Joy Helpern is an old classmate of Nathan Zuckerman’s whom he reunites with at their 45th high school reunion. When they were teens, Nathan took Joy on a hayride and was disappointed when she wasn’t interested in getting physically intimate with him. At the reunion, she tearfully admits that she turned Nathan down back then because she was ashamed of her family’s extreme poverty and feared that if Nathan became her boyfriend, he would eventually escort her home and see how the family lived. Joy’s tearful admission affects Nathan deeply and builds on his growing anxieties about all the ways people misjudge and misunderstood one another.