrator can’t stay mad at her because he’s too interested in her life to focus on his own feelings. This, in turn, demonstrates just how unable he is to resist Holly’s allure. 
Themes
Companionship, Love, and Sexuality Theme Icon
Privacy and Obsession Theme Icon
Holly says she visits a man named Sally Tomato on Thursdays. She makes the narrator promise not to repeat this story, then says that Sally is a mobster. Apparently, Sally’s lawyer contacted her and offered her $100 per week to visit Sally in prison on Thursdays, saying that Holly would be cheering him up with her company. In response, she told the lawyer that she doesn’t turn “tricks.” She also admits to the narrator that she didn’t think $100 was enough. After all, she says, she can get at least that much from the rich men she goes out with, adding, “any gent with the slightest chic will give you fifty for the girl’s john, and I always ask for cab fare too, that’s another fifty.” Nonetheless, Holly agreed to visit Sally because the lawyer claimed that he once saw her from afar and greatly admired her.
What Holly says about not doing “tricks” (meaning that she’s not a prostitute) is interesting, since she goes on to say that she makes money by going out with rich men. Of course, readers have already seen that she doesn’t sleep with men in whom she has no interest, based on the fact that she turned away a disgruntled man after he walked her home. Still, Holly reveals in this moment that she makes her livelihood by dating men in exchange for money. Whether or not this sometimes includes having sex remains unclear, especially because she uses very specific, decent language when talking about her profession, ultimately implying that the men give her cash simply so she can tip the restroom attendants when she goes to the “powder room.” Either way, it seems that visiting Sally Tomato in prison for $100 per week isn’t all that different from the way she normally makes money, as this too is a form of companionship.
Themes
Female Independence and Freedom Theme Icon
Wealth, Happiness, and Belonging Theme Icon
Companionship, Love, and Sexuality Theme Icon
Continuing her story, Holly says that she poses as Sally Tomato’s niece so that the guards let her visit him. In exchange for $100, she relays coded messages from Sally to the lawyer, Mr. O’Shaughnessy. When the narrator points out that it sounds like she could get in quite a bit of trouble for doing this, she tells him not to worry about her, saying that she has taken care of herself for quite some time. She then gets into the narrator’s bed for a nap as the sun comes up. Lying next to Holly, the narrator can’t sleep, which is why he hears her when she starts crying in her sleeping, saying, “Where are you, Fred?” When Holly awakes, the narrator asks why she was crying, but she only gets up and says that she hates “snoops.” 
Once again, the narrator reveals his fascination with Holly’s private life, this time listening to what she says when she talks in her sleep. And though Holly is quite willing to speak openly about many aspects of her life, she demonstrates in this moment that there are certain things she doesn’t want people to know about—including, it seems, the traumatic memories about her past that are capable of making her cry in her sleep.
Themes
Privacy and Obsession Theme Icon
The following day, the narrator finds a note from Holly thanking him for letting her in. She promises not to pester him again, but he leaves her a return note saying, “Please do.” For the next several days, she doesn’t buzz his apartment, and he wonders what she’s doing, finding that he misses her chaotic presence. The following Wednesday, he leaves her a note saying that the next day is Thursday, and she responds with a note inviting him to come for a drink that evening. When he arrives, she’s nowhere to be seen. Instead, a short, portly man named O.J. Berman opens the door and tells the narrator that Holly’s in the shower. O.J. also tries to discern whether or not the narrator was actually invited, saying that men often arrive unannounced at Holly’s apartment.
Already, the idea of Holly has fully taken hold of the narrator. Even though they’ve only spent one night talking to each other, he can’t stop thinking about her, as if they’ve been close for a long, long time. At this point, though, it’s unclear if this is because they have a special bond or because everyone is naturally drawn to Holly. Indeed, it seems that people flock to her, a notion that O.J. Berman confirms when he says that men are always coming to Holly’s apartment uninvited.
Themes
Companionship, Love, and Sexuality Theme Icon
Privacy and Obsession Theme Icon
O.J. relaxes when the narrator assures him that he lives upstairs. Having settled this, O.J. talks about Holly, saying that she’s a “phony,” though he adds that she’s also “real” because she legitimately believes everything she says. No matter what, he says, it’s impossible to convince Holly of anything. All the same, he likes her just as much as everyone else does. He tells the narrator that he’s a talent agent and that he met Holly on the west coast, where he helped her get rid of her accent, which he couldn’t quite place, since Holly has never told him where she’s from. In fact, O.J. suspects that he’ll never know her personal history. Nonetheless, he helped her drop her accent so she could become a movie star, but when he finally got her an audition for a big role, she unexpectedly abandoned him and moved to New York.
The secrecy surrounding Holly’s past aligns with the idea that she doesn’t want anyone to know her personal history. This clashes with her otherwise open, unguarded persona, thereby intimating that her way of moving through the world is somewhat calculated. Indeed, she presents herself as someone willing to volunteer information about herself, and this attitude helps her keep secrets, since it makes people think they know her when, in reality, they don’t. Furthermore, Holly’s decision to move to New York on a whim aligns with her overall restlessness, as if she can’t quite find a place that gives her a sense of belonging.
Themes
Female Independence and Freedom Theme Icon
Wealth, Happiness, and Belonging Theme Icon
Privacy and Obsession Theme Icon
O.J. tells the narrator that Holly informed him that she left for New York because she didn’t want to be an actress badly enough. A person has to really want that kind of fame to succeed, she upheld, and she simply didn’t have this kind of desire. When O.J. asked what Holly wanted, she told him she didn’t know but that she’d tell him when she found out. Looking around Holly’s apartment now, O.J. disparages her lifestyle, marveling at the idea that she could possibly want this over a life as a movie star. Speaking to the narrator, O.J. bemoans the fact that Holly wants to live off of “tips” and marry Rusty Trawler. In response, the narrator says he doesn’t know Rusty. This, O.J. says, means he must not know Holly very well. 
Not only has it become clear that Holly doesn’t know where she belongs, it’s also evident that she doesn’t quite know what she wants in life. This, however, doesn’t seem to bother her, as she confidently admits that she doesn’t know what she wants. This attitude confounds someone like O.J., who clearly cares first and foremost about wealth. To him, it’s unfathomable that Holly would rather live a bohemian life and make her money by going out with rich men. But this is because he doesn’t understand Holly or know much about her life—nor, for that matter, does the narrator, who is still slowly piecing together an image of the elusive Holly Golightly.
Themes
Female Independence and Freedom Theme Icon
Wealth, Happiness, and Belonging Theme Icon
Companionship, Love, and Sexuality Theme Icon
Privacy and Obsession Theme Icon
Holly sweeps into the room, a towel wrapped around her body. She asks what rumors O.J. is spreading about her, and he admits that he was telling the narrator that she’s crazy. “Fred knows that already,” she says. She then makes fun of O.J. for always acting like a bigshot and flaunting the fact that he knows celebrities. Moving on, she tells him that the narrator is a writer and that he’s written many fantastic stories. Walking out of the room, she asks if O.J. will make him rich, reminding the narrator as she goes that she’s his agent. She also tells them to let in anyone who knocks. And sure enough, there are a great many knocks, as large numbers of men arrive one by one, each of them surprised to see other people there, as if they thought they’d been invited over for a private, intimate evening.
