As Subhi’s imaginary friend, whatever the duck says actually comes from Subhi—and it’s surprisingly mature and cynical to note what Subhi (through the duck) says here about not knowing his ba’s stories. Subhi is gaining maturity, and the harsh reality, violence, and cruelty of the camps is, perhaps, becoming harder for him to deny. The flashlight and his friendship with Jimmie, though, offer Subhi hope and something positive to cling to.