The Ministry of Utmost Happiness

by

Arundhati Roy

The Ministry of Utmost Happiness: Chapter 2 Summary & Analysis

Summary
Analysis
Anjum is born the fourth of five children. The first three are girls. At birth, the midwife presents Anjum to her mother as a boy, and her mother, Jahanara Begum, is absolutely thrilled. She has been wanting a boy for years, and has already picked out a name—Aftab. But when the sun rises the day after Aftab’s birth, Jahanara picks up her newborn child only to discover, underneath his tiny penis, “a small, unformed, but undoubtedly girl-part.” When she sees that her child is intersex, Jahanara is devastated. She even contemplates killing herself and the baby.
Jahanara’s eagerness to have a baby boy demonstrates the extent to which the male gender is privileged over the female in Jahanara’s society. Her impulse to kill herself and the baby when she realizes Aftab is intersex reveals the glaring intolerance that abounds in her community: she finds the idea of having a child who doesn’t fit into strict gender categories to be so unbearable that she thinks it might be better for the child not to live at all.
Themes
Gender Identity, Social Division, and Coexistence  Theme Icon
Jahanara’s confusion and disappointment leads her to feel terrified of her own child. She thinks to herself that in Urdu, the only language she knows, everything has a gender—except her own child. Of course, she remembers, even in Urdu there are words for people like Aftab: Hijra and Kinnar. Still, she thinks to herself “two words do not make a language. Was it possible to live outside languages?” She isn’t able to answer her question, and worries for her child.
Throughout the novel, Roy examines language’s ability to describe reality. In this passage, Jahanara unknowingly engages with an age-old philosophical question: is language created in response to reality, or is reality created in response to language? She thinks that because there are no words for people like Aftab, they can’t exist. This line of thinking, though, shows how people sometimes allow language’s limitations to limit their tolerance for difference.
Themes
Gender Identity, Social Division, and Coexistence  Theme Icon
Social Hierarchy vs. Social Inclusivity  Theme Icon
Ultimately, Jahanara resolves to keep her baby’s gender a secret. But she does decide to take little Aftab to a sacred place to bless him, the shrine of Hazrat Sarmad Shaheed. She doesn’t usually go to this particular shrine, but feels called to it on this particular occasion, “perhaps […] drawn to the strange people she had seen camped there […] the kind of people who in her earlier life she would not have deigned to even glance at unless they’d crossed her path. Suddenly they seem[] to be the most important people in the world.”
In this moment, Jahanara’s choice of a shrine is significant. By writing that the people who frequent the shrine are the type Jahanara wouldn’t normally even look at, Roy implies that the shrine-goers are socially marginalized. Jahanara’s sudden belief that they are the “most important people in the world” demonstrates that Aftab’s birth has already begun to change Jahanara’s relationship to social hierarchy. She is more accepting of those on the margins of society because she recognizes her child to be one of them.
Themes
Gender Identity, Social Division, and Coexistence  Theme Icon
Social Hierarchy vs. Social Inclusivity  Theme Icon
Religion and Power Theme Icon
Shaheed was an Armenian Jewish merchant who travelled to Delhi to be with his beloved, a young Hindu boy. Later in life, Shaheed converted to Islam, which he also ultimately renounced. At the end of his life, he wandered the streets, naked, living as an ascetic and accepting alms. He was ultimately arrested, and the king tried to force him to admit there was no God but the Muslim God. Because this was contrary to his belief, Shaheed refused, and was beheaded. At his shrine, his “insubordinate spirit […] celebrate[s] (but never preach[es]) the virtue of spirituality over sacrament, simplicity over opulence and stubborn, ecstatic love even when faced with the prospect of annihilation.” Jahanara asks the spirit of Shaheed to bless her Aftab, and he does.
Shaheed’s story is an archetype of resilience and hope in the face of difficulty. Over the course of her life, Anjum also develops and makes use of her own “insubordinate spirit” and love “in the face of annihilation.” Undoubtedly, Anjum will live a life on the margins of society, and because of this position, she will experience many difficulties. However, Shaheed’s blessing provides her with resilience and strength of character to navigate these challenges.
Themes
Resilience and Hope Theme Icon
Social Hierarchy vs. Social Inclusivity  Theme Icon
Religion and Power Theme Icon
Quotes
Get the entire The Ministry of Utmost Happiness LitChart as a printable PDF.
The Ministry of Utmost Happiness PDF
Aftab passes as a normal boy until he is five years old. Jahanara waits for his “girl part to heal,” and meanwhile Aftab starts going to school, where he particularly enjoys singing lessons. His voice is high and sweet, and Jahanara sends him to Ustad Hameed Khan, a renowned young musician. Aftab excels at singing, and his high voice allows him to sing even female parts. For this, adults celebrate him, but other children tease him. Eventually, the teasing becomes so bad that Aftab wants to give up music classes. But Ustad Hameed won’t hear of it, and gives Aftab lessons on his own.
This is the first moment in the novel where readers see the way that Aftab sees himself—not how his parents or society see him. While it is clear that Jahanara wants more than anything for Aftab to be traditionally masculine, Aftab’s relationship style of singing reveals that he may have a more feminine nature rather than a masculine one.
Themes
Gender Identity, Social Division, and Coexistence  Theme Icon
Social Hierarchy vs. Social Inclusivity  Theme Icon
The time comes for Aftab to have his circumcision, and although Jahanara attempts to put off this rite of passage, there comes a time when she can no longer avoid it. Desperate, she finally confides in her husband, Mulaqat Ali, and tells him their son is intersex. Once a successful tradesman, the business Mulaqat worked at selling beverages weakened with the violence of partition, and the arrival of Coca-Cola in India. He works as an herbalist to supplement his income, and can trace his family lineage back to the Mongol Emperor Changez Khan. Fond of Urdu poetry, Mulaqat often has a verse of a poem suitable for any situation—but when his wife tells him about their son, no comforting poem comes to mind.
The story about Mulaqat Ali’s failed business is the first moment in the novel where Roy explicitly discusses the ways in which capitalism has affected the characters. Coca-Cola represents the arrival of globalist capitalism in India. The fact that it weakens Mulaqat’s business selling a beverage traditional to the region demonstrates the power American companies have under capitalism to weaken not only the economies of Third World countries, but also the survival of their unique cultures.
