Never Caught

by

Erica Armstrong Dunbar

Tobias Lear was George Washington’s trusted secretary. Over the years in which he served Washington—he took care of Washington’s most intimate affairs until the president’s death in 1799—Lear was responsible for scouting suitable housing for the Washingtons up north; for handling Washington’s more delicate correspondences; and for assembling the staff, both enslaved and indentured, who would care for the Washingtons in their many residences. Lear later assumed the role of chief of staff once Washington ascended to the presidency and moved with his wife and young son to the Executive Mansion at High Street in Philadelphia, the nation’s temporary capital. Lear handled matters of the utmost discretion for the Washingtons—including the controversial decision to “rotate” or “shuffle” the Washington’s slaves between Philadelphia and Mount Vernon after learning of a law which allowed any adult enslaved man or woman to claim their freedom after six months of living in Pennsylvania. Lear, in his letters to his employers, revealed a certain ambivalence about the institution of slavery—yet his mind was governed by a deeply-ingrained sense of paternalism, or the erroneous and racist belief that white slaveholders knew what was best for the Black men and women they kept enslaved. He, like the Washingtons, believed that freedom would be too great a burden for any Black man or woman to bear.
Get the entire Never Caught LitChart as a printable PDF.
Never Caught PDF

Tobias Lear Character Timeline in Never Caught

The timeline below shows where the character Tobias Lear appears in Never Caught. The colored dots and icons indicate which themes are associated with that appearance.
Chapter 2
Slavery and Paternalism Theme Icon
Narrative and Historical Erasure Theme Icon
Freedom and Agency Theme Icon
...husband in New York—she even misses his inauguration on April 30th, 1789. On May 3rd, Tobias Lear —Washington’s trusted personal secretary—writes to a relative of Martha’s left in charge of Mount Vernon... (full context)
Chapter 3
Slavery and Paternalism Theme Icon
Freedom and Agency Theme Icon
...is more work than the seven slaves the Washington have brought along can handle, so Tobias Lear begins to bring in additional white servants. This, Dunbar writes, is likely the first time... (full context)
Chapter 4
Slavery and Paternalism Theme Icon
Freedom and Agency Theme Icon
...on High Street, Washington builds additional accommodations for his “entourage” of slaves—as well as for Tobias Lear , Lear’s wife Mary, their son Benjamin, and the Lear’s 20-odd slaves and servants who... (full context)
Chapter 5
Slavery and Paternalism Theme Icon
The Creation of America Theme Icon
Freedom and Agency Theme Icon
Martha Washington enlists the help of Tobias Lear in coming up with a system that will discreetly yet effectively allow their family to... (full context)
Slavery and Paternalism Theme Icon
The Creation of America Theme Icon
Freedom and Agency Theme Icon
...he needs to protect his reputation amidst growing antislavery sentiment in the North. He urges Tobias Lear to keep his missives secret, and he urges Martha to keep her slaves in the... (full context)
Slavery and Paternalism Theme Icon
Freedom and Agency Theme Icon
...for himself, but for his daughters back in Mount Vernon and for Richmond. Hercules promises Tobias Lear that he has no intention of taking advantage of the opportunity for freedom, which would... (full context)
Slavery and Paternalism Theme Icon
Freedom and Agency Theme Icon
The Washingtons’ “slave shuffle,” as Dunbar calls it, is successful for many years. Tobias Lear is instrumental in helping the Washingtons to keep their plot going. Lear reveals in private... (full context)
Chapter 13
The Creation of America Theme Icon
...soon after dinner, and by the morning, it is clear that Washington needs a doctor. Tobias Lear calls a friend of Washington’s, who lets some of Washington’s blood—an 18th-century medical practice—before a... (full context)