Holly doesn’t take offense at the fact that O.J. is telling the narrator she’s crazy because she’s used to having people talk about her. In fact, it’s likely that she’s comfortable with this kind of gossip because she knows that such talk helps spread intrigue about her, ensuring that everyone in her social circles remains fascinated by her. After all, Holly clearly has many admirers, as evidenced by the many men who come to her apartment hoping to spend time alone with her. 
Themes
Companionship, Love, and Sexuality Theme Icon
Privacy and Obsession Theme Icon
The narrator can’t discern any similarities between the men, except that none of them are particularly young. O.J. Berman, for his part, takes advantage of the arrival of new guests to avoid talking to the narrator about his writing, while the narrator himself pretends to study the books on Holly’s shelves. As he does this, he notices one man in particular who commands the most attention in the room. The man is large and youthful, as if he hasn’t yet lost his baby fat, and he draws attention to himself by making martinis, putting on music, and boisterously introducing people to one another. Holly refers to him as Rusty, asking him to complete various tasks. This, the narrator learns, is Rusty Trawler.
Because the narrator is intrigued by Holly’s life, he’s naturally interested in the men who arrive in large numbers to attend her party. Moreover, he takes a particular interest in Rusty, since O.J. suggested earlier that Holly might marry him. At the same time, though, the narrator also studies the men in the room simply because he has nothing else to do. A shy person who keeps to himself, the narrator would rather watch others than interact with them.
Themes
Companionship, Love, and Sexuality Theme Icon
Privacy and Obsession Theme Icon
As the narrator looks at Holly’s books, he finds a newspaper clipping wedged into one of them. The clipping is about Rusty Trawler, which is how the narrator learns that Rusty became a millionaire orphan in 1908 when his wealthy parents died. His father was killed by an anarchist, and his mother died shortly thereafter of “shock.” Since then, newspapers have kept tabs on him, like when he “caused his godfather-custodian to be arrested on charges of sodomy” and, later, underwent three scandalous divorces. He is also widely known as a Nazi sympathizer. Now, as the narrator reads these things about Rusty, Holly approaches him. The narrator asks about her visit to Sally Tomato, but she instantly changes the subject, making it clear that she doesn’t want to discuss this matter any further.
In many ways, Holly and Rusty are similar. After all, both of them attract quite a bit of attention, as people desperately try to gain insight into their personal lives. Whereas everyone knows the details of Rusty’s past, though, nobody knows about Holly’s personal history. In this regard, then, they are opposites. Forced to lead a life under the public eye, Rusty doesn’t hide anything from other people. Holly, on the other hand, is very secretive, as evidenced by her unwillingness to talk to the narrator in this moment about her most recent visit to Sally Tomato.
Themes
Privacy and Obsession Theme Icon
Holly asks the narrator what he thinks of O.J., going on to say that she doesn’t feel guilty about abandoning him, though she recognizes that she should feel bad. Still, she upholds that she wasn’t suited to be an actress, and though she would like to become rich and famous someday, she’s not yet ready to do this because she doesn’t know what kind of life she wants to lead. She would, she says, like to know how to be herself whenever she’s rich enough to wake up and “have breakfast at Tiffany’s.” As Holly says this, she holds her nameless cat, explaining that she found him walking by the river. Both she and this cat, she says, don’t belong to anyone, including each other.
Once again, Holly confidently admits that she doesn’t know what she wants in life. This time, she adds to this sentiment by saying that fame might interfere with her ability to fully come into herself and settle into her own life. This is a fairly wise thing to say—a notion that suggests that, though Holly doesn’t know what she wants, she’s perfectly aware of what she doesn’t want. In keeping with this, she doesn’t want to do anything that might make it even harder for her to gain a sense of belonging or self-assurance. Looking at this another way, though, one could argue that Holly abandoned O.J. and a movie career because she didn’t want to commit to a certain lifestyle. After all, it’s clear that she appreciates independence and freedom, which is why she emphasizes the fact that she and her cat don’t belong to each other.
Themes
Female Independence and Freedom Theme Icon
Wealth, Happiness, and Belonging Theme Icon
Companionship, Love, and Sexuality Theme Icon
Quotes
Holly tells the narrator that she doesn’t want to truly settle down until she finds a place where she feels a sense of belonging. She then talks about how wonderful she feels whenever she’s at Tiffany’s, though she doesn’t particularly care about diamonds. Still, when she gets what she calls “the mean reds”—which she defines as a kind of angsty sadness—she goes to Tiffany’s because its beauty makes her feel like nothing bad could possibly happen to her. If she could manage to feel this way in real life, she says, she would finally settle down, furnish her apartment, and name her cat. Saying this, Holly adds that perhaps after World War II ends she and Fred will be able to—but she cuts herself off, instantly changing the subject.
Beneath the surface of Holly’s affable charm, she experiences quite a bit of sadness—so much, in fact, that she has given this discontent its own name: “the mean reds.” The fact that she goes to Tiffany’s jewelry store when she feels this way implies that she wants to find a sense of belonging even though she’s unable to. After all, if she were able to settle down, she could finally be the kind of person who shops at Tiffany’s and furnishes her apartment and names her cat—in other words, someone who is invested in and emotionally attached to her own life. Unfortunately for Holly, though, she hasn’t yet found a way to always feel the way she feels at Tiffany’s, so she hasn’t let herself fully commit to her current circumstances. On another note, when Holly abruptly stops talking about what she and her brother will do when the war ends, she once again confirms that she wants to keep certain aspects of her life private.
Themes
Female Independence and Freedom Theme Icon
Wealth, Happiness, and Belonging Theme Icon
Companionship, Love, and Sexuality Theme Icon
Privacy and Obsession Theme Icon
Quotes
Rusty approaches Holly and the narrator and complains that he’s hungry, accusing Holly of not loving him enough to feed him. When Holly tells him to stop complaining, the narrator senses that Rusty loves this kind of attention. Holly then sends him to go make the narrator a drink, and as he turns to do so, he asks if she loves him, but she doesn’t answer the question. When Rusty is gone, the narrator asks whether or not Holly actually does love Rusty, and she responds by saying that she’s well aware of the fact that he’s rich (implying that she would benefit from this if she married him) and insinuates that Rusty is gay and that their so-called relationship has nothing to do with love. 
Once again, homosexuality surfaces in Breakfast at Tiffany’s, though only as an implication. Indeed, Holly only hints that Rusty is gay, thereby inviting readers to speculate alongside everyone else whether or not he’s secretly attracted to men. This kind of speculation is important to note, since it puts readers in a certain headspace, one in which they’re encouraged to interrogate the characters’ sexual orientations. Since the narrator is so taken by Holly but appears to have no romantic feelings for her, the idea that certain characters might be withholding the true nature of their sexual preferences is especially significant, ultimately supporting the idea that the narrator himself is a closeted gay man.
Themes
Companionship, Love, and Sexuality Theme Icon
Suddenly, a tall model named Mag Wildwood makes a grand entrance and, in a stutter, admonishes Holly for keeping all these handsome men to herself. Holly is unhappy to see her, but Mag doesn’t notice. Without hesitation she floats through the party, charming the men until she goes to the bathroom, at which point Holly loudly insinuates that Mag has a venereal disease. When Mag returns, none of the men want to talk to her anymore. Angry, Mag gets drunk and picks fights. Eventually, she drunkenly collapses, and Holly and the rest of the partygoers decide to go elsewhere. On her way out, Holly asks the narrator to put Mag in a taxi. When Holly leaves, Mag rises, starts to confront the narrator, and then falls to the floor. After checking her breathing and pulse, he gives her a pillow and leaves.
