Secrets

by

Bernard MacLaverty

The Protagonist Character Analysis

The protagonist of “Secrets” is an unnamed young man who lives with his mother and his Great Aunt Mary. At the beginning of the story, Great Aunt Mary is on her deathbed, surrounded by family. As the protagonist waits for her death, the story flashes back to his childhood, when the protagonist is a curious boy in a household that values privacy. He has a caring relationship with Aunt Mary, but whenever he asks her about her past, she reprimands him for being too inquisitive. He is especially curious about Aunt Mary’s friend, Brother Benignus, who he knows has written her many postcards over the years. Craving a deeper connection with his aunt, and wanting to satisfy his curiosity about Brother Benignus, the protagonist finally oversteps his aunt’s boundaries and breaks the trust they share: he sneaks into her room and reads her letters from her former lover, John, even though she has expressly forbidden him from touching the letters. He learns that, after enduring horrific trauma in World War I, John broke off his relationship with Mary and became a Catholic monk named Brother Benignus. As the protagonist realizes that John and Brother Benignus are the same person, Aunt Mary returns to her room to discover him invading her privacy. Deeply hurt, she slaps the protagonist and tells him that she will remember his betrayal until she dies. The story then returns to the present. Aunt Mary is now dead, and the protagonist is watching as his mother burns Aunt Mary’s papers, including John’s letters. By letting the letters burn despite his ongoing curiosity about Brother Benignus, the protagonist shows that he has learned how to respect Aunt Mary’s desires for privacy. Later on, when he is alone in Aunt Mary’s old room, the protagonist breaks down in tears. Because he grieves alone, his tears represent the pattern of emotional isolation he learned from Aunt Mary. However, the protagonist’s tears also carry a sense of release and healing, as he is able to acknowledge his grief and guilt over the incident, and to hope for his aunt’s forgiveness.

The Protagonist Quotes in Secrets

The Secrets quotes below are all either spoken by The Protagonist or refer to The Protagonist. For each quote, you can also see the other characters and themes related to it (each theme is indicated by its own dot and icon, like this one:
Secrets and Curiosity Theme Icon
).
Secrets Quotes

He was trembling with anger or sorrow, he didn’t know which. He sat in the brightness of her big sitting-room at the oval table and waited for something to happen. On the table was a cut-glass vase of irises, dying because she had been in bed for over a week. He sat staring at them. They were withering from the tips inward, scrolling themselves delicately, brown and neat. Clearing up after themselves. He stared at them for a long time until he heard the sounds of women weeping from the next room.

Related Characters: The Protagonist, Great Aunt Mary
Page Number: 281
Explanation and Analysis:

When he was bored he would interrupt her and ask about the ring. He loved hearing her tell of how her grandmother had given it to her as a brooch and she had had a ring made from it. He would try to count back to see how old it was. Had her grandmother got it from her grandmother? And if so what had she turned it into? She would nod her head from side to side and say, “How would I know a thing like that?” keeping her place in the closed book with her finger.

“Don’t be so inquisitive,” she’d say. “Let’s see what happens next in the story.”

Related Characters: Great Aunt Mary (speaker), The Protagonist
Page Number: 282
Explanation and Analysis:

He reached over towards the letters but before his hand touched them his aunt’s voice, harsh for once, warned.

“A-A-A,” she moved her pen from side to side. “Do not touch,” she said and smiled. “Anything else, yes! That section, no!” She resumed her writing.

Related Characters: Great Aunt Mary (speaker), The Protagonist
Related Symbols: The Letters
Page Number: 283
Explanation and Analysis:

“Who is that?” he asked.

“Why? What do you think of her?”

“She’s all right.”

“Do you think she is beautiful?” The boy nodded.

“That’s me,” she said. The boy was glad he had pleased her in return for the stamps.

Related Characters: The Protagonist (speaker), Great Aunt Mary (speaker)
Related Symbols: Miss Havisham
Page Number: 283
Explanation and Analysis:

“I thought maybe it was Brother Benignus,” he said. She looked at him not answering.

“Was your friend killed in the war?”

At first she said no, but then she changed her mind.

“Perhaps he was,” she said, then smiled. “You are far too inquisitive. Put it to use and go and see what is for tea.”

Related Characters: The Protagonist (speaker), Great Aunt Mary (speaker), John/Brother Benignus
Page Number: 283
Explanation and Analysis:

The only emotion I have experienced lately is one of anger. Sheer white trembling anger. I have no pity or sorrow for the dead and injured. I thank God it is not me but I am enraged that it had to be them. If I live through this experience I will be a different person.

Related Characters: John/Brother Benignus (speaker), The Protagonist, Great Aunt Mary
Related Symbols: The Letters
Page Number: 285
Explanation and Analysis:

I have been thinking a lot as I lie here about the war and about myself and about you. I do not know how to say this but I feel deeply that I must do something, must sacrifice something to make up for the horror of the past year. In some strange way Christ has spoken to me through the carnage.

