When the shape is gone, the directors realize that their visions were not identical: while
Moncharmin saw a skull,
Richard perceived the figure an old woman. They both conclude that they must have suffered from some kind of illusion and laugh about the entire episode. When they finally reach Box Five, they conclude that there is nothing to be seen. They examine the various elements of furniture but notice nothing unusual about them. They conclude that they will watch
Faust from this very box on Saturday, as to prove to their tricksters that they cannot be fooled.