Rushing to Judgment Theme Analysis

Through the hidden kindness of Mr. Wills, “The Taste of Watermelon” suggests that people are not always what they seem. The sixteen-year-old narrator and his family have recently moved next door to Mr. Wills, an intimidating and talented farmer. He is a big man who seems quick to anger, and he never visits with anyone in the community, which others find weird. For this reason, when Mr. Wills obsessively guards an especially large watermelon growing on his farm, the narrator’s family judge him for acting selfishly, assuming that he’s being needlessly possessive and that, by devoting himself to his melon, he’s neglecting his sick wife. Finally, when the narrator hears a rumor that Mr. Wills’s shotgun holds lethal bullets instead of the salt pellets farmers normally use, he feels sure that Mr. Wills is a cruel tyrant, overly protective both of his watermelon patch and his attractive teenage daughter. This motivates him to steal Mr. Wills’s prize melon, partly to rebel against his perceived cruelty.

However, the events of the story show that the narrator was wrong to assume that Mr. Wills was unkind and tyrannical. After stealing the enormous watermelon, the narrator learns that Mr. Wills was growing the watermelon for his sick wife, who was planning on sharing it with the entire neighborhood. Far from acting selfishly, Mr. Wills’s devotion to the watermelon was an act of love for his wife and an act of hope that they might become woven into the wider community. The family’s antisocial nature turns out to be due to Mrs. Wills’s illness and Mr. Wills’s overwork, as he does not have a son to help out on the farm. Ultimately, when the narrator admits to his crime, Mr. Wills forgives him readily, reveals that his gun was only filled with salt pellets, and suggests that the narrator repay him by helping him farm next year. In this way, the story reveals that superficial judgments often hide a more complex truth—perceived villains might simply be misunderstood.