Themes
Corruption, Political Violence, and Capitalism Theme Icon
Gender Identity, Social Division, and Coexistence  Theme Icon
Mulaqat comes to the conclusion that he and his wife need to take Aftab to Dr. Ghulam Nabi, a “sexologist.” Dr. Nabi declares that Aftab is not technically a Hijra, what he defines as a male trapped in a female body. Indeed, male traits seem to be more dominant, but the doctor warns Aftab’s parents that “Hijra tendencies”—behavioral as well as physical—are not likely to go away. He prescribes Aftab some pills and recommends a surgeon who could seal Aftab’s “girl-part.”
Readers are introduced to the word Hijra, which is a very important term over the course of the novel. But Dr. Nabi’s description of the term is confusing: by saying Aftab is not a male trapped in a female body, he implies that he can tell by way of someone’s physical appearance what their gender identity is. This perspective on gender is continuously challenged as the novel unfolds.
Themes
Gender Identity, Social Division, and Coexistence  Theme Icon
Mulaqat decides Aftab will get the gender-change surgery, and while he saves up money, he resolves to tell his son stories about his Mongol ancestors. The men were fierce warriors, but Aftab is captured by the story of a warrior queen, and finds himself wanting to be her. While his siblings all go to school, Aftab stays at home, observing the neighborhood. One day he sees a tall, thin woman “wearing bright lipstick, gold high heels and a shiny, green satin salwar kameez” and, again, wants to be her.
In this passage, Mulaqat essentially tries to pitch masculinity to Aftab, attempting to convince his son of the merits of the male gender over the female one. Aftab’s desire to be the warrior queen reveals, with clarity, his true gender identity.
Themes
Gender Identity, Social Division, and Coexistence  Theme Icon
Aftab follows the fascinating woman all the way down the street until she enters a house with a blue doorway. He is intrigued by her in part because he knows that if she were really a woman, she wouldn’t have been allowed to dress that way—she would have had to wear a burqa or at the very least a head covering. Aftab longs to be her, to have her graceful walk and stylish clothing—for “it [is] not Aftab’s girl-part that [is] just an appendage.”
Aftab’s observation that the woman, who is a Hijra, wouldn’t be able to dress that way if she were a “real” woman is interesting, and complicates readers’ understanding of Hijras as being marginalized, oppressed, and discriminated against. In some ways, Hijras are more powerful than cis-gendered women in the world of the novel and have more liberty to express themselves freely. In this way, the margins of society are not just a place of oppression, but also a place of liberation.
Themes
Gender Identity, Social Division, and Coexistence  Theme Icon
Social Hierarchy vs. Social Inclusivity  Theme Icon
Every day, Aftab stands outside the house, which he learns is called the Khwabgah, or “house of dreams.” At first, the residents of the house all shoo him away, not wanting to upset his father. But Aftab sticks around, runs errands for them, and occasionally massages their feet. Eventually, they let him in. Aftab is fascinated by the house and its residents, mostly Hijras. Kulsoom Bi is the head of the house, and Aftab befriends Nimmo, a Hijra who “would have been beautiful but for her fast-growing facial hair” who is “obsessed with Western women’s fashion.”
The meaning “house of dreams” for the Khwabgah has various significations in the story. Firstly, for Aftab it is the place of his dreams, a space that he never has known could exist but where he sees he will be able to express himself in ways that he has never imagined possible in the rest of the world. Secondly, there is a lot of language surrounding the Khwabgah and other spaces Anjum inhabits in the story that describes them as being separate from the real world. The Khwabgah, for being so different from the rest of society, exists almost as a sort of parallel universe, as a dream world.
Themes
Gender Identity, Social Division, and Coexistence  Theme Icon
Social Hierarchy vs. Social Inclusivity  Theme Icon
One day, Nimmo asks Aftab why God made Hijras. She answers her own question, saying that it was an experiment, that God wanted to create something that was totally incapable of happiness. Aftab protests, saying he loves the Khwabgah and that everyone seems happy there. Nimmo disagrees, going on to say that everything that makes “normal people” unhappy is outside of them—cost of living, abusive husbands, disappointing children, Hindu-Muslim conflicts. But, she says, for Hijras, “The war is inside us. Indo-Pak is inside us.”
Here, Nimmo’s view on what it means to be a Hijra starkly contrasts with Aftab’s. While Aftab sees beauty in the world of the Khwabgah and the expressions of those who live there, Nimmo sees a group of people who are incapable of happiness because their identities are so marginalized that they do not even make sense to mainstream society. By comparing being a Hijra to having an internal India-Pakistan conflict, Nimmo demonstrates that she believes the difficulty Hijras face doesn’t come from a society that doesn’t respect their identity, but rather from a genuine internal conflict between the masculine and feminine identities.
Themes
Corruption, Political Violence, and Capitalism Theme Icon
Gender Identity, Social Division, and Coexistence  Theme Icon
Social Hierarchy vs. Social Inclusivity  Theme Icon
Quotes
When Nimmo says this, Aftab wants to say she’s wrong, because he loves the Khwabgah. But a couple years later, when his body begins to change, he understands the suffering she speaks of. He becomes tall and muscular, and, worst of all, develops a deep, masculine voice. He resolves never to sing again, except in jest. This, for him, is the last straw—without music, there is nothing tying him to the Duniya, or the real world. He steals some of his parents’ money, packs up his things, and moves into the Khwabgah.
Here, readers realize that Aftab’s positive perspective on the Khwabgah and on Hijras in the previous passage is largely born of naivete. When Aftab himself begins to experience his body behaving in ways that conflict with his gender identity, he understands the deep internal conflict Nimmo has spoken of. His choice to move outside of the Duniya, the real world, demonstrates that he has fully recognized himself as a marginalized person, and chosen to embrace both the joys and challenges of that experience.
Themes
Gender Identity, Social Division, and Coexistence  Theme Icon
Social Hierarchy vs. Social Inclusivity  Theme Icon
At first, Jahanara begs Aftab to leave the Khwabgah, but he refuses. She resolves to meet with him every so often at the shrine of Hazrat Sarmad Shaheed. Mulaqat, ashamed, resolves to cut all ties with his former son. Meanwhile, Aftab becomes Anjum, eventually to become Delhi’s most famous Hijra. She is coveted by NGO’s and journalists, who assume her traditional Muslim family has abused her. She responds that she was the one who had been cruel.
Here, Jahanara’s dedication to her child contrasts with Mulaqat Ali’s refusal to acknowledge Anjum. Jahanara highlights how an acceptance of social difference fosters greater social connection, while Mulaqat’s insistence on adhering to social norms and structures isolates him from his own child.