Mag’s presence irks Holly because Mag draws attention away from her. This suggests that Holly likes being in the spotlight, but there is also another—more practical—reason that she doesn’t want Mag to distract the men: Holly’s livelihood depends upon her ability to entice these wealthy men. If Mag interferes too much, then, Holly won’t be able to sustain herself. This is why she spreads a nasty rumor about Mag, effectively neutralizing the threat that Mag poses to Holly’s independence and self-sufficiency.
Themes
Female Independence and Freedom Theme Icon
Wealth, Happiness, and Belonging Theme Icon
The next day, Holly chides the narrator for failing to help Mag, apparently feeling great sympathy for how badly her friend is hungover. For the rest of the weekend, Mag stays with Holly, piquing the narrator’s interest—especially when a Brazilian man named José Ybarra-Jaeger accidentally comes to his door instead of Holly’s. José is looking for Mag and is, apparently, her boyfriend. He is a Brazilian politician who divides his time among Brazil; Washington, D.C.; and New York. 
Even after the narrator and Holly become friends, he still finds himself feeling like an outsider, desperately trying to gain information about her life. Forever an observer, he watches from afar as Holly’s life unfolds. Once again, then, readers see just how little privacy Holly has, though it remains the case that hardly anyone knows about her past.
Themes
Privacy and Obsession Theme Icon
On the same day that José first appears, he returns in the afternoon with multiple suitcases, and the narrator wonders what’s going on downstairs. He later eavesdrops as Mag and Holly sit out on the fire escape with the nameless cat. Mag tells Holly that she’s lucky because Rusty is, at the very least, American. This means very little to Holly, who says she’ll leave America as soon as the war ends, adding that Fred is a soldier. This confuses Mag, who thinks that the narrator is Fred. Accordingly, she says she didn’t know he was a soldier, adding that he looks rather stupid. Holly corrects her by saying that the narrator isn’t stupid, but simply wants to be “on the inside staring out,” which makes him seem dumb. She also clarifies that his real name isn’t Fred. 
Holly’s assessment of the narrator is quite accurate, since he wants so badly to be part of her life. As it stands, though, he’s an outsider forced to simply observe what goes on in the brownstone. Furthermore, it’s worth noting that Holly dreams of leaving the United States. This is a sign that she feels restless in her current existence, yearning to leave everything behind for a new life.
Themes
Female Independence and Freedom Theme Icon
Wealth, Happiness, and Belonging Theme Icon
Privacy and Obsession Theme Icon
Quotes
Mag complains that José is Brazilian, saying she finds it hard to wrap her head around the idea of marrying somebody who isn’t American. Suggesting it’s not so bad that José isn’t American, Holly asks if he bites in bed—something that she herself hates. Mag says he doesn’t, though she adds that he does laugh. Holly says she likes it when men aren’t so serious in bed, and then she asks more about Mag and José’s sex life, but Mag doesn’t answer because she says she can’t remember the details. This, she says, is because she doesn’t think about such things, which makes her “normal.” Holly concedes that this is indeed a normal way to approach sex, but says she’d rather be “natural.”
Although Holly is sometimes guarded about certain elements of her personal life, she has no problem talking about sex and intimacy. Mag, for her part, tries to shame Holly by suggesting that her open-minded approach to these matters is irregular and strange, but this doesn’t bother Holly, who makes a distinction between what’s “normal” and what’s “natural.” This point illustrates how little Holly cares about following societal rules. Indeed, she can’t be bothered to police herself according to arbitrary conventions. Rather, Holly wants to live an unencumbered life, one in which she can let herself be whomever and however she wants.
Themes
Female Independence and Freedom Theme Icon
Companionship, Love, and Sexuality Theme Icon
Again, Mag complains, saying she doesn’t want to move to Brazil. When she describes what it’s like, though, Holly says that it sounds rather nice, and Mag jokingly says, “Better you than me.” In a reflective tone of voice, Holly agrees, saying, “Better me than you.”
Holly doesn’t mind the idea of uprooting her life, even if it would mean living somewhere completely different than the United States. This once again underlines Holly’s somewhat restless spirit, as she yearns for change in a way that Mag can’t embrace for herself, even though she’s the one in a relationship with José.
Themes
Female Independence and Freedom Theme Icon
Wealth, Happiness, and Belonging Theme Icon
Companionship, Love, and Sexuality Theme Icon
After the weekend, the narrator notices that Mag’s name has been added to Holly’s mailbox. Opening his own, the narrator finds a letter informing him that a literary magazine wants to publish one of his stories, though they can’t pay him. Rushing to Holly’s apartment, he shows her the letter in a fit of excitement. Though Holly’s initial reaction is unsatisfying because she tells him not to accept unless they pay him, she quickly sees that he merely wants her congratulations, so she suggests that they go to a celebratory lunch. While she gets dressed, she tells the narrator that Mag has moved in, saying that this is good because she’s so dumb that Holly could abandon her with the lease if she ever needed to. The narrator listens to her as she rambles on and runs around in various states of undress looking for clothes.
It’s worth remembering that Holly promised to help the narrator with his writing career. Now, though, his first success has nothing to do with her, and she even tells him not to go through with it. This is perhaps because Holly is trying to advocate for the narrator, thinking he deserves money, but it also indicates that she doesn’t quite understand that getting published—even without payment—is a big deal for him, This frames Holly as somewhat callous and insensitive—an interpretation that seems even more appropriate when she says she wouldn’t mind sticking Mag with the lease if she ever needed to. At the same time, though, Holly also sees that she’s hurt the narrator’s feelings, and she immediately tries to make up for it by taking him to lunch, thereby demonstrating that, though she is perhaps preoccupied by her own life, she still cares about the narrator.
Themes
Companionship, Love, and Sexuality Theme Icon
The narrator and Holly drink Manhattans at Joe Bell’s, then have lunch in Central Park, stopping by the zoo on their way out, though they quickly leave because Holly hates looking at animals in cages. Frolicking around the park and the city, they have a fantastic time as they talk about their pasts. When Holly tells stories about her personal history, though, she speaks vaguely, hardly divulging any concrete information. Later, they go to a five-and-dime store and steal Halloween masks, skipping gleefully down the street as they make their getaway.
Holly’s aversion to seeing animals in cages aligns with her overall approach to life. Indeed, she hates the idea of confinement, prizing independence and freedom above all else. However, why this means so much to her remains unclear, since she’s so hesitant to speak honestly about her past.
Themes
Female Independence and Freedom Theme Icon
Privacy and Obsession Theme Icon
Quotes
The narrator and Holly spend quite a bit of time together, but the narrator soon gets a day job that makes it hard for him to see Holly, since she keeps such unconventional hours. While the narrator sleeps, Holly goes out with Rusty, Mag, and José, and the narrator wonders why José spends so much time with this group, ultimately deciding that it must be because of Holly’s charm. One day, he spots Holly running into the public library, so he follows her and watches her from afar as she sits at a long table and reads a large stack of books, taking notes as she goes. When she finally leaves, he approaches and looks at the books, which are all about Brazil.
