Death Theme Analysis

Hurst refers to death explicitly and implicitly throughout “The Scarlet Ibis,” using foreshadowing, the symbolism of the ibis itself, and allusions to the Biblical story of Cain and Abel. These devices give the story an allegorical dimension, demonstrating that often the most innocent people die not because they deserve to die, but because of the carelessness and wrongdoing of others. The story contains several examples of foreshadowing of Doodle’s untimely death. For instance, when Doodle is born, Doodle’s parents assume that he will not live and have a small coffin built for him, which continues to haunt Doodle as a “memento mori” long after he has outgrown it. Similarly, Brother menacingly remarks that Doodle’s real name (William Armstrong) only sounds good on a tombstone. Together, these references serve to imbue the story with an atmosphere of death, constantly reminding readers of the eeriness and sadness of premature death.

The primary symbol at work in the story, the scarlet ibis, directly parallels Doodle in its journey and serves as an omen of his own fate as it falls victim to forces outside its control. The scarlet ibis—a bird not native to North America, making sightings of it incredibly rare—appears one day in the yard of the boys’ home, having been carried there by a storm. Brother observes that the bird is beautiful and graceful, but when it attempts to fly its wings are mangled, and it crashes to the ground. He wonders “how many miles it had traveled to die like this, in our yard, beneath the bleeding tree.” After Brother discovers Doodle lifeless in the forest, he acknowledges his brother’s connection to the bird. Doodle progresses so far past the limitations imposed on him by his disability, only to be overwhelmed by his own storm and at the very end of the story.

“The Scarlet Ibis” also parallels, in some ways, the Biblical story of Cain and Abel, in which Cain kills his younger brother Abel out of jealousy and spite. When God asks where Abel is, he responds, “am I my brother’s keeper?” and when God discovers what has happened, Cain is sent into exile. Although the motivations are different, there are clear connections between the stories. Most of The Scarlet Ibis takes place in a pastoral setting in which the boys roam free, but the opening (which occurs chronologically after Doodle has died) describes a vision of decaying nature, implying that Brother has left the idyllic world of his childhood behind. Brother betrays Doodle and causes his death, illustrating the same moral message as the Bible story: we must all behave like our brother’s keepers. These allusions, combined with the symbol of the ibis and the moments of foreshadowing, strengthen the reader’s understanding of Doodle as a tragic figure of innocence whose life is crushed by the selfishness and blindness of those around him.