Themes
Gender Identity, Social Division, and Coexistence  Theme Icon
Social Hierarchy vs. Social Inclusivity  Theme Icon
Finally, at the Khwabgah, Anjum is able to dress the way she’s always dreamed of. She gets her nose pierced and wears elaborate feminine clothes, pulling her short hair back and weaving it into a braid of extensions. On Anjum’s 18th birthday, Kulsoom Bi throws her a party, and, that night, she dreams that she is “a new bride on her wedding night.” To her dismay, she wakes up to find that she had an orgasm during the night, and came onto her new red sari. Dismayed, Anjum speaks with Kulsoom Bi, who comforts her saying that Hijras are bodies “in which a Holy Soul lives.” Kulsoom Bi also encourages Anjum to undergo gender transition surgery, saying that it is not against Islam.
Kulsoom Bi’s optimistic interpretation of what it means to be a Hijra contrasts with the Indo-Pak metaphor that Nimmo shared with Anjum. Kulsoom Bi’s attitude demonstrates her celebration of the Hijra identity, which is even based on her Muslim faith. The fact that she needs to tell Anjum that the surgery is not against Islam suggests that there are people who argue that it is. Kulsoom Bi, then, has developed an interpretation of her own religion that is inclusive rather than exclusionary, welcoming of difference rather than punishing of it.
Themes
Gender Identity, Social Division, and Coexistence  Theme Icon
Religion and Power Theme Icon
Anjum decides to have the surgery with Dr. Mukhtar, who works with many of the residents of the Khwabgah. After removing her penis, Anjum feels much better physically. Dr. Mukhtar also gives Anjum pills that “undeepen her voice” but also give it “a peculiar, rasping quality, which sometimes sound[s] like two voices quarreling with each other instead of one.” In this state, with her “patched up body parts,” Anjum lives in the Khwabgah for 30 years—until, suddenly, she announces that she wants to leave.
Here, the medicine that makes Anjum’s voice sound like “two voices quarreling with each other instead of one” further emphasizes the idea that Hijras are constantly at war within themselves, experiencing their own version of Indo-Pak. Anjum has chosen to get the surgery to come closer to presenting as and feeling like a woman, but the effect the pills have on her voice render her someone forever in between worlds and identities, unable to fit into any specific category.
Themes
Gender Identity, Social Division, and Coexistence  Theme Icon
When Anjum announces that she wants to leave the Khwabgah, no one takes her seriously at first. Even she herself isn’t sure why she does, but she fantasizes about living in her own home, being a mother to Zainab, and living “like an ordinary person.” She wonders, though, if a life like that is “reasonable […] on the part of someone like herself.”
In this moment, Anjum reckons with her desire to live in the Duniya as a “normal person,” without being sure if that is possible for someone with her gender identity. This suggests that Anjum’s choice to live outside of the Duniya isn’t just a rejection of the real world, but also a response to its rejection of her.
Themes
Gender Identity, Social Division, and Coexistence  Theme Icon
Social Hierarchy vs. Social Inclusivity  Theme Icon
Zainab is the person Anjum loves most in this world, whom she finds one day, an abandoned baby, on the steps in front of a mosque. Anjum offers the baby a finger to grasp, and Zainab responds. This shocks Anjum, as “being ignored instead of dreaded by the tiny creature subdue[s] what Nimmo […] call[s] Indo-Pak.” Adoring the feeling of acceptance, Anjum brings the baby home to the Khwabgah. She makes public announcements that a baby has been found, but, to her relief, no one responds. Zainab comes to call Anjum “Mummy,” and grows into a stubborn “bandicoot-like” little girl.
Anjum’s attachment to Zainab originates from the fact that the baby, unlike everyone else, does not reject Anjum or think that she is strange. From the description in the passage, readers can assume that Anjum longs to help others but fears that they will reject her assistance because of her Hijra identity. Zainab, of course, is unable to reject this assistance because she has not yet been indoctrinated into the norms that govern her society.
Themes
Gender Identity, Social Division, and Coexistence  Theme Icon
Social Hierarchy vs. Social Inclusivity  Theme Icon
Unfamiliar with the rites of motherhood, Anjum spoils Zainab at first. Discovering Zainab’s love for animals, Anjum gifts her a baby goat. When Zainab grows older, Anjum begins to tell her bedtime stories based on her own life, that are “entirely inappropriate for a young child.” Soon, though, Anjum learns to modify the stories to be child-appropriate. For instance, she euphemizes the “Flyover Story”—a time when the police attacked a party where Anjum and other Hijras were gathering and threatened to arrest them all for prostitution if they didn’t run home, and Anjum had to pee on a flyover—into a story where Anjum simply gets caught in the rain and goes pee outside. In this way, “Anjum beg[ins] to rewrite a simpler, happier life for herself.”
Anjum’s desire to tell Zainab the truth about her life demonstrates a certain isolation on her part. The fact that she would share these stories even with a child who is too young to understand suggests that part of Anjum longs to be seen and understood for everything she is. This desire, perhaps, stems from the fact that she no longer has close relationships with any of her family members, and wants to create that tight-knit connection with her new child. Her assumptions that Zainab can handle the brutal reality of the violence Anjum has experienced might also stem from the fact that as a child, Anjum had to deal with challenges far beyond those that a normal child experiences due to her gender.
Themes
Corruption, Political Violence, and Capitalism Theme Icon
Social Hierarchy vs. Social Inclusivity  Theme Icon
When Zainab turns five, Anjum takes her to have singing lessons with Ustad Hameed, her old music teacher. Sadly, the little girl has no talent for music, but does have a real passion for animals. Anjum gifts her with a rooster in addition to the goat, and, when it comes time, registers her for school. (Anjum’s brother, Saqib, and his wife are the official parents.) Sadly, Zainab falls too ill to go to school. She gets malaria, and then two bouts of viral fever. Worried, Anjum wonders if someone has put a hex on Zainab. She suspects Saeeda, a younger Hijra who is more modern than Anjum, who uses words like “transperson” and is Zainab’s second-favorite in the Khwabgah.
Anjum’s relationship with Saeeda exemplifies the tension between the traditional Hijra community and their modern counterparts. Interestingly, Saeeda is characterized as sophisticated for her use of English words, which allow her to participate in the Hijra or trans community in a more global context. Anjum’s clinging to the term Hijra, even though the word can be seen as offensive, can be interpreted not just as old-fashioned stubbornness but as a form of retaining the integrity of her language and culture.
