Joel Davis, usually called Papa D, is a Black man who owns a juke joint in an unnamed town in the U.S. South. Some younger, progressive Black students see Papa D as a traitor because he does business with Lyle Britten, a virulently racist white store owner. Papa D helped Lyle cover up his murder of Willa Mae’s husband as self-defense, but he subsequently testifies against Lyle when Lyle is tried for Richard Henry’s murder.