As the novel draws to a close, O’Brien relies upon another sudden, unexpected twist—Cacciato shows up out of nowhere, just when Berlin needs to run into him. The last time Berlin tracked down Cacciato, Cacciato’s fellow monks attacked Berlin. Here, Cacciato seems both weaker and more menacing, and he even greets Berlin when Berlin opens his door (which is, surreally, open and unlocked). Cacciato’s behavior again seems unreal and dreamlike—apparently he’s been expecting Berlin.