Themes
Gender Identity, Social Division, and Coexistence  Theme Icon
Social Hierarchy vs. Social Inclusivity  Theme Icon
In addition to possibly hexing Zainab, Saeeda has also stolen Anjum’s spot as the most famous Hijra in Delhi. Her modern image and ability to switch between Western and traditional clothes better suits “the image of the New India—a nuclear power and an emerging destination for international finance.” An aging Ustad Kulsoom Bi sees the benefits of including members like this in the Khwabgah, and Saeeda is neck-to-neck with Anjum for replacing Kulsoom Bi as head of the house.
In this moment, Roy further explores Saeeda’s choice to express herself in a modern or Western way. Although readers may be unlikely to suspect that Hijras, who exists on the margins of society, would be affected by or even participate in the rise of globalization in India, it is clear that Saeeda’s way of expressing herself is a byproduct of globalization, of India’s increased participation with the English-speaking world.
Themes
Corruption, Political Violence, and Capitalism Theme Icon
Gender Identity, Social Division, and Coexistence  Theme Icon
One day, Anjum hears commotion in the Khwabgah and, fearing the worst, runs downstairs with Zainab. What she discovers is that the two commercial airlines have crashed into tall buildings in a city called New York. Anjum suspects that the hex Saeeda has put on Zainab has made the whole world sick, but she is the only one blaming a local Hijra for the attacks. Instead, Muslim communities across the world are persecuted. In India, political parties espousing the belief that India ought to be a Hindu republic rise to power. The “Poet-Prime Minister” makes a speech in which he says “The Mussalman, he doesn’t like the Other […] His Faith he wants to spread through Terror.”
This moment marks the beginning of increased discrimination against Muslims in India, which continues throughout the novel. The “Poet Prime-Minister,” an extremist whose “poetry” most often takes the form of propaganda, delivers an ironic speech. That he would blatantly single out Muslims for their apparent lack of religious tolerance belies his own total lack of acceptance of people of the Muslim faith in India. He leverages the 9/11 attacks to justify further violence against Muslims in his own country, even though they clearly have nothing to do with the events in New York.
Themes
Corruption, Political Violence, and Capitalism Theme Icon
Religion and Power Theme Icon
Anjum sees on the news that “all the prisons [are] full of young Muslim men” and “thank[s] the Almighty that Zainab [is] a girl. It [is] so much safer.” Meanwhile, Zainab’s health does not improve, and Anjum ultimately seeks the advice of a Muslim religious leader, who advises her to visit the shrine of Hazrat Gharib Nawaz in Ajmer. So, once Zainab has gotten a little better, Anjum resolves to make the trip with Zakir Mian, an old friend of her father’s, “too old to be embarrassed about being seen travelling with a Hijra.” He suggests that they visit the shrine of Wali Dakhani, an Urdu poet whom Mulaqat loved.
Anjum’s gratitude that Zainab is a girl is another moment in the story where the assumptions society makes about gender—that the masculine is inherently better than the feminine—is challenged. Furthermore, Roy’s observation that Zakir Mian is “too old” to be embarrassed about Anjum’s gender identity suggests that strong attachment to societal norms is something to be outgrown; the older and wiser someone is, the less particular they become about judging whether or not those around them are socially acceptable or marginalized.
Themes
Gender Identity, Social Division, and Coexistence  Theme Icon
Religion and Power Theme Icon
The two set off for Ajmer, and, for the first three days, Anjum calls the Khwabgah every day to check on Zainab. After the third day, the residents don’t hear from her, but they do see on television terrible news from Gujarat: 60 Hindu pilgrims have been burned alive in a train. Politicians declare it “the work of Pakistani terrorists,” and an “unofficial spokesperson announce[s] unofficially that every action [will] be met with an equal and opposite reaction.” This triggers an unprecedented chain reaction of Hindu extremist groups wearing saffron headbands murdering Muslims, attacking them in their homes and shops and on pilgrimages and even in the hospital.
In this moment, the government's persecution of India’s Muslim population becomes almost explicit. The fact that an “unofficial” spokesperson was given the airtime and media attention necessary to make such a declaration demonstrates the extent to which the government has little to no investment in serving or protecting the Muslim population. Furthermore, the phrase “equal and opposite” is woefully inaccurate in this case. The murders and attacks the Hindu extremists commit against the Muslim population far outweigh the original attack on Hindus.
Themes
Corruption, Political Violence, and Capitalism Theme Icon
Social Hierarchy vs. Social Inclusivity  Theme Icon
Religion and Power Theme Icon
Worried, Saeeda suggests that they keep the news on at the Khwabgah to see if they can find out what has happened to Anjum and Zakir Mian, whom they haven’t heard from. They look closely at footage of Muslim refugee camps in Gujarat to see if they can glimpse either. On TV, they learn that the shrine of Wali Dakhani has been razed to make room for a tarred road. Even so, pilgrims continue to leave flowers in the middle of the road where the shrine used to be.
The fact that pilgrims continue to leave flowers on the asphalt road in front of the shrine is a clear example of resilience and hope in the face of tyranny and the threat of violence. The flowers that they leave on the road get run over every day, but the pilgrims consistently replace them. The government’s choice to raze a popular Muslim shrine further demonstrates its willful oppression and persecution of the Muslim population.
Themes
Resilience and Hope Theme Icon
Religion and Power Theme Icon
The Khwabgah goes two months without hearing anything from Anjum. By that time, “the murdering [has] grown sporadic,” and Mansoor, Zakir Mian’s son, goes to Ahmedabad to see if he can find his father. On the way, he wears red puja threads to try and pass for Hindu. He never finds Zakir Mian, and instead learns that he has been murdered. He finds Anjum in the men’s section of a refugee camp—dressed in men’s clothing and with a short haircut—and brings her back home. After hugging a delighted Zainab, the first thing Anjum does upon returning to the Khwabgah is change into her preferred feminine clothes and put on makeup. She is subdued, and doesn’t seem happy to see the women of the Khwabgah. She is particularly unhappy that Zainab has begun to call Saeeda “Mummy” as well.
Here, Mansoor feels so unsafe for potentially looking like a Muslim that he shaves his beard—an important religious symbol in his faith—and, further, goes so far as to wear puja threads, traditionally associated with Hinduism. This demonstrates the extent to which the Indian state has made it clear that it will not protect Muslims. Mansoor clearly fears for his life, and so disguises himself as a member of another religion. Additionally, the fact that Anjum has been forced to present as masculine while in the refugee camp demonstrates mainstream society’s refusal to accept people with her gender identity.