Again, the narrator finds himself wondering about Holly’s life as if he doesn’t even know her. No matter what he does, it seems, she remains something of a mystery to him. This confirms Holly’s idea that the narrator wants to be “on the inside staring out,” since he currently feels like an outsider. And yet, the narrator has good reason to wonder about Holly, since her actions are rather inscrutable. When it becomes clear that she’s been reading about Brazil, for instance, readers are invited to question why, exactly, she has taken such an interest in José.
Themes
Privacy and Obsession Theme Icon
On Christmas Eve, Holly and Mag have a party and ask the narrator to come early to help them trim the Christmas tree. When they finish, Holly tells the narrator that she has a present for him. Bringing him into her bedroom, she shows him the birdcage. Beside himself, the narrator comments on how expensive the cage was, but Holly disregards this, saying that it amounts to “a few extra trips to the powder room.” However, she also makes him promise to never put a living thing inside of it. Agreeing, he embraces her, but she holds out her hand to receive the gift he got her. Knowing that his gift isn’t as grand as Holly’s, the narrator gives her a St. Christopher’s medallion. He knows it isn’t all that special, but, at the very least, it’s from Tiffany’s
Although the narrator doesn’t feel like he knows all that much about Holly’s private life, there’s no denying that they’ve developed a close—and rather touching—relationship. In this moment, they both give each other thoughtful gifts, proving that they’re both attentive to what the other wants. For Holly, this means receiving something—anything—from Tiffany’s, helping her feel that much closer to finding the kind of life she wants to lead. And even though Holly gives the narrator the birdcage, she can’t keep herself from expressing how uncomfortable she is with the fact that it is something designed to keep a living thing from flying free. This, in turn, is a reflection of Holly’s overall discomfort with anything that might curtail her independence or freedom. 
Themes
Female Independence and Freedom Theme Icon
Wealth, Happiness, and Belonging Theme Icon
Companionship, Love, and Sexuality Theme Icon
In the present, the narrator still has the birdcage. However, shortly after Holly gave it to him, he gave it back. This transpires when they have a massive falling out, which happens right after Holly returns from a trip she took in February with Rusty, Mag, and José. While the narrator rubs oil on her back, Holly tells him about the trip, explaining that they went to Key West, Florida first, where Rusty got into an altercation with a group of sailors. He will now have to wear a back brace for the rest of his life. Mag also found her way into the hospital while in Florida, since she got terribly sunburned. Not wanting to spend their vacation in the hospital, José and Holly went to Havana together. When they returned, Mag thought they were having an affair, but Holly dissuaded her by claiming she’s attracted to women, not men.
Holly’s interest in José takes on new meaning when she tells the narrator this story about their shared vacation. At this point, it becomes rather clear that Holly and José are romantically drawn to each other, though Holly has yet to fully admit this. In fact, she denies Mag’s allegations that she and José are having an affair by saying that she’s a lesbian, once more bringing up homosexuality in a fleeting way. In this regard, readers are invited to continue questioning the sexual preferences of the novella’s characters—an important aspect of the book, since the narrator himself provides no insight into his own orientation.
Themes
Companionship, Love, and Sexuality Theme Icon
Holly tells the narrator that she gave one of his stories to O.J. Berman. She says that O.J. is interested in his writing but thinks he’s writing about things nobody cares about—a sentiment with which Holly agrees. She then criticizes the subjects the narrator chooses to focus on and bemoans how much description he uses. As Holly does so, the narrator feels as if his hand, which is still rubbing oil on Holly’s back, has taken on a mind of its own, wanting badly to smack her. Going on, Holly says that none of his descriptions mean anything, so the narrator asks her to give an example of a work she thinks “means something.” Immediately, she  names Wuthering Heights as an example. When she begins to explain why, though, it becomes clear that she’s talking about the movie, not the book, causing the narrator to condescendingly say, “Oh, oh, the movie.”  
Again, Holly offends the narrator by speaking critically about his writing. Although they’re close, he’s unwilling to listen to her opinions about his own work. This, it seems, is the one way that the narrator isn’t passive, considering that he’s willing to stand up for himself when she speaks disparagingly about his stories. In all other scenarios, he’s willing to go along with whatever Holly says or does. When it comes to the narrator’s writing, though, his vanity kicks in and he stands up for himself. This, in turn, throws his relationship with Holly out of balance, since she’s used to his otherwise flexible, easygoing manner.
Themes
Companionship, Love, and Sexuality Theme Icon
Offended, Holly’s entire back tenses beneath the narrator’s hand, and she tells him that, though it’s common for people to feel better than others, it’s “customary to present a little proof before you take the privilege.” The narrator then says that he doesn’t compare himself to Holly or to O.J. Berman because they want different things, insisting that he doesn’t want money. When Holly asks him what he does want, he says he doesn’t know yet, and she responds by suggesting that this is exactly what his stories sound like: like he began writing them without knowing the ending. She also reminds the narrator that he’s going to need money, especially since there aren’t many people who will buy him expensive birdcages. When he mumbles an apology, Holly tells him that he’ll really be sorry if he hits her; she can sense, she says, that he wants to.
It’s somewhat hypocritical that Holly criticizes the narrator for not knowing what he wants, since she has admitted multiple times that she has the same problem. Now, though, Holly scolds the narrator for his passive, unintentional way of being, which she claims manifests itself in his writing. Interestingly enough, the narrator ultimately subverts this criticism by standing up to Holly, showing her that he isn’t quite as passive as she might think—and this, it seems, is what bothers Holly in the first place. In this moment, then, readers see that Holly and the narrator have a complex relationship that is predicated on Holly’s dominance and the narrator’s willingness to yield to her.
Themes
Female Independence and Freedom Theme Icon
Companionship, Love, and Sexuality Theme Icon
The narrator does indeed want to hit Holly, but he refrains. Instead, he says he’s sorry that Holly wasted her money on him, since she has to work so hard to make it—after all, he adds, “Rusty Trawler is too hard a way of earning it.” Instantly, Holly sits up, exposing her breasts, and tells the narrator to get out of her apartment. Accordingly, the narrator marches upstairs, gets the birdcage, and puts outside her door. The next morning, he sees it sitting on the curb waiting for trash collection. Unable to bear the idea of it going to the dump, he defeatedly takes it back inside and puts it in his room.
Holly and the narrator’s argument comes to a breaking point when he acknowledges that she makes her money by dating rich men she doesn’t even like. Of course, Holly was already aware that the narrator knew this detail about her life, but he has never weaponized the truth against her like this. Consequently, she reacts harshly. In addition, it’s worth noting that Holly makes no effort to cover her breasts when she sits up. This indicates that she has been topless throughout the entire scene, even though the narrator hasn’t mentioned it. The lack of sexual attraction between them therefore comes to the forefront of the novella, as readers see once and for all that, though they’re close to each other, there is clearly nothing romantic about their bond.
Themes
Wealth, Happiness, and Belonging Theme Icon
Companionship, Love, and Sexuality Theme Icon
The narrator doesn’t speak to Holly for quite some time. However, he refuses to sign a petition circulated by his elderly neighbor, Madame Sapphia Spanella, who insists that Holly should be evicted because she is “morally objectionable” and has too many parties. One day in the spring, the narrator notices a suspicious looking man hovering by the mailboxes, peering at Holly’s card. He then sees this same man waiting across the street and staring at Holly’s apartment. The narrator wonders if he’s a detective or if he’s perhaps associated with Sally Tomato. While walking to a diner that evening, he notices that the man is following him. Indeed, the mysterious gentleman trails him all the way to the diner, whistling one of the folksy songs that Holly often plays on the guitar.
