Abigail asks
Gibbie if he has ever heard the story of
Treasure Island, and volunteers to tell it to him. As she begins, Abigail realizes that if Gibbie does not die, only
Dovey and
Judah are left to fulfill the second half of the prophecy, and momentarily pauses, letting the weight of her realization sink in. After a moment, Gibbie begs her to go on, and she does, but cannot stop herself from quietly fearing that it will be Judah who dies.