Themes
Gender Identity, Social Division, and Coexistence  Theme Icon
Religion and Power Theme Icon
Anjum’s strange mood lasts for many weeks. She teaches Zainab a strange chant that nobody knows—the Gayatri Mantra, that she learned in the refugee camp at Gujarat. She says it is good to know for mob situations, so that Zainab can pass for Hindu if she needs to. One day, Anjum even gives Zainab a haircut and dresses her in boy’s clothes, explaining to the perplexed members of the Khwabgah that “it’s safer like this.”
Anjum’s choice to teach Zainab the Gayatri Mantra is similar to Mansoor’s choice to wear puja threads. Although these religious symbols mean nothing to the Muslim characters, Anjum and Mansoor are so terrified by the lawless persecution that their people face that they adopt religious behaviors that have nothing to do with their own beliefs.
Themes
Religion and Power Theme Icon
Ustad Kulsoom Bi does not like what Anjum has done with Zainab, and calls an emergency meeting. She speaks proudly of the history of the Khwabgah, reminding her fellow Hijras of their ancestors’ important role with Mughal royals in the historical Red Court. She reminds them of a sound and light show at the modern-day Red Court, in which at one point listeners can distinctly hear “the deep, distinct, rasping, coquettish giggle of a court eunuch.” Ustad Kulsoom Bi adores this part of the installation, for “to be present in history, even as nothing more than a chuckle, [is] a universe away from being absent from it, from being written out of it altogether.” Anjum remembers the time she herself went to see the installation, and a tourist asked to take her picture—it was the first time she was photographed.
Here, Kulsoom Bi and Anjum both celebrate moments in which they have felt acknowledged. Kulsoom Bi’s reflection on the importance of documentation speaks to the very real fear that many marginalized populations have of being erased from history. A form of oppression that Roy interrogates at length in the novel is the use of language and narrative control on the part of oppressors to make sure the marginalized population’s narrative will never be told and, consequently, will never be recognized as truth. The threat of this erasure is what causes Kulsoom Bi to celebrate something so small as the recording of a giggle that sounds like a Hijra.
Themes
Gender Identity, Social Division, and Coexistence  Theme Icon
Social Hierarchy vs. Social Inclusivity  Theme Icon
Anjum’s attention returns to the meeting, where Ustad Kulsoom Bi continues to speak proudly of the legacy of Hijras in India. She reminds the other girls that the Khwabgah is a place where “Holy Souls trapped in the wrong bodies [are] liberated.” But, she emphasizes, the key principle of the Khwabgah is manzoori, or “consent.” She reminds everyone that in the Duniya, people spread rumors that Hijras capture and castrate young boys. In keeping with the principle of consent, she says, Anjum cannot oblige Zainab to present as a boy, even if she thinks it makes her safer.
Kulsoom Bi’s insistence upon maintaining the integrity of the Khwabgah and of Hijras’ reputation in Delhi also stems from her desire to maintain control of the cultural narratives that are told about Hijras. Because the Hijra population is so marginalized and, consequently, so vulnerable, Kulsoom Bi feels an extra obligation to uphold the moral integrity of the Khwabgah and everyone who lives there.
Themes
Gender Identity, Social Division, and Coexistence  Theme Icon
Social Hierarchy vs. Social Inclusivity  Theme Icon
Anjum protests, insisting that Zainab is her child and she will do as she pleases with her, threatening to leave the Khwabgah with Zainab. Ustad Kulsoom Bi responds that the Anjum can go wherever she wants, but the child will stay in the Khwabgah. At first, Anjum’s threat to leave is mostly rhetorical, but as time passes, she begins to truly consider leaving her home of the past 30 years.
In this moment, Anjum’s true independence shines through. Her rebellious spirit prevents her from compromising on what she believes to be right, no matter what the consequences may be—and, in this case, losing her child, whom she has described as the person she loves most in the world, is a steep price to pay for freedom. She is willing to marginalize herself even further from society, leaving behind the only community that will accept her, in order to live by her own rules.
Themes
Social Hierarchy vs. Social Inclusivity  Theme Icon
Thinking Anjum is crazy for wanting to leave, the women of the Khwabgah go and visit Dr. Bhagat, a doctor who prescribes many of them with mental health medication. Fearing (erroneously) that the Hindu doctor will not understand that Anjum may be traumatized from what she experienced at the refugee camp, Saeeda doesn’t mention that Anjum was present in Gujarat, but does tell the doctor about Anjum’s anxiety and crazy desire to leave the Khwabgah. The doctor prescribes Anjum a medication, which she refuses to take.
The women’s relationship with Dr. Bhagat is interesting, as they seem to depend entirely upon him for their health care, and many of them take medication from him for their mental health. Roy never explicitly implies that the doctor pathologizes transgender people, but the fact that so many of the Hijras are so dependent upon the medication he prescribes invites readers to consider whether the doctor has pathologized their gender identity. The other interpretation, of course, would be that as marginalized people, living in a world that doesn’t respect them causes Hijras in particular to have poor mental health.
Themes
Gender Identity, Social Division, and Coexistence  Theme Icon
Social Hierarchy vs. Social Inclusivity  Theme Icon
Growing increasingly restless and unhappy, Anjum burns Dr. Bhagat’s prescription, along with a collection of photographs and articles of her that she has collected over the years, scaring Zainab so much that she moves all her things to Saeeda’s room. Heartbroken, Anjum packs a few of her things—her cupboard, two suits, and a pair of men’s shoes—and leaves the Khwabgah, headed for the graveyard behind the government hospital, where many of her family members are buried.
In this moment, Anjum first departs for the graveyard, where she is at the beginning of the novel. Anjum’s choice to move to a graveyard, where people go to die rather than to live, suggests that she wishes to withdraw even more extremely from the Duniya. She is completely isolating herself from the rest of the world, which, presumably, has caused her so much pain—for both her religion and her gender identity—that she no longer wishes to participate in it.
Themes
Social Hierarchy vs. Social Inclusivity  Theme Icon
Anjum sets up her belongings next to her father’s grave, among the “smack addicts” and stray dogs that populate the graveyard. Normally, she would be in danger in such a situation, but “her desolation protect[s] her.” Alone with her mind, she tries to shut out memories of what happened to her and Zakir Mian, but is unable to. She remembers how the Hindu extremists, “saffron parakeets with steel talons and bloodied beaks,” murdered everyone around her, tore them limb from limb and set them on fire. She remembers how she had feigned death but was discovered, only to be spared because “killing Hijras brings bad luck.” Indeed, the murderers seemed to be preoccupied with not acquiring bad luck—their “wrists wielding iron rods that bludgeoned people to death were festooned with red puja threads lovingly tied by adoring mothers.”
