An elderly member of Jeanette’s church and Jeanette’s first—and only—childhood friend. It is Elsie who visits Jeanette in the hospital most frequently when Jeanette is recovering from surgery on her adenoids, and Elsie who encourages Jeanette to make creative religious-themed projects for school despite her classmates’ and teachers’ disdain for them. Elsie also allows Jeanette and Melanie to sleep over at her house. It’s revealed that Elsie knew what the two of them were up to the entire time, but wanted to shelter them from harm. Elsie does eventually reveal the truth of Melanie and Jeanette’s affair to Miss Jewsbury, and as Jeanette grows older Elsie grows increasingly sick and is frequently absent from church services and events. When Jeanette is called out as a sinner in front of her congregation, though, Elsie stands up for her, and calls on the church to stop attacking Jeanette and do something to actually help her come to terms with who she is. It is the last time Jeanette ever sees Elsie, as she is soon after expelled from the church and Elsie, unbeknownst to Jeanette, passes away. Elsie’s death is a major moment of reckoning for Jeanette, who, as a result of being cast out of the church, is not even made aware of her friend’s death. When Jeanette, who works at the local funeral parlor, serves ice cream to church congregants during Elsie’s wake, chaos breaks out as members of the community balk at Jeanette’s presence among them, though it was Jeanette who was perhaps closest to Elsie out of all of them. Elsie’s arc ties in most directly with themes of women and womanhood, as she is one of Jeanette’s first models of kindness and piety without agenda, meanness, or desire for control.