Fear of the unknown underlies many of Van Cheele’s observations and deductions in “Gabriel-Ernest,” leading him to conclusions that, while probable, cannot actually be proven as fact. By showing how fear of the unknown can motivate—and distort—reasoning, the author demonstrates the limits of human knowledge and control of the world. Van Cheele is presented as a man of knowledge, but a man who wants to possess knowledge, not a man who truly wants to learn. While the first appearance of Gabriel-Ernest is quite an “unexpected apparition,” Van Cheele is most disturbed by the way that this naked boy’s presence undermines his mastery of the woods and their contents. As he talks to Gabriel-Ernest, Van Cheele “began to have an irritated feeling that he was grappling with a problem that was eluding him,” a foretaste of greater fears to come. When Gabriel-Ernest crosses the pool towards him moments later, he covers his throat “Almost instinctively.” Van Cheele’s inability to understand the boy feels like a primal threat, even though he can’t prove that the boy intends to harm him.
Unable to solve the mystery of the boy’s presence and thereby quell his fear, Van Cheele is abnormally quiet that evening at dinner. The next day, however, “his cheerfulness partially return[s],” as he believes that consulting Cunningham about what he saw in the woods will resolve his doubts. Unfortunately for Van Cheele, hearing Cunningham’s story only fills him with terror, leading him to uncharacteristically “[tear] off at top speed towards the station,” hoping to stop Gabriel-Ernest in time. Far from being something he can master, preferably easily, the reality of the mystery proves to be something that Van Cheele may be powerless to even understand, let alone control. His changing emotional states show how Van Cheele’s thinking is powered primarily by fear, not curiosity. When the cause of the Toop child’s death is ambiguous, it is unclear just how much Van Cheele’s fear of the unknown was justified, but his arrogance and pretense to understanding the world around him seem humbled by his encounter with Gabriel-Ernest—or have at least been depicted by Saki with pointed irony.
Fear of the Unknown ThemeTracker
Fear of the Unknown Quotes in Gabriel-Ernest
‘There is a wild beast in your woods,’ said the artist Cunningham, as he was being driven to the station. It was the only remark he had made during the drive, but as Van Cheele had talked incessantly his companion’s silence had not been noticeable.
‘A stray fox or two and some resident weasels. Nothing more formidable,’ said Van Cheele. The artist said nothing.
‘What did you mean about a wild beast?’ said Van Cheele later, when they were on the platform.
‘Nothing. My imagination. Here is the train,’ said Cunningham.
‘You can’t live in these woods,’ said Van Cheele.
‘They are very nice woods,’ said the boy, with a touch of patronage in his voice.
‘But where do you sleep at night?’
‘I don’t sleep at night; that’s my busiest time.’
Van Cheele began to have an irritated feeling that he was grappling with a problem that was eluding him.
‘What do you feed on?’ he asked.
‘Flesh,’ said the boy, and he pronounced the word with slow relish, as though he were tasting it.
‘Flesh! What flesh?’
‘Since it interests you, rabbits, wild-fowl, hares, poultry, lambs in their season, children when I can get any; they’re usually too well locked in at night, when I do most of my hunting. It’s quite two months since I tasted child-flesh.’
And then, as Van Cheele ran his mind over the various depredations that had been committed during the last month or two, he came suddenly to a dead stop, alike in his walk and his speculations. The child missing from the mill two months ago – the accepted theory was that it had tumbled into the mill-race and been swept away; but the mother had always declared she had heard a shriek on the hill side of the house, in the opposite direction from the water. It was unthinkable, of course, but he wished that the boy had not made that uncanny remark about child-flesh eaten two months ago. Such dreadful things should not be said even in fun.
‘Suddenly I became aware of a naked boy, a bather from some neighbouring pool, I took him to be, who was standing out on the bare hillside also watching the sunset. His pose was so suggestive of some wild faun of Pagan myth that I instantly wanted to engage him as a model, and in another moment I think I should have hailed him. But just then the sun dipped out of view, and all the orange and pink slid out of the landscape, leaving it cold and grey. And at the same moment an astounding thing happened – the boy vanished too!’
‘What! vanished away into nothing?’ asked Van Cheele excitedly.
‘No; that is the dreadful part of it,’ answered the artist; ‘on the open hillside where the boy had been standing a second ago, stood a large wolf, blackish in colour, with gleaming fangs and cruel, yellow eyes.’