The appearance of this strange man serves as a reminder that there is still quite a lot the narrator doesn’t know about Holly’s life. To compound this lack of knowledge, he once again finds himself in the position of an outsider, since he and Holly are no longer interacting with one another. Once more, then, the narrator is left to piece together what, exactly, is going on in Holly’s life. And though their relationship might be on hiatus, it’s clear that the narrator’s obsessive fascination with Holly continues.
Themes
Privacy and Obsession Theme Icon
Unnerved, the narrator confronts the strange man when he sits right next to him at the counter of the diner. After the narrator asks what he wants, the man says he needs his help. He then takes a picture from his wallet and hands it to the narrator. The picture shows six children standing next to the man, who has his arm around one of the girls. Pointing to this girl, the man identifies her as Holly, then shows the narrator Fred. Beginning to understand, the narrator says that the man is Holly’s father, but this stops the stranger. First of all, the man tells the narrator, Holly’s name isn’t Holly, it’s Lulamae. Second of all, he’s not her father, he’s her husband. His name is Doc Golightly, and he’s a veterinarian from Texas.
In this moment, readers—and, of course, the narrator—grasp the extent to which Holly has kept her past a secret. Not only has the narrator just heard for the first time that Holly used to live in Texas, but he learns that she was (or perhaps is) married to a much older man. Simply put, Holly has an entire history that has remained a secret until the narrator’s conversation with Doc Golightly.
Themes
Privacy and Obsession Theme Icon
Doc Golightly explains that he’s been searching for Holly for five years. He recently received a letter from Fred informing him that she’s been living in New York, and he immediately came on a bus. She belongs, he upholds, back at home with her husband and children. Beside himself, the narrator says that the children in the picture couldn’t possibly be Holly’s children, and Doc clarifies that they aren’t her “natural-born” children, since their real mother died two years before he married Holly, who was 14 at the time. Doc admits that most 14-year-olds aren’t mature enough to get married, but he says that Holly was always an “exceptional woman” and knew exactly what she was doing when she accepted his proposal. But then, after years of happiness (during which she barely had to do any kind of work), she ran away, leaving behind Doc, his children, and Fred.
That Doc Golightly believes Holly was mature enough to get married when she was only 14 is obviously problematic and predatory. However, it suggests that Holly has always presented herself in a confident, impressive way, though it’s clear that no 14-year-old is old enough to get married, regardless of how adult she seems. To make matters worse, Doc appears unwilling to see that his marriage to Holly curtailed her freedom, finding it mystifying that she would ever want to run away. Instead of recognizing why Holly would want to establish a life of her own once she was old enough to begin an adult life, Doc gets hung up on the fact that she never had to work while living with him—a detail that obviously had nothing to do with why she wanted to leave, since she was likely focused on establishing her own independence, not on whether or not she had to do chores. 
Themes
Female Independence and Freedom Theme Icon
Wealth, Happiness, and Belonging Theme Icon
Companionship, Love, and Sexuality Theme Icon
Quotes
Doc Golightly tells the narrator that he found Holly and Fred raiding his farm after they ran away from their cruel foster parents. Apparently, he says, their real parents died of tuberculosis along with their other siblings. When Doc found them, he took them in and cared for them. For several years, Doc claims, they were all happy, but then Holly started reading fashion magazines, which is where he suspects she got the idea to come to New York. 
When Doc tells the narrator why Holly came to his farm in the first place, readers see that their relationship ultimately helped her ensure that she and Fred would be able to survive. In this sense, then, Holly’s marriage to Doc is similar to the relationships she has with wealthy men in New York, in that she utilizes her sex appeal as a way of establishing self-sufficiency and fending for herself. 
Themes
Female Independence and Freedom Theme Icon
Companionship, Love, and Sexuality Theme Icon
The narrator pays for his and Doc’s meal, then goes back to the apartment with him, having agreed to approach Holly and tell her that Doc is there. Doc wants him to do this because he’s afraid his presence might shock her and scare her off. On the way to the apartment, the narrator asks about Fred, and Doc says that Fred stayed with him until joining the Army, at which point he started corresponding with Holly and, later, sent Doc her address. Now, he says, he has come to take her home, confident that she’ll want to come with him.
It’s easy to see that Doc’s confidence that Holly will return to Texas is unwarranted, since Holly will obviously not want to give up her life in New York. After all, she has created a life of independence and freedom in the city, making it highly unlikely that she’d ever want to go back to depending upon Doc for money, food, and shelter.
Themes
Female Independence and Freedom Theme Icon
Wealth, Happiness, and Belonging Theme Icon
When the narrator goes to Holly’s door, she’s already on her way out. Playfully calling him an idiot, she says she’s in a rush and that they can make amends the following day. “Sure, Lulamae,” he says. “If you’re still around tomorrow.” Shocked, she looks at him for a moment before rushing downstairs, calling Fred’s name as she goes. When she sees Doc, she halts and retreats in disappointment, but then she touches his face and says hello, kissing his cheek and happily repeating his name. As they embrace, the narrator slips into his own apartment. From inside, he listens as Madame Sapphia Spanella opens her door and shouts at them, telling Holly to do her “whoring” somewhere else.
It’s rather surprising that Holly is happy to see Doc. One might think she wouldn’t want to see him, considering that she ran away from him in the first place. The fact that she’s glad to reunite with him in this moment therefore suggests that she never disliked him or felt any kind of ill will toward him. Instead, she simply wanted to make her own life, yearning for a sense of freedom that a life with Doc simply couldn’t afford her.
Themes
Female Independence and Freedom Theme Icon
Companionship, Love, and Sexuality Theme Icon
The next morning, Holly and the narrator drink at Joe Bell’s. She tells him she never divorced Doc because the marriage must not have been legal, since she was only 14. She hasn’t slept all night, since she’s been with Doc since the narrator left them. She spent the evening with him and then took him home. She insinuates that they had sex, saying that she “had to” because Doc truly loves her. Plus, she says, he’s a very kind, sensitive man. After that, Holly took Doc to the bus station, and Doc thought she was coming back to Texas with him right up until he boarded the bus without her, though she kept reminding him that she’s not 14 anymore. However, she now says that she might as well still be 14—the only difference is that she calls it the “mean reds” when she feels wayward and lost.
When Holly suggests that she “had to” have sex with Doc because he loves her, she makes a rare concession to what other people want (though not a particularly healthy one, considering that she should only engage in sexual activity if she wants to, regardless of how much her partner loves her). Indeed, Holly usually doesn’t yield to what others want, though she does insinuate several times throughout the novella that she sometimes ends up having sex with the men who pay to take her out. The difference is that she sleeps with Doc for emotional reasons, whereas she sleeps with rich men for monetary reasons (though it’s also worth acknowledging that she might actually want to have sex with these men, too). What’s more, Holly’s decision to stay in New York underlines the fact that she wants to maintain her independence, though she also suggests that she still hasn’t found a sense of belonging, since she often feels just as lost as she did when she was 14 and didn’t have much personal freedom. 