The revelation that Anjum’s Hijra identity has protected her from death adds another layer of complexity to Roy’s exploration of gender and privilege. Hijras are both looked down upon and feared, and in this way Anjum’s identity as a marginalized person is, in some ways, a social position of power and protection. The fact that the Hindu mobs are willing to murder thousands and yet fear acquiring bad luck for killing one Hijra is blatantly ironic. It demonstrates the extent to which religious extremism has prevented the mob from recognizing the humanity of their Muslim compatriots. Because their religious beliefs teach them that it is bad luck to kill Hijras, they don’t; and yet because their religious and political leaders either implicitly or explicitly condone the murder of Muslim citizens, they do.
Themes
Corruption, Political Violence, and Capitalism Theme Icon
Gender Identity, Social Division, and Coexistence  Theme Icon
Social Hierarchy vs. Social Inclusivity  Theme Icon
Religion and Power Theme Icon
Instead of killing her, the mob simply made her “chant their slogans,” and Anjum remembers repeating “Victory to Mother India!” While she suffers with her traumas in the graveyard, Anjum receives no visitors at first, but D.D. Gupta, a client of hers at the Khwabgah who works in construction in Iraq, comes to visit her before moving to Baghdad. When he visits, he brings her a cell phone, which she doesn’t use. Eventually, Saeeda brings Zainab a few times, Ustad Kulsoom Bi visits and gives Anjum an allowance from the Khwabgah, and even Saqib comes once a week. Ustad Hameed comes and sings for Anjum, which he knows to be possibly one of her only sources of joy in those difficult moments. Still, Anjum won’t be convinced to return to the Khwabgah.
The mob forcing Anjum to repeat their slogans may have been Anjum’s inspiration for teaching Zainab the Gayatri Mantra. In both cases, language functions as a tool to disguise marginalized populations. Although Anjum has chosen to withdraw from the world in order to process her trauma, it is clear from the large quantity of people that visit her that she will never be able to sever her real-world connections. Because of her loved ones’ dedication, Anjum is able to begin building a community even from such a marginalized position.
Themes
Resilience and Hope Theme Icon
Social Hierarchy vs. Social Inclusivity  Theme Icon
Over the years, Anjum’s grief subsides—her memories of the saffron parakeets of Gujarat dim and of Zakir Mian “will not go away” but become “a constant but undemanding companion.” As she heals, Anjum begins to present as a woman again, dying her hair with henna and replacing a dead tooth with a shiny, new implant. Meanwhile, she transforms her tiny shack in the graveyard into a real house, painting the walls fuchsia and even building a little kitchen. Saeeda and Zainab begin to visit again, and although Anjum is devastated at the permanent wound in their relationships, she is glad the child feels comfortable around her again. When authorities challenge Anjum’s right to live in the graveyard, she protests, saying she isn’t living there—she is dying there. The officers, who fear being cursed by a Hijra, leave her alone, allowing her to stay there for a small fee.
Over the course of the novel, Anjum changes her presentation of gender to reflect her overall wellbeing. Her presentation as a male when she first arrives in the graveyard is a reflection of her grief and trauma, whereas her gradual return to presenting as female reflects her slow but deliberate healing process as she begins to work through the trauma she suffered at Gujarat. The detail about the authorities charging Anjum a small fee to live in the graveyard speaks to the commonality of corruption among the Indian authorities—Anjum, and presumably anyone else, is able to get around the law, as long as she pays.
Themes
Corruption, Political Violence, and Capitalism Theme Icon
Resilience and Hope Theme Icon
Gender Identity, Social Division, and Coexistence  Theme Icon
Social Hierarchy vs. Social Inclusivity  Theme Icon
With time, Anjum’s home grows and grows. Imam Ziauddin eventually moves in permanently, and Anjum builds rooms over the graves of several of her relatives nearby. What’s more, her house starts functioning as a guesthouse—obviously, not too many people are interested in spending the night in the graveyard, and Anjum won’t let in just anyone, so business isn’t exactly booming. But still, her house and the community she forms around it slowly grows. She names the guest house Jannat, meaning “paradise.” Because she steals electricity from the mortuary, “where the corpses required round-the-clock refrigeration,” Anjum suffers no power cuts and keeps the TV on day and night, learning much about modern politics.
Anjum’s choice of name for her new home and guest house has an interesting double meaning. Naming it “paradise" suggests that she and the other inhabitants are no longer living and have gone to heaven, which speaks to Anjum’s total departure from the Duniya, or the “real world.” But secondly, calling the home paradise reflects Anjum’s high opinion of the home she has created for herself and will create for others. It is as if there, on the margins of a hellish and violent society, she has created a safe haven where she and others like her can be safe and happy.
Themes
Resilience and Hope Theme Icon
Social Hierarchy vs. Social Inclusivity  Theme Icon
Many of Anjum’s guests are other Hijras who have “fallen out of, or been expelled from, the tightly administered grid of Hijra Gharanas.” Among these is Nimmo, who over the years has become a large, beautiful woman and the owner of a successful business that sells goats for slaughter on particularly on Eid (a Muslim religious feast commemorating the end of Ramadan, a month of fasting.) Nimmo gifts Anjum with a beautiful ram to rear and slaughter for Eid one year. She raises him with great care, as she believes “love, after all, is the ingredient that separates a sacrifice from ordinary, everyday butchery.”
“Butchery” is also the language Anjum uses to describe the murders of Muslim pilgrims to Gujarat, and so her use of this term to describe the holy sacrifice of an Eid ram draws attention. She may be suggesting that the lack of love on the part of Hindu extremists for their Muslim compatriots is what makes possible such mass, thoughtless violence.
Themes
Social Hierarchy vs. Social Inclusivity  Theme Icon
Religion and Power Theme Icon
That Eid, Anjum hires a popular butcher to perform the sacrifice. Anjum dresses as a man to take on the role of “Man of the House” and is the one to say the traditional prayer before the ram’s throat is slit. She distributes “little parcels of mutton […] in the way it is Written: a third for the family, a third for nears and dears, a third for the poor.” For Eid, Anjum, Nimmo, Imam Ziauddin, and all of the addicts in the graveyard eat very well. Nimmo gifts Anjum a mobile phone, which, unlike the phone D.D. Gupta gifted her, she keeps.
Anjum and Nimmo’s active participation in Muslim religious ceremonies stands in silent protest to the members of society that believe being a Hijra goes against Islam. The fact that Anjum feels she has to present as a man in order to perform the ritual sacrifice is interesting, and suggests that she values the teachings and rules of Islam more than her own right to present as the gender that she wants, in the context that she wants to. By demonstrating that she is willing to make a sacrifice, so to speak, by not presenting as her preferred gender, Anjum demonstrates deep respect for her faith.
