Merchants of Doubt

by

Naomi Oreskes and Erik M. Conway

Free market fundamentalism is the devout belief that unregulated capitalism is the only economic system under which democratic freedoms can survive. Mainly a holdover from the Cold War, it amounts to a more extreme version of the belief that unregulated markets will always allocate resources in the most efficient possible way.

Free Market Fundamentalism Quotes in Merchants of Doubt

The Merchants of Doubt quotes below are all either spoken by Free Market Fundamentalism or refer to Free Market Fundamentalism. For each quote, you can also see the other terms and themes related to it (each theme is indicated by its own dot and icon, like this one:
Science, Trust, and Public Policy Theme Icon
).
Chapter 5 Quotes

Anti-Communism had launched the weapons and rocketry programs that launched the careers of Singer, Seitz, and Nierenberg, and anti-Communism had underlain their politics since the days of Sputnik. Their defense of freedom was a defense against Soviet Communism. But somehow, somewhere, defending America against the Soviet threat had transmogrified into defending the tobacco industry against the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency.

Related Characters: Naomi Oreskes and Erik M. Conway (speaker), S. Fred Singer, Frederick Seitz, William Nierenberg, Ronald Reagan
Page Number: 164
Explanation and Analysis:
Conclusion Quotes

Free market fundamentalists can perhaps hold to their views because often they have very little direct experience in commerce or industry. The men in our story all made their careers in programs and institutions that were either directly created by the federal government or largely funded by it. Robert Jastrow spent the lion’s share of his career at the Goddard Institute for Space Studies—part of NASA. Frederick Seitz and Bill Nierenberg launched their careers in the atomic weapons programs, and expanded them at universities whose research activities were almost entirely funded by the federal government at taxpayer expense. Fred Singer worked directly for the government, first at the National Weather Satellite Service, later in the Department of Transportation. If government is bad and free markets are good, why did they not reject government support for their own research and professional positions and work in the private sector?

Related Characters: Naomi Oreskes and Erik M. Conway (speaker), S. Fred Singer, Frederick Seitz, William Nierenberg, Robert Jastrow
Page Number: 250
Explanation and Analysis:

Cornucopians hold to a blind faith in technology that isn’t borne out by the historical evidence. We call it “technofideism.”

Why do they hold this belief when history shows it to be untrue? Again we turn to Milton Friedman’s Capitalism and Freedom, where he claimed that “the great advances of civilization, in industry or agriculture, have never come from centralized government.” To historians of technology, this would be laughable had it not been written (five years after Sputnik) by one of the most influential economists of the second half of the twentieth century.

Related Characters: Naomi Oreskes and Erik M. Conway (speaker)
Page Number: 261
Explanation and Analysis:

What this all adds up to—to return to our story—is that the doubt-mongering campaigns we have followed were not about science. They were about the proper role of government, particularly in redressing market failures. Because the results of scientific investigation seem to suggest that government really did need to intervene in the marketplace if pollution and public health were to be effectively addressed, the defenders of the free market refused to accept those results. The enemies of government regulation of the marketplace became the enemies of science.

Related Characters: Naomi Oreskes and Erik M. Conway (speaker)
Page Number: 262
Explanation and Analysis:
Get the entire Merchants of Doubt LitChart as a printable PDF.
Merchants of Doubt PDF

Free Market Fundamentalism Term Timeline in Merchants of Doubt

The timeline below shows where the term Free Market Fundamentalism appears in Merchants of Doubt. The colored dots and icons indicate which themes are associated with that appearance.
Chapter 5
Science, Trust, and Public Policy Theme Icon
Capitalism and the Environment Theme Icon
...Fred Seitz worked for the tobacco industry as part of a broader campaign for “ free market fundamentalism ” and against government regulation. Using Tobacco to Defend Free Enterprise. Oreskes and Conway explain... (full context)
Chapter 6
Science, Trust, and Public Policy Theme Icon
Capitalism and the Environment Theme Icon
...didn’t reject science altogether, it did ignore climate scientists and any economists who disagreed with free market fundamentalism . (full context)
Conclusion
Capitalism and the Environment Theme Icon
In other words, the merchants of doubt believe in “ free market fundamentalism ”—they think that society will only be free if the economy is left completely unregulated.... (full context)
Capitalism and the Environment Theme Icon
The main problem with free market fundamentalism is that, empirically, it’s false. Free markets often aren’t the best way to allocate resources,... (full context)
Science, Trust, and Public Policy Theme Icon
Capitalism and the Environment Theme Icon
Media Bias Theme Icon
...in his calculations. Right-wing think tanks ardently defend Lomberg’s work, as Cornucopian thinking strongly supports free market fundamentalism . But it’s also wrong: climate change will likely accelerate, so future technology may not... (full context)