Themes
Female Independence and Freedom Theme Icon
Wealth, Happiness, and Belonging Theme Icon
Companionship, Love, and Sexuality Theme Icon
Turning to Joe Bell, Holly tells him never to love a “wild thing,” which she believes was Doc’s biggest mistake. If Joe loves a wild thing, she says, he’ll end up staring up into the sky, as if watching a bird fly away. Turning to the narrator, Joe says that Holly must be drunk, and though she agrees, she says that Doc ultimately understood her when she told him she couldn’t return to her old life in Texas. Raising her glass to toast Doc’s kindness, she says that it’s easier to look up at the sky than to live there. After all, the sky is a lonely, “empty” place. 
When Holly says that the sky is an “empty” place, she intimates that, though freedom and independence are important to her, they don’t necessarily give her a sense of companionship or belonging. Holly is, it seems, still searching for a way to feel settled into her own life without having to sacrifice her autonomy and appetite for change. For now, she has chosen to prioritize independence over all else, but this comes with loneliness and a sense of estrangement from the rest of the world, as if she’s a bird flying into a vast expanse of nothingness.
Themes
Female Independence and Freedom Theme Icon
Wealth, Happiness, and Belonging Theme Icon
Companionship, Love, and Sexuality Theme Icon
Quotes
On the subway several days later, the narrator sees an alarming headline on somebody else’s newspaper. “TRAWLER MARRIES FOURTH,” it reads, but he can’t see the rest. Suddenly, he feels angry, jealous, and disappointed. The thought of Holly marrying Rusty Trawler deeply upsets the narrator—so much that he wonders why, exactly, he feels like this. He then realizes that it’s because he loves Holly, though the kind of love he feels for her is the same kind that he felt for his childhood mailman, his mother’s cook, and an entire family who lived near him when he was a boy. Still, he notes that even this kind of love can lead to jealousy.
The narrator acknowledges in this moment that he loves Holly, but the love he feels for her isn’t romantic. This provides insight into the nature of their relationship, which is quite complex even though they aren’t physically attracted to each other. Indeed, what the narrator wants is to be “on the inside staring out,” as Holly puts it, not on outside staring in. For this reason, he hates the idea that Holly would simply go forth and marry Rusty Trawler without the narrator knowing. Doing this, it seems, would undermine Holly and the narrator’s otherwise close and emotionally intimate relationship, which is clearly just as nuanced and delicate as any romantic bond.
Themes
Companionship, Love, and Sexuality Theme Icon
Privacy and Obsession Theme Icon
Quotes
Rushing off the subway, the narrator buys a newspaper and sees that Rusty isn’t marrying Holly, but Mag Wildwood. Confused, he goes back to the brownstone, where Madame Sapphia Spanella greets him and tells him to call the police because somebody is trying to kill Holly. Upstairs, he tries and fails to enter her apartment, but then José appears and opens the door with his own key. Accompanying José is a doctor, who pushes his way inside, walks over broken glass and upturned furniture, and finds Holly collapsed on the bed. José then gives her a sedative, and explains to the narrator that Holly isn’t upset about Rusty’s marriage to Mag—in fact, both she and José are relieved, since they actively wanted to be rid of them. Instead, Holly is upset because she received a telegram from Doc informing her that Fred was killed in action.
That Holly and José both want Mag and Rusty to marry each other once again suggests that they are romantically interested in each other, though José doesn’t fully clarify that they’re in a relationship, thereby leaving the narrator to put the pieces together for himself (once again). Meanwhile, though, Holly is too focused on her brother’s death to care about any of her other relationships. This makes sense, considering that she spoke about Fred quite frequently even when she was trying to keep the details of her past secret. 
Themes
Companionship, Love, and Sexuality Theme Icon
Privacy and Obsession Theme Icon
Holly stops calling the narrator Fred. In the coming months, Holly stays inside and isn’t as social as normal. During this period, José moves in with her, and she hardly leaves the apartment except for her weekly visits to Sally Tomato. Slowly, though, Holly begins to furnish the apartment and learn Portuguese. She also starts talking to the narrator about how she’s going to marry José and move to Rio de Janeiro. One day, she casually mentions that she’s six weeks pregnant. She says she wishes she’d been a virgin when she first had sex with José, quickly adding that she hasn’t been with that many men—only 11, she says, not counting “what happened” before she was 13, since that doesn’t “count.”
Finally, Holly reveals once and for all that she and José are in a romantic relationship. This apparently has a profound effect on her, judging by the fact that she furnishes her apartment—something she said she wouldn’t ever do unless she felt as if she truly belonged to her own life. Now, it seems, she no longer feels restless and eager for change, though she also speaks excitedly about moving to Brazil. This, in turn, suggests that any happiness she has about her current circumstances is fleeting and that, in the long run, she still thirsts for change. On another note, when Holly talks about her lovers, she refutes the idea that she might be considered a prostitute simply because of how many people she has slept with—though this doesn’t necessarily clarify whether or not having sex with men is part of how she financially sustains herself. When she says that she doesn’t “count” the men she had sex with before she was 13, she reveals that men started pursuing her long before it was appropriate to do so—an indication that she was prematurely exposed to sex and adult desire.
Themes
Female Independence and Freedom Theme Icon
Wealth, Happiness, and Belonging Theme Icon
Companionship, Love, and Sexuality Theme Icon
One day in autumn, the narrator is waiting near the mailboxes because it’s his birthday and he’s expecting money from his family. As he waits, Holly passes and suggests they go horseback riding in the park. She adds that she has to go riding to say farewell to her favorite horse in the city. When the narrator asks what she means, she informs him that she and José are moving to Brazil the following weekend. The narrator insists that she can’t simply leave everyone behind, but she says she has no friends. After he points out that she has him and Joe Bell and Sally Tomato, she admits that she will indeed miss Sally, though she hasn’t seen him for a month. In fact, he was happy when she told him she was leaving the country, saying that this is probably for the best.
Holly’s abrupt announcement that she and José will soon be moving undoubtedly comes as a shock to the narrator. Once again, he finds himself on the outside looking in, trying to make sense of Holly’s life from afar even though they’ve become quite close. Still, Holly clearly feels rather alone in the city and is eager to leave, despite the fact that she has the narrator as a friend and has fallen in love with José. In turn, readers get the sense that, though Holly claims she’s happy with José, what she’s really happy about is the prospect of a new adventure.
Themes
Female Independence and Freedom Theme Icon
Wealth, Happiness, and Belonging Theme Icon
Companionship, Love, and Sexuality Theme Icon
Privacy and Obsession Theme Icon
Frustrated, the narrator asks Holly if José knows that she’s already married. Snapping at the narrator, Holly tells him to stop trying to ruin an otherwise beautiful day, adding that he’d better not tell anyone about Doc Golightly. Mounting their horses, they let the conversation drop, and the narrator begins to enjoy watching Holly stride about so expertly. But just then, a group of teenagers jumps out, scaring the horses and slashing them with small switches. Suddenly, the narrator’s horse takes off in fright, sprinting so hard that it’s all he can do to hold on. The horse makes its way out of the park and into the city as the narrator clings for his life. Finally, a mounted police officer and Holly manage to catch up and slow the horse down, though only after multiple blocks of hard riding.
The narrator brings up Doc Golightly because he’s angry and disappointed to hear that Holly is about to move. Worse, she has just said that she doesn’t have any friends in New York, thereby insulting the narrator, since he sees himself as one of her closest friends. For this reason, he tries to put a damper on her otherwise high-spirited mood.
