Even if Shay might be right that the Smoke wasn’t going to last forever, it doesn’t mean that Tally shouldn’t feel remorse for what she did. It’s only through experiencing this guilt will Tally be able to understand the importance of being loyal, kind, and empathetic. Tally’s understanding that this night will be difficult, even for the Specials, shows how underprepared the Specials are to deal with an uprising like this—they’re not used to people acting like autonomous individuals, and they don’t know how to handle it.