The Sum of Us

by

Heather McGhee

Zero-Sum Thinking vs. Solidarity Theme Analysis

Themes and Colors
Zero-Sum Thinking vs. Solidarity Theme Icon
The Toll of Racism Theme Icon
American Values and Identity Theme Icon
Research, Persuasion, and Policy Change Theme Icon
LitCharts assigns a color and icon to each theme in The Sum of Us, which you can use to track the themes throughout the work.
Zero-Sum Thinking vs. Solidarity Theme Icon

In The Sum of Us, policy researcher Heather McGhee asks why the U.S. lags so far behind other developed countries when it comes to public goods (like infrastructure, healthcare, and public education) and quality of life (including wages, life expectancy, and violence). The problem, she argues, is that Americans can’t pass effective public policies because they’re divided by racism. Specifically, many white voters are stuck in a zero-sum paradigm: they assume that anything that helps people of color will hurt them, and vice-versa, so they automatically vote against anything that people of color support. Throughout the book, McGhee details how this zero-sum thinking is deeply embedded in American history and white culture, which has long depended on stealing Indigenous people’s land and Black people’s labor to flourish. But in the 21st century, the world is no longer zero-sum: most social and economic policies (like universal healthcare, increasing the minimum wage, and stopping climate change) would benefit everyone, including the vast majority of white people. Still, self-interested elites know that they can turn white voters against these policies by associating them with Black and brown people. So Republicans and conservative media focus on cultivating racial resentment—they teach white people that the government is giving away what is rightly theirs to “inferior and undeserving” people of color. This wins them white votes, which allows them to implement their real agenda of tax cuts, privatization, and deregulation, which only benefit the ultra-wealthy. And this corporate agenda‚ for McGhee, is the real problem: over the last half-century, it has made inequality skyrocket, the nation’s public goods deteriorate, and social progress stubbornly difficult to achieve.

McGhee argues that, to resolve its problems in the 21st century, the U.S. must replace zero-sum thinking with interracial solidarity: ordinary people must deliberately work across racial lines to build political coalitions around their shared values, goals, and policy demands. Throughout the book, McGhee shows how communities can overcome racism and achieve remarkable political progress through this kind of organizing. She calls this result the Solidarity Dividend—the bonus that Americans gain simply by choosing to unite rather than divide themselves. The book is full of compelling examples of Solidarity Dividends, like the Fight for $15 campaign winning minimum wage increases, white parents sending their children to majority-Black schools in an effort to integrate the U.S. school system, and the Maine People’s Alliance organizing white locals and African immigrants to convince the governor of the nation’s whitest state to expand Medicaid. All of these examples show that cross-racial solidarity is the key to revitalizing the U.S.’s economy and public life.

Related Themes from Other Texts
Compare and contrast themes from other texts to this theme…

Zero-Sum Thinking vs. Solidarity ThemeTracker

The ThemeTracker below shows where, and to what degree, the theme of Zero-Sum Thinking vs. Solidarity appears in each chapter of The Sum of Us. Click or tap on any chapter to read its Summary & Analysis.
How often theme appears:
chapter length:
Get the entire The Sum of Us LitChart as a printable PDF.
The Sum of Us PDF

Zero-Sum Thinking vs. Solidarity Quotes in The Sum of Us

Below you will find the important quotes in The Sum of Us related to the theme of Zero-Sum Thinking vs. Solidarity.
Introduction Quotes

“Why can’t we have nice things?”
Perhaps there’s been a time when you’ve pondered exactly this question. And by nice things, you weren’t thinking about hovercraft or laundry that does itself. You were thinking about more basic aspects of a high-functioning society, like adequately funded schools or reliable infrastructure, wages that keep workers out of poverty or a public health system to handle pandemics. The “we” who can’t seem to have nice things is Americans, all Americans.

Related Characters: Heather McGhee (speaker)
Page Number: xi
Explanation and Analysis:

Was it possible that even when we didn’t bring up race, it didn’t matter? That racism could strengthen the hand that beat us, even when we were advocating for policies that would help all Americans—including white people?

Related Characters: Heather McGhee (speaker)
Page Number: xvi
Explanation and Analysis:

The logical extension of the zero-sum story is that a future without racism is something white people should fear, because there will be nothing good for them in it. They should be arming themselves (as they have been in record numbers, “for protection,” since the Obama presidency) because demographic change will end in a dog-eat-dog race war. Obviously, this isn’t the story we want to tell. It’s not even what we believe. The same research I found showing that white people increasingly see the world through a zero-sum prism showed that Black people do not. African Americans just don’t buy that our gain has to come at the expense of white people. And time and time again, history has shown that we’re right.