Themes
Gender Identity, Social Division, and Coexistence  Theme Icon
Religion and Power Theme Icon
The next morning, a second permanent guest arrives at Jannat Guest House: a young man who has dubbed himself Saddam Hussain. Anjum takes a liking to him, and offers him extremely cheap rent. Saddam works at the mortuary handling cadavers, as the upper-caste Hindu doctors whose legal job it is to perform post-mortems feel that they are above the task. Saddam and the others who perform his job are part of a caste called Chamars, whom the doctors think of as Untouchable. When he arrives to stay for good at Jannat Guest House, he has just been fired from his job after a fight with a doctor. He comes along with a white mare named Payal, and wears sunglasses, even indoors.
The Brahmin doctors’ insistence on making low-caste members of society perform post-mortems demonstrates the extent to which class oppression affects Indian society. Being a doctor is a prestigious job, which mostly upper-caste people have access to. And yet, their strong identification with being high caste prevents them from literally doing the prestigious jobs they have been hired for. It is unlikely that untrained staff are as qualified to perform accurate post-mortems as the doctors are. But because caste is so powerful in India, the doctors value establishing their authority and dominance over other castes more than they value doing their job.
Themes
Social Hierarchy vs. Social Inclusivity  Theme Icon
Saddam tells Anjum the story of how he burned his eyes looking at a tree. Previously, he was employed as a security guard at Safe n’ Sound Guard Service—where he used the name Dayachand, as no one would trust a Muslim security guard—when he was assigned to guard an art exhibition in which everything was made of steel. He was tasked with staring at a steel tree all day, making sure visitors did not touch it. However, the sunlight reflecting off of the metal burned his eyes, and when he asked for permission to wear sunglasses, he was denied because it looked unprofessional. After several weeks, Saddam’s eyes were permanently damaged, and he couldn’t open them in daylight without sunglasses, which he was fired for wearing. Upon leaving, he cursed at his boss, and Anjum laughs when he tells her what names he called his employer.
Saddam’s frank explanation that he chose to use the name Dayachand when he worked as a security guard because no one trusts Muslims show just how discriminated against and criminalized the Muslim population has become in India. What’s more, the fact that his boss would allow him to sustain a permanent injury on the job speaks to the widespread issue of class oppression. If low-caste, working-class people were respected, Saddam would have workers’ rights that would prevent such a thing from happening. But the combination of the caste system and capitalism creates a system under which his body is seen as a disposable tool.
Themes
Corruption, Political Violence, and Capitalism Theme Icon
Social Hierarchy vs. Social Inclusivity  Theme Icon
Religion and Power Theme Icon
Now unemployed, Saddam supports himself with a few odd jobs. For instance, he takes his horse Payal and stations outside of hospitals, pretending to be re-shoeing her. Superstitious Hindu relatives of the ill want to take the old horseshoe for good luck, and Saddam happily sells them. He also sells medication to poor people from villages who are tended to in Delhi’s government hospitals.
Perhaps because he has previously felt so oppressed by upper-caste Hindu members of society, Saddam chooses an odd job that takes advantage of their religious beliefs to rob them of their money. Just as Saddam has been taken advantage of by upper-caste Hindus’ participation in capitalism, he will take advantage of them to make money himself.
Themes
Corruption, Political Violence, and Capitalism Theme Icon
Religion and Power Theme Icon
Saddam soon partners with Anjum and Imam Ziauddin to begin another odd job when Anwar Bhai, the owner of a nearby brothel, arrives at Jannat with the dead body of one of his girls, Rubina. Anwar is unhappy for many reasons—Rubina’s eyes are missing, and, because of her profession, none of the graveyards in Delhi are willing to bury her. Sensing a business opportunity, Saddam tells Anwar that he’s come to the right place. The other sex workers that worked with Rubina begin preparing her body for the funeral, bathing, drying, and perfuming her. Two addicts help Saddam to dig a grave, and Imam Ziauddin says the prayers. Although initially both Anjum and Saddam refuse the 500 rupees Anwar offers them for the service, Saddam is “not one to pass up a business opportunity,” and the very next week Jannat Guest House begins to double as a funeral parlor.
The disrespect Rubina’s body faces shows how discriminatory mainstream society is against sex workers. The implication is that Rubina’s eyes were forcibly removed, out of disrespect for her and her profession, during the autopsy process. Because of Anjum’s commitment to providing a safe haven for the marginalized, beginning to provide funeral services for those who are deemed too unclean by the religious institutions that normally perform funerals is a natural business opportunity for her. In this way, by honoring with ceremony the deaths of those deemed unworthy of celebration by mainstream society, Anjum begins to create an even more expansive community for herself and others on society’s fringes.
Themes
Social Hierarchy vs. Social Inclusivity  Theme Icon
Religion and Power Theme Icon
As expected, Jannat Guest House and Funeral Services isn’t the typical funeral parlor. Indeed, like guests, Anjum either warmly welcomes or roaringly rejects petitions from those who want to be buried on her land. Her only “clear criterion” is that Anjum is only willing to bury “those whom the graveyards and imams of the Duniya [have] rejected.” Even the police, “whose rules [are] as irrational as Anjum’s” sometimes bring bodies to Jannat. Ustad Kulsoom Bi eventually is buried in Anjum’s graveyard, along with many other Delhi Hijras. (This is how Imam Ziauddin finally receives the answer to the question he asks at the beginning of the story about where Hijras go to die.)
Imam Ziauddin’s willingness to participate in the ceremony marks a change in consciousness for him—at the beginning of the novel, he asked Anjum where “people like her go to die” and at this point in the story readers realize he was referring to Hijras when he said “people like you.” Clearly, spending so much time around Anjum and other marginalized people has inspired him to have a change of heart, recognizing that even people who do not fit into the norms prescribed by society or even Islam are worthy of a respectful send-off when they leave this lifetime.
Themes
Gender Identity, Social Division, and Coexistence  Theme Icon
Social Hierarchy vs. Social Inclusivity  Theme Icon
Religion and Power Theme Icon
Anjum and Saddam live together, but don’t spend much time in one another’s company. Anjum likes to spend her days watching television, and on the news she learns that, in spite of the moderate but puppet-like Sikh president, Hindu conservative extremist groups are gaining power again. Gujarat ka Lalla is the Chief Minister of Gujarat and “talk[s] a lot about avenging centuries of Muslim Rule.” One Independence Day, Anjum is watching the news and listens to a speech given by the Sikh president, according to Anjum, “speak[s] like a marionette.”