Related Characters: John/Brother Benignus (speaker), The Protagonist, Great Aunt Mary
Related Symbols: The Letters
Page Number: 285
Explanation and Analysis:

“You have been reading my letters,” she said quietly. Her mouth was tight with the words and her eyes blazed. The boy could say nothing. She struck him across the side of the face.

“Get out,” she said. “Get out of my room.”

The boy, the side of his face stinging and red, put the keys on the table on his way out. When he reached the door she called him. He stopped, his hand on the handle.

“You are dirt,” she hissed, “and always will be dirt. I shall remember this till the day I die.”

Related Characters: Great Aunt Mary (speaker), The Protagonist
Related Symbols: The Letters
Page Number: 286
Explanation and Analysis:

Tears came into his eyes for the first time since she had died and he cried silently into the crook of his arm for the woman who had been his maiden aunt, his teller of tales, that she might forgive him.

Related Characters: The Protagonist, Great Aunt Mary
Related Symbols: The Fire
Page Number: 286
Explanation and Analysis:
Get the entire Secrets LitChart as a printable PDF.
Secrets PDF

The Protagonist Quotes in Secrets

The Secrets quotes below are all either spoken by The Protagonist or refer to The Protagonist. For each quote, you can also see the other characters and themes related to it (each theme is indicated by its own dot and icon, like this one:
Secrets and Curiosity Theme Icon
).
Secrets Quotes

He was trembling with anger or sorrow, he didn’t know which. He sat in the brightness of her big sitting-room at the oval table and waited for something to happen. On the table was a cut-glass vase of irises, dying because she had been in bed for over a week. He sat staring at them. They were withering from the tips inward, scrolling themselves delicately, brown and neat. Clearing up after themselves. He stared at them for a long time until he heard the sounds of women weeping from the next room.

Related Characters: The Protagonist, Great Aunt Mary
Page Number: 281
Explanation and Analysis:

When he was bored he would interrupt her and ask about the ring. He loved hearing her tell of how her grandmother had given it to her as a brooch and she had had a ring made from it. He would try to count back to see how old it was. Had her grandmother got it from her grandmother? And if so what had she turned it into? She would nod her head from side to side and say, “How would I know a thing like that?” keeping her place in the closed book with her finger.

“Don’t be so inquisitive,” she’d say. “Let’s see what happens next in the story.”

Related Characters: Great Aunt Mary (speaker), The Protagonist
Page Number: 282
Explanation and Analysis:

He reached over towards the letters but before his hand touched them his aunt’s voice, harsh for once, warned.

“A-A-A,” she moved her pen from side to side. “Do not touch,” she said and smiled. “Anything else, yes! That section, no!” She resumed her writing.

Related Characters: Great Aunt Mary (speaker), The Protagonist
Related Symbols: The Letters
Page Number: 283
Explanation and Analysis:

“Who is that?” he asked.

“Why? What do you think of her?”

“She’s all right.”

“Do you think she is beautiful?” The boy nodded.

“That’s me,” she said. The boy was glad he had pleased her in return for the stamps.

Related Characters: The Protagonist (speaker), Great Aunt Mary (speaker)
Related Symbols: Miss Havisham
Page Number: 283
Explanation and Analysis:

“I thought maybe it was Brother Benignus,” he said. She looked at him not answering.

“Was your friend killed in the war?”

At first she said no, but then she changed her mind.

“Perhaps he was,” she said, then smiled. “You are far too inquisitive. Put it to use and go and see what is for tea.”

Related Characters: The Protagonist (speaker), Great Aunt Mary (speaker), John/Brother Benignus
Page Number: 283
Explanation and Analysis:

The only emotion I have experienced lately is one of anger. Sheer white trembling anger. I have no pity or sorrow for the dead and injured. I thank God it is not me but I am enraged that it had to be them. If I live through this experience I will be a different person.

Related Characters: John/Brother Benignus (speaker), The Protagonist, Great Aunt Mary
Related Symbols: The Letters
Page Number: 285
Explanation and Analysis:

I have been thinking a lot as I lie here about the war and about myself and about you. I do not know how to say this but I feel deeply that I must do something, must sacrifice something to make up for the horror of the past year. In some strange way Christ has spoken to me through the carnage.

Related Characters: John/Brother Benignus (speaker), The Protagonist, Great Aunt Mary
Related Symbols: The Letters
Page Number: 285
Explanation and Analysis:

“You have been reading my letters,” she said quietly. Her mouth was tight with the words and her eyes blazed. The boy could say nothing. She struck him across the side of the face.

“Get out,” she said. “Get out of my room.”

The boy, the side of his face stinging and red, put the keys on the table on his way out. When he reached the door she called him. He stopped, his hand on the handle.

“You are dirt,” she hissed, “and always will be dirt. I shall remember this till the day I die.”

Related Characters: Great Aunt Mary (speaker), The Protagonist
Related Symbols: The Letters
Page Number: 286
Explanation and Analysis:

Tears came into his eyes for the first time since she had died and he cried silently into the crook of his arm for the woman who had been his maiden aunt, his teller of tales, that she might forgive him.

Related Characters: The Protagonist, Great Aunt Mary
Related Symbols: The Fire
Page Number: 286
Explanation and Analysis: