Photograph 51

by

Anna Ziegler

The Winter’s Tale Symbol Analysis

The Winter’s Tale Symbol Icon

William Shakespeare’s play The Winter’s Tale symbolizes the way that women’s voices and accomplishments have historically been seen as less important than those of their male counterparts. In Photograph 51, Rosalind Franklin’s attends a performance of The Winter’s Tale one weekend. (This anecdote seems to be fictional, though it’s plausible enough, given that a production of The Winter’s Tale directed by Peter Brooks was indeed playing in London’s West End in 1951.) On Monday, her colleague Maurice Wilkins admits that he nearly attended the same performance but decided at the last minute not to buy a ticket. Wilkins later reveals in an aside that he saw Rosalind ducking into the theater and wanted to follow her inside in hopes of creating at least one experience that he and his reluctant partner could share—but he was too afraid to do so. Rosalind remarks that while the actor who played Leontes, John Gielgud, was wonderful, she cannot remember the actress who played his wife Hermione; the actress simply didn’t “stand out.”

Rosalind, the play suggests, has come to adopt a kind of internalized misogyny after years of oppression and sexism—she discounts the Hermione actress’s performance as being unmemorable, not realizing that her own laborious work in pursuit of uncovering the structure of DNA will soon be overlooked in a similar fashion. On an even deeper level, the central relationship between the king Leontes and his wife, Hermione, whom he murders when he suspects that she is unfaithful—only to pray her back to life again towards the end of the play—represents the uneven and occasionally cruel dynamic between Wilkins and Rosalind. Their contentious relationship leads the frustrated Wilkins to betray Rosalind by showing her research to their Cambridge rivals Crick and Watson—it is only at the end of the play, after Rosalind’s death, that Wilkins shows remorse for his actions and begs for Rosalind to come back to life so they can begin their relationship again and anew.

The Winter’s Tale Quotes in Photograph 51

The Photograph 51 quotes below all refer to the symbol of The Winter’s Tale. For each quote, you can also see the other characters and themes related to it (each theme is indicated by its own dot and icon, like this one:
Sexism and Antisemitism Theme Icon
).
Photograph 51 Quotes

WILKINS. I almost went to see the very same performance. […] Our paths so nearly crossed. (Beat.) Was it any good?

ROSALIND. Oh yes. Very.

WILKINS. The great difference, you know, between The Winter’s Tale and the story on which it’s based—Pandosto—is that in Shakespeare’s version the heroine survives.

ROSALIND. John Gielgud played Leontes. He really was very good. Very lifelike. Very good. When Hermione died, even though it was his fault, I felt for him. I truly did.

WILKINS. And who played Hermione?

ROSALIND. I don’t remember. She didn’t stand out, I suppose.

Related Characters: Rosalind Franklin (speaker), Maurice Wilkins (speaker)
Related Symbols: The Winter’s Tale
Page Number: 18
Explanation and Analysis:

WILKINS. And they do. I love that Hermione wasn’t really dead. That she comes back.

ROSALIND. (Sympathetically.) No, Maurice. She doesn’t. Not really.

WILKINS. Of course she does.

ROSALIND. No.

WILKINS. Then how do you explain the statue coming to life?

ROSALIND. Hope. They all project it. Leontes projects life where there is none, so he can be forgiven.

Related Characters: Rosalind Franklin (speaker), Maurice Wilkins (speaker)
Related Symbols: The Winter’s Tale
Page Number: 59
Explanation and Analysis:
Get the entire Photograph 51 LitChart as a printable PDF.
Photograph 51 PDF

The Winter’s Tale Symbol Timeline in Photograph 51

The timeline below shows where the symbol The Winter’s Tale appears in Photograph 51. The colored dots and icons indicate which themes are associated with that appearance.
Photograph 51
Sexism and Antisemitism Theme Icon
Personal Values vs. Professional Success Theme Icon
Choices and Actions vs. Chance and Fate Theme Icon
...how her weekend was, and she tells him that she went to a matinee of The Winter’s Tale the day before. Wilkins says he almost went to the same performance—he passed the theater... (full context)
Sexism and Antisemitism Theme Icon
Personal Values vs. Professional Success Theme Icon
Choices and Actions vs. Chance and Fate Theme Icon
Time and Memory Theme Icon
...has something to tell her. He confesses that on the day she went to see The Winter’s Tale , he saw her go into the theatre. He got in line at the box... (full context)
Sexism and Antisemitism Theme Icon
Personal Values vs. Professional Success Theme Icon
Choices and Actions vs. Chance and Fate Theme Icon
Time and Memory Theme Icon
...Wilkins have a similar conversation to the one they had earlier in the play, quoting The Winter’s Tale back and forth. Wilkins says that he loves the part where Hermione, killed by her... (full context)
Sexism and Antisemitism Theme Icon
Personal Values vs. Professional Success Theme Icon
Choices and Actions vs. Chance and Fate Theme Icon
Time and Memory Theme Icon
...in regret.” Rosalind, smiling sadly, says that perhaps the two of them should have seen The Winter’s Tale together, or gone to lunch. Wilkins asks if that would’ve changed things between them, but... (full context)