Giuseppe Garibaldi was an Italian general and revolutionary who led a successful military campaign to reunify Italy in the mid-1800s. The editor sees Garibaldi’s military tactics as a version of the reader’s extremist idea that Indians should achieve home rule by taking up arms and forcing the English out of India. The editor argues that Garibaldi’s revolution merely gave power to an Italian elite, without truly freeing the population from tyranny. From the editor’s perspective, this shows that Giuseppe Mazzini’s view of independence as moral autonomy or self-rule is a better goal for India.