The implication that the Sikh president speaks like a marionette invites readers to wonder who is controlling him. No matter who is behind the operation, a president who functions as a puppet of another organization is a clear sign of corruption in the country. The prevalence of Gujarat-ka-Lalla, who originally called for revenge against Muslims in response to the attacks on Hindus in Gujarat, warns of the rise of a far-right, religious extremist political movement.
Themes
Corruption, Political Violence, and Capitalism Theme Icon
Religion and Power Theme Icon
Saddened by the rise of the political right in her country, Anjum goes outside with Saddam and Biroo, their dog, to enjoy some tea. She begins to tell Saddam the “Flyover Story” that Zainab had loved when she was a little girl, and, suddenly, has the realization that she was “born to be a mother,” which she shares with Saddam. But Saddam is doubtful, and asks her how that would be possible; he reminds her that “there is, after all, such a thing as Reality.” Angrily, Anjum challenges him, saying, “Once you have fallen off the edge like all of us have […] you will never stop falling. And as you fall you will hold on to other falling people […] The place where we live, where we have made our home, is the place of falling people […] We don’t really exist.”
Here, Anjum makes clear the philosophy behind her work with Jannat Guest House and Funeral Services. She sees herself as already “fallen,” completely outside of the rules of the Duniya and mainstream society. Her use of the verb “fall” seems to mean “fail to conform.” She references her status as someone who doesn’t conform to society to challenge the limiting beliefs Saddam Hussain has created surrounding her chances at motherhood. Because he is still trapped in mainstream thinking, he believes someone like Anjum doesn’t have access to motherhood. But Anjum seems to be saying that because she doesn’t conform to society’s rules and expectations in any way, she cannot be limited by them.
Themes
Gender Identity, Social Division, and Coexistence  Theme Icon
Social Hierarchy vs. Social Inclusivity  Theme Icon
Quotes
Out of affection for Anjum, Saddam doesn’t push the conversation further. Indeed, in that moment, he realizes she’s the person he loves most in the world. After some silence, Anjum asks him why he calls himself Saddam Hussain. He reveals that the story has to do with “saffron parakeets and a dead cow.” His real name is Dayachand, and he comes from a family of Chamars, or members of the Untouchable caste. One day, he went with his father to collect a cow that had died on an upper-caste man’s property—members of the upper-caste wouldn’t dirty themselves by touching dead cows. Collecting these bodies was Saddam’s father’s profession.
Saddam’s former job performing post-mortems is very similar to his deceased father’s job in disposing of cow carcasses. That an Untouchable father and son would both perform similarly low-caste professions demonstrates how ingrained the caste system is in Indian society, and how strongly it prevents upward mobility. What’s more, Saddam’s real name, Dayachand, is a Hindu name—the one he used to pretend to be Hindu when he worked as a security guard, This suggests that he has converted from Hinduism perhaps in response to the caste-related oppression that he and his father have experienced.
Themes
Social Hierarchy vs. Social Inclusivity  Theme Icon
Religion and Power Theme Icon
On that day, the community was celebrating Dussehra, a festival that celebrates Hindu gods vanquishing evil demons. (“Audacious scholars” believe this festival might have been based on Aryan invaders vanquishing the indigenous rulers of the land.) As Saddam and his father were driving back with the cow carcass, they came across an official, whom they usually bribed, who asked them that day for more money. Saddam’s father couldn’t pay, so the official had his father arrested for cow-slaughter. After the festivities, a mob gathered in front of the police station, demanding that the “cow-killers” be handed over to them. Fearing for his life, Saddam mingled with the crowd. The police acquiesced, and the crowd beat Saddam’s father to death. He remembers how the crowd “splashed through puddles of his father’s blood as if it were rainwater,” and says to Anjum, “I was part of the mob that killed my father.”
Roy’s characterization of scholars who challenge the moral integrity of Hindu ceremonies is ominous. It suggests that scholars need to have courage to have opinions that don’t align with those of the mainstream religious majority—something that, in a true democracy, shouldn’t happen. That the police released a prisoner to a demanding mob is only further evidence of the Indian government’s corruption. Even though the police officially should protect citizens of all castes and religions, their own deeply ingrained beliefs that Untouchable lives don’t matter allows them to fail to do their job. It should be the police who administer justice, not a violent mob, and yet their bias against low-caste people allows them to ignore this responsibility.
Themes
Corruption, Political Violence, and Capitalism Theme Icon
Social Hierarchy vs. Social Inclusivity  Theme Icon
Religion and Power Theme Icon
Hearing Saddam’s words, Anjum remembers her traumatic experience with a Hindu extremist mob. Saddam goes on to say how shortly after his father was killed, his mother also died, and how he stole money from an uncle to come to Delhi. This was where he saw the video of Saddam Hussain’s hanging. Saddam was so impressed by the other Saddam’s stoicism when he was killed that he resolved to become a Muslim and take his name. Saddam says he wants to be like his chosen namesake: willing to pay the price for doing what he feels he has to do. Anjum tells Saddam that she has a friend who lives in Iraq, and shares with Saddam photos that D. D. Gupta has sent her. One of these is graffiti of the words of an American army general: “Be professional, be polite, and have a plan to kill everybody you meet.”
Saddam Hussain’s admiration from his chosen namesake only goes to show how his own government and society has failed him. The real Saddam Hussein is an antagonist in mainstream narratives of world politics. But the protagonists or “good guys” that the character Saddam Hussain has been taught to recognize in mainstream society have failed him. The high-caste Brahmins that he has been taught to admire disrespect and take advantage of him and his father. The police, an authority figure he was likely raised to respect, turn his father over to a mob that kills him. The lack of positive experiences with “good guys” in his own society allows Saddam Hussain to admire and want to replicate someone internationally recognized as a “bad guy,” so to speak, because Saddam has lost faith in the system to administer justice.
Themes
Corruption, Political Violence, and Capitalism Theme Icon
Social Hierarchy vs. Social Inclusivity  Theme Icon
Religion and Power Theme Icon
Once they have finished talking, Anjum and Saddam go back inside, where they “continue[] to float through their lives like a pair of astronauts,” although not without plans. Anjum wants to die, while Saddam wants to kill the official that condemned his father to death. Meanwhile, miles away, “in a troubled forest, a baby wait[s] to be born…”
The comparison of Anjum and Saddam’s lives to those of “astronauts” further emphasizes their almost total isolation from the goings-on of the real world and mainstream society.
Themes
Social Hierarchy vs. Social Inclusivity  Theme Icon