Related Characters: Heather McGhee (speaker), Barack Obama
Page Number: xxi-xxii
Explanation and Analysis:
Chapter 1 Quotes

The story of this country’s rise from a starving colony to a world superpower is one that can’t be told without the central character of race—specifically, the creation of a “racial” hierarchy to justify the theft of Indigenous land and the enslavement of African and Indigenous people. […] This hierarchy—backed by pseudo-scientists, explorers, and even clergy—gave Europeans moral permission to exploit and enslave. So, from the United States’ colonial beginnings, progress for those considered white did come directly at the expense of people considered nonwhite. The U.S. economy depended on systems of exploitation—on literally taking land and labor from racialized others to enrich white colonizers and slaveholders. This made it easy for the powerful to sell the idea that the inverse was also true: that liberation or justice for people of color would necessarily require taking something away from white people.

Related Characters: Heather McGhee (speaker)
Page Number: 7
Explanation and Analysis:

For the common white American, the presence of Blackness—imagined as naturally enslaved, with no agency or reason, denied each and every one of the enumerated freedoms—gave daily shape to the confines of a new identity just cohering at the end of the eighteenth century: white, free, citizen. It was as if they couldn’t imagine a world where nobody escaped the tyranny they had known in the Old World; if it could be Blacks, it wouldn’t have to be whites.

Related Characters: Heather McGhee (speaker)
Page Number: 13
Explanation and Analysis:

Today, the racial zero-sum story is resurgent because there is a political movement invested in ginning up white resentment toward lateral scapegoats (similarly or worse-situated people of color) to escape accountability for a massive redistribution of wealth from the many to the few. For four years, a tax-cutting and self-dealing millionaire trumpeted the zero-sum story from the White House, but the Trump presidency was in many ways brought to us by two decades of zero-sum propaganda on the ubiquitous cable news network owned by billionaire Rupert Murdoch.

Related Characters: Heather McGhee (speaker), Barack Obama , Donald Trump
Page Number: 15
Explanation and Analysis:
Chapter 2 Quotes

A functioning society rests on a web of mutuality, a willingness among all involved to share enough with one another to accomplish what no one person can do alone. In a sense, that’s what government is. I can’t create my own electric grid, school system, internet, or healthcare system—and the most efficient way to ensure that those things are created and available to all on a fair and open basis is to fund and provide them publicly.

Related Characters: Heather McGhee (speaker)
Page Number: 21
Explanation and Analysis:

When the people with power in a society see a portion of the populace as inferior and undeserving, their definition of “the public” becomes conditional. It’s often unconscious, but their perception of the Other as undeserving is so important to their perception of themselves as deserving that they’ll tear apart the web that supports everyone, including them. Public goods, in other words, are only for the public we perceive to be good.

Related Characters: Heather McGhee (speaker)
Page Number: 30
Explanation and Analysis:

Even though welfare was a sliver of the federal budget and served at least as many white people as Black, the rhetorical weight of the welfare stereotype—the idea of a Black person getting for free what white people had to work for—helped sink white support for all government. The idea tapped into an old stereotype of Black laziness that was first trafficked in the antebellum era to excuse and minimize slavery and was then carried forward in minstrel shows, cartoons, and comedy to the present day. The welfare trope also did the powerful blame-shifting work of projection: like telling white aristocrats that it was their slaves who were the lazy ones, the Black welfare stereotype was a total inversion of the way the U.S. government had actually given “free stuff” to one race over all others.

Related Characters: Heather McGhee (speaker)
Page Number: 33
Explanation and Analysis:

The racial polarization of our two-party system has forced a choice between class interest and perceived racial interest, and in every presidential election since the Civil Rights Act, the majority of white people chose the party of their race. That choice keeps a conservative faction in power that blocks progress on the modest economic agenda they could support.

Related Characters: Heather McGhee (speaker)
Page Number: 38
Explanation and Analysis:
Chapter 3 Quotes

“These folks are gonna come out of the woodwork like bugs.”

Related Characters: Barack Obama
Page Number: 59
Explanation and Analysis:

I discovered that if you try to convince anyone but the most committed progressives (disproportionately people of color) about big public solutions without addressing race, most will agree … right up until they hear the counter-message that does talk, even implicitly, about race. Racial scapegoating about “illegals,” drugs, gangs, and riots undermines public support for working together. Our research showed that color-blind approaches that ignored racism didn’t beat the scapegoating zero-sum story; we had to be honest about racism’s role in dividing us in order to call people to their higher ideals.