Themes
Female Independence and Freedom Theme Icon
Companionship, Love, and Sexuality Theme Icon
Privacy and Obsession Theme Icon
The police officer takes the horses back to the stables while Holly hails a taxi. Inside the car, she asks how the narrator feels, and he thanks her for saving his life, telling her that she’s amazing and saying that he loves her. “Damn fool,” she says, kissing him on the cheek. Then, all of a sudden, the narrator sees four different versions of her circling before his face, at which point he passes out. 
When Holly saves the narrator, he forgets his anger and jealousy. Instead of focusing on the fact that Holly is going to leave him behind in New York, he concentrates on how much she means to him as a friend. When he tries to show her affection by expressing how grateful he is to her, though, she only calls him a “damn fool,” as if reciprocating this sentiment would require too much intimacy and effort. With this in mind, readers see how hesitant Holly is to fully let people get close to her—even the narrator.
Themes
Female Independence and Freedom Theme Icon
Companionship, Love, and Sexuality Theme Icon
That very same evening, pictures of Holly appear in the newspaper, but the story has nothing to do with what happened in the park. Rather, one of the headlines reads: “PLAYGIRL ARRESTED IN NARCOTICS SCANDAL.” One of the articles explains that Holly—whom the writer describes as a popular figure in New York’s “café society”—was arrested for helping Sally Tomato run a drug ring from prison. Apparently, Sally’s lawyer, Mr. O’Shaughnessy, isn’t a lawyer, but a defrocked priest with a long criminal record. The coded messages Holly relayed to him from Sally were orders about how to run the drug ring in his absence.
Unfortunately for Holly, her association with the mobster Sally Tomato has finally caught up to her. It’s not altogether surprising that she has been implicated in this nefarious scandal, since she willingly passed coded messages between Sally and O’Shaughnessy—an obviously suspicious act that she chose to ignore simply because she liked Sally and because O’Shaughnessy gave her $100 each week. Now, though, Holly has not only been arrested, but her reputation in the city has been tarnished, as journalists go out of their way to disrupt her identity as a popular member of New York’s “café society” of socialites.
Themes
Female Independence and Freedom Theme Icon
Privacy and Obsession Theme Icon
The narrator knows about Holly’s arrest before it appears in the papers, since he was there when two detectives took her into custody. He was in the bathtub while Holly waited to rub a healing liniment on his aching body before putting him in bed. Suddenly, a knock sounded on the door, and when Holly called out that the visitors should enter, Madame Sapphia Spanella came in with the detectives, immediately identifying Holly and, seeing the narrator in the nude, insisting that the scene was proof that Holly’s a “whore.” One of the detectives—a woman—told Holly to come with them, placing her hand on her shoulder. Instantly, Holly called her a “driveling old bull-dyke” and ordered her to take her hand away, at which point the officer slapped her. On her way out, Holly asked the narrator to feed her cat in her absence.
Holly’s animosity in this moment is in keeping with the fact that she strongly dislikes anything that might curtail her independence and freedom. Needless to say, going to jail would do this, so she doesn’t take kindly to the detectives when they arrive and tell her that she has to come with them. Holly also insults the female detective by calling her a derogatory name and assuming she’s a lesbian, most likely intentionally provoking the detective because Holly is so angry.
Themes
Female Independence and Freedom Theme Icon
That night, Joe Bell visits the narrator and asks if he thinks it’s true that Holly was mixed up in a drug ring. He also insists that they go to his bar and call everyone Holly knows in order to help her post bail. This proves difficult, though, because the narrator has multiple drinks while making these calls. To make matters worse, there aren’t very many people to call. When he phones Mag Wildwood and Rusty Trawler and explains what happened, Mag tells him that she and Rusty will sue anyone who tries to associate them with Holly. Finally, the narrator reaches O.J. Berman, who assures him that he has already arranged to post her bail and has contacted best lawyer in New York, saying that, though he doesn’t owe Holly anything, he feels obliged to help.
Even though Holly has previously claimed that she has no friends, the narrator, Joe Bell, and O.J. prove that this isn’t true. In fact, O.J. starts trying to help Holly before the narrator even asks him to, demonstrating that there are people Holly can depend upon, even if they can’t necessarily depend upon her. (After all, she abandoned O.J. when he got her an audition to be in a movie, effectively jeopardizing his reputation as an agent.) In this way, it becomes clear that Holly isn’t quite as alone in the world as she might feel. 
Themes
Female Independence and Freedom Theme Icon
Companionship, Love, and Sexuality Theme Icon
The next morning, Holly is still in jail. The narrator goes to her apartment to feed her cat, slipping in through the window. Once inside, he finds José’s cousin, who has also come in through the window. The cousin is packing a suitcase full of José’s clothes, and he gives the narrator a letter from José, asking him to bring it to Holly. Frustrated, the narrator gathers that José is abandoning Holly, but begrudgingly agrees to give her the letter. 
Unfortunately, José’s choice to abandon Holly in her time of need will undoubtedly confirm her belief that nobody truly cares about her. Of course, this isn’t true, as evidenced by the fact that O.J. has already arranged her bail before anyone even asks him to do so. Nonetheless, though, José’s actions will make Holly feel as if the most important people in her life will always let her down.
Themes
Companionship, Love, and Sexuality Theme Icon
The narrator visits Holly in jail, and she tells him—casual as ever—that she lost her baby because of the hard horseback riding she had to do in order to catch up to him the previous day. Moving on, she speaks somewhat nonsensically about a “fat woman” she’s been seeing ever since Fred died. As soon as she heard the news of her brother’s death, this woman appeared. She was, Holly says, holding Fred in her lap like a baby. Turning her attention back to the narrator, she asks if he understands now why she lost her presence of mind and trashed her own apartment. 
Holly’s strange hallucination suggests that she’s under quite a bit of emotional pressure. Indeed, losing her brother has put a significant strain on her, and this strain has only been exacerbated by her arrest and miscarriage. Simply put, Holly is at an extreme low point in her life, and the only person there to help her through it is the narrator and, remotely, O.J. Berman and Joe Bell.
Themes
Companionship, Love, and Sexuality Theme Icon
With great regret, the narrator gives José’s letter to Holly. In the letter, José informs her that, though he loves her and has always appreciated that she’s unique, he can’t continue to see her because he must “protect” his own reputation. He is, he admits, a coward. Hearing this, Holly asks the narrator what he thinks, and he says that it is, at the very least, very honest and even somewhat “touching.” Holly, for her part, disagrees, lamenting the fact that she truly loved José.
Holly finds no solace in the fact that José’s letter is honest, since this does nothing to change the fact that the man she loves has abandoned her. Although people are constantly drawn to Holly, José has left her at perhaps the most crucial time possible, worrying more about his reputation than about their relationship. In turn, Holly finds it hard to deny her original belief that she has nobody in her life to depend upon.
Themes
Companionship, Love, and Sexuality Theme Icon
Turning her attention to her miscarriage, Holly thanks the narrator, saying that if it weren’t for him, she would still be pregnant and would have to live as a single parent. Plus, she’s now considering suing the police department by claiming that the detective’s slap precipitated her miscarriage. This strikes the narrator as a bad idea, so he urges Holly to be serious, wanting her to think realistically about what she’s going to do when she makes bail. She then tells him that she plans to flee the country, saying that she’ll use her ticket to Brazil even though she’s no longer with José. After all, the ticket is already paid for, and she’s never been to Brazil. Beside himself, the narrator tries impress upon Holly how serious it would be for her to leave the country to avoid a prison sentence, but she remains steadfast in her convictions. 
