Butterfly is one of the three master miniaturists trained by Master Osman and recruited by Enishte to work on the Sultan’s secret book. Extraordinarily handsome, his personality is defined by his desire to please others and his loyalty to great masters and the traditional style of miniaturist painting. Butterfly is Master Osman’s favorite miniaturist, and there are strong hints that Osman is in love with him. Other miniaturists who are jealous of Osman’s favoritism of Butterfly start rumors that Butterfly is an Erzurumi, and Butterfly makes a habit of going to the coffeehouse in order to disprove this. Of the three miniaturists, Butterfly is the least likely suspect in the murders of Elegant and Enishte.