Lasher’s main point is that automation has stripped people of their “dignity,” making it harder for them to maintain a sense of self-respect. This hints at the novel’s interest in the downsides of a society that has replaced physical laborers with machines. However, this point also strangely endorses the idea that people are defined by their jobs—after all, the implication is that people can only be happy if they feel “needed” and useful. Although
Player Piano offers such a harsh critique of the corporate world’s obsession with productivity, then, it also underhandedly supports the notion that a feeling of productivity lends meaning and value to life. In another sense, though, Lasher’s point about people liking to feel “needed on earth” brings to mind not just the idea of productivity, but also the importance of a more general sense of
purpose in life—something that isn’t necessarily tied to the economy or the corporate world.