Holly’s decision to flee the country aligns with her appetite for freedom. Although she will soon be let out on bail, there’s no guaranteeing that she won’t receive an actual prison sentence. Needless to say, this would significantly hinder her ability to live a free and individualistic life. Accordingly, Holly has decided to embark upon a life on the run, an existence that will preserve her freedom but ultimately ensure that she’s never able to fully settle down.
Themes
Female Independence and Freedom Theme Icon
Explaining why she plans to leave the country, Holly says she’ll never say anything to incriminate Sally Tomato. She judges everyone based on how they treat her, she says, and he treated her well. And though the state might not be able to prove that Holly is guilty, she knows the attention the trial will attract will all but ruin her reputation in the United States, making it impossible for her to live the life she’s built. To emphasize her point, she says that the narrator would understand what she means if he, too, depended on the “particular talents” that are required to make a living the way she does. She then asks the narrator to create a list for her of the 50 richest men in Brazil.  
Holly is well aware that her ability to sustain herself is directly linked to whether or not people admire and covet her. If she is no longer seen as a popular woman in New York’s “café society,” then rich men won’t want to go out with her, and she’ll lose her income. Because of this, Holly has resolved to leave the country, apparently planning to continue to date rich men as a way of supporting herself.
Themes
Female Independence and Freedom Theme Icon
Wealth, Happiness, and Belonging Theme Icon
Companionship, Love, and Sexuality Theme Icon
Quotes
On the day of Holly’s flight, she gets out of jail (having delayed her release by pretending to still be unhealthy after her miscarriage). After going straight to the bank, she heads to Joe Bell’s bar, knowing it’d be unwise to return to her apartment, which is under surveillance. She then sends Joe to the narrator’s apartment to ask him to gather her belongings and bring them to the bar. She wants her jewelry, guitar, clothes, toiletries, and a 100-year-old bottle of brandy. She also wants the cat, who tries to evade the narrator. Finally, though, the narrator manages to bring all of these things, including the cat and the St. Christopher’s medal that he gave her. Once at the bar, he and Holly drink the brandy. Joe, for his part, refuses to toast with them because he disapproves of Holly’s plan.
Up until the very end of the novella, the narrator does whatever Holly wants him to do, even if he doesn’t want to do it. Indeed, the narrator doesn’t want Holly to leave, but he proves himself essential to Holly’s plan when he agrees to collect her belongings and bring them to her at Joe’s bar. Once again, then, readers see how passively willing the narrator is to make sacrifices for Holly. This, of course, is because he loves her, though not in a romantic way.
Themes
Companionship, Love, and Sexuality Theme Icon
Privacy and Obsession Theme Icon
Despite Joe’s disapproval, he calls a limo to take Holly to the airport, unable to resist showing her one last kindness. Giving her flowers, he says farewell and rushes to the bathroom, trying to hide his emotion. Holly and the narrator then get in the car and start toward the airport, but Holly tells the driver to stop in Spanish Harlem. Getting out, she sets the cat on the curb and tells him to go away. In response, he rubs up against her leg and doesn’t move, so she gets back in the car and tells the chauffeur to drive. Trying to justify her decision to let him go, Holly says that she and the cat have never belonged to each other. Cutting herself off, though, she orders the driver to stop and dashes down the street in search of the cat.
Although Holly would like to think that she hasn’t developed attachments to the life she’s about to leave, she realizes in this moment that she truly has cultivated meaningful relationships. This, in turn, will make it that much harder for her to leave the country, though she has already started the process. Still, she suddenly finds herself hesitating to go through with her original plan.
Themes
Female Independence and Freedom Theme Icon
Companionship, Love, and Sexuality Theme Icon
The cat is no longer where Holly left him. Regretting her decision, she cries out that she and the cat truly did belong to one another. Hearing this, the narrator promises to come back to find the cat after Holly leaves. This soothes Holly to a certain extent, but she admits that she’s afraid of what she’s about to do, suddenly realizing that her life of aimless detachment might continue forever. She laments the fact that she never knows what belongs to her until she gets rid of it, but then she gets back in the car and tells the driver to take her to the airport.
The gravity of what Holly is about to do dawns on her in this moment, as she realizes that she’ll never be able to recover all she’s about to cast away. Like the cat, her life in America will soon be gone, since she won’t be able to return to the country without getting arrested and put in prison. And though this prospect didn’t seem all that daunting at first, it now feels dizzyingly real because it’s accompanied by a sense of finality—or, rather, by the opposite of finality, since Holly realizes that fleeing the country will force her to spend the rest of her life on the run, making it that much harder to find a sense of belonging. However, she is also used to putting the past behind her and transitioning into entirely new lifestyles, which is why she’s able to will herself back into the limo.
Themes
Female Independence and Freedom Theme Icon
Wealth, Happiness, and Belonging Theme Icon
Months pass, and the narrator doesn’t hear from Holly. That Christmas, Sally Tomato dies, and the newspapers mention Holly in the articles about him, but there’s otherwise very little press about her. That spring, the narrator finally receives a postcard from Holly, who tells him that she disliked Brazil. She’s now in Buenos Aires, which she loves. It’s not quite Tiffany’s, she says, but it’s close. She is involved with a wealthy lover who has a wife and seven children, so she’s looking for an apartment of her own. She promises to send the narrator her address when she has one. But this is the last he hears from her.
When the narrator hears from Holly, it’s evident that Holly isn’t particularly attached to anything. Like she did in New York, she’s supporting herself by dating rich men (in particular, a married man with seven children), but she doesn’t have a permanent address, ultimately indicating that she hasn’t found the sense of belonging that she hopes to find before settling down. Holly is, it seems, still searching for an elusive kind of happiness—one she might never find.
Themes
Female Independence and Freedom Theme Icon
Wealth, Happiness, and Belonging Theme Icon
Companionship, Love, and Sexuality Theme Icon
The narrator is sad that Holly never sends him her address, especially because he has so many things to tell her. For starters, he has sold several stories. He’s also heard that Rusty and Mag are getting divorced. As for himself, he’s moving out of the brownstone because it feels “haunted.” Most of all, though, he wants to tell Holly that he found her cat. For weeks after Holly left, the narrator went to Spanish Harlem to search for the lost animal. Finally, he found the cat sitting inside somebody’s apartment, perched in the window of what looked like a cozy room. The narrator couldn’t help but wonder what the cat’s name was, feeling sure that he finally had one now. After all, the cat had clearly found a home in which he belonged. And wherever she is, the narrator thinks, he hopes that Holly has, too. 
In many ways, Breakfast at Tiffany’s is a story about the natural desire to belong. Even animals, Capote intimates, hope to find the contentment that comes along with settling into a pleasant and fulfilling life. As for Holly, it remains unclear whether she will ever manage to attain what her nameless cat now has, ultimately intimating that, though everyone yearns for this kind of fulfillment, such happiness and assurance are still rather rare and elusive things.
Themes
Female Independence and Freedom Theme Icon
Wealth, Happiness, and Belonging Theme Icon
Companionship, Love, and Sexuality Theme Icon
Quotes