Related Characters: Heather McGhee (speaker)
Page Number: 63-64
Explanation and Analysis:
Chapter 4 Quotes

The public conversation and the media coverage of the subprime mortgage crisis started out racialized and stayed that way. We’ve had so much practice justifying racial inequality with well-worn stereotypes that the narrative about this entirely new kind of financial havoc immediately slipped into that groove. Even when the extent of the industry’s recklessness and lack of government oversight was clear, the racialized story was there, offering to turn the predators themselves into victims. After the crash, conservatives were quick to blame the meltdown on people of color and on the government for being too solicitous of them.

Related Characters: Heather McGhee (speaker)
Page Number: 90
Explanation and Analysis:

And all of it was preventable, if only we had paid attention earlier to the financial fires burning through Black and brown communities across the nation. Instead, the predatory practices were allowed to continue until the disaster had engulfed white communities, too—and only then, far too late, was it recognized as an emergency. There is no question that the financial crisis hurt people of color first and worst. And yet the majority of the people it damaged were white. This is the dynamic we’ve seen over and over again throughout our country’s history, from the drained public pools, to the shuttered public schools, to the overgrown yards of vacant homes.

Related Characters: Heather McGhee (speaker)
Related Symbols: Public Swimming Pools
Page Number: 96-97
Explanation and Analysis:
Chapter 5 Quotes

At the worker center, I asked Melvin about how unions are perceived where he lives. “The people that we see, as soon as they see UAW, and even if you bring up union, they just think color. They just see color. They think that unions, period—not just UAW—they just think unions, period, are for lazy Black people….And a lot of ’em, even though they want the union, their racism, that hatred is keeping them from joining.”

Johnny agreed with Melvin’s assessment of his fellow white workers. “They get their southern mentality….‘I ain’t votin’ [yes] because the Blacks are votin’ for it. If the Blacks are for it, I’m against it.’ ”

Related Characters: Heather McGhee (speaker), Johnny (speaker), Melvin (speaker)
Page Number: 117
Explanation and Analysis:

The company was able to redraw the lines of allegiance—not worker to worker, but white to white—for the relatively low cost of a few perks.

Related Characters: Heather McGhee (speaker)
Page Number: 120
Explanation and Analysis:
Chapter 6 Quotes

The scale of their organization is as large as a political party, but they use front groups and shell companies to keep their funding mostly secret. The core philosophy that unites their economic aims with their attacks on a multiracial democracy is that a robust democracy will lead to the masses banding together to oppose property owners’ concentration of wealth and power.

Related Characters: Heather McGhee (speaker), Charles and David Koch
Page Number: 155
Explanation and Analysis:
Chapter 7 Quotes

Who your neighbors, your co-workers, and your classmates are is one of the most powerful determinants of your path in life. And most white Americans spend their lives on a path set out for them by a centuries-old lie: that in the zero-sum racial competition, white spaces are the best spaces.

White people are the most segregated people in America.

That’s a different way to think about what has perennially been an issue cast with the opposite die: people of color are those who are segregated, because the white majority separates out the Black minority, excludes the Chinese, forces Indigenous Americans onto reservations, expels the Latinos.

Related Characters: Heather McGhee (speaker)
Page Number: 168
Explanation and Analysis:

White children “who learn the prejudices of our society,” wrote the social scientists, were “being taught to gain personal status in an unrealistic and non-adaptive way.” They were “not required to evaluate themselves in terms of the more basic standards of actual personal ability and achievement.” What’s more, they “often develop patterns of guilt feelings, rationalizations and other mechanisms which they must use in an attempt to protect themselves from recognizing the essential injustice of their unrealistic fears and hatreds of minority groups.” The best research of the day concluded that “confusion, conflict, moral cynicism, and disrespect for authority may arise in [white] children as a consequence of being taught the moral, religious and democratic principles of justice and fair play by the same persons and institutions who seem to be acting in a prejudiced and discriminatory manner.”

Related Characters: Heather McGhee (speaker)
Page Number: 182-183
Explanation and Analysis:
Chapter 8 Quotes

Perhaps it makes sense, if you’ve spent a lifetime seeing yourself as the winner of a zero-sum competition for status, that you would have learned along the way to accept inequality as normal; that you’d come to attribute society’s wins and losses solely to the players’ skill and merit. You might also learn that if there are problems, you and yours are likely to be spared the costs. The thing is, that’s just not the case with the environment and climate change. We live under the same sky.

Related Characters: Heather McGhee (speaker)
Page Number: 205
Explanation and Analysis:

If a set of decision makers believes that an environmental burden can be shouldered by someone else to whom they don’t feel connected or accountable, they won’t think it’s worthwhile to minimize the burden by, for example, forcing industry to put controls on pollution. But that results in a system that creates more pollution than would exist if decision makers cared about everyone equally—and we’re talking about air, water, and soil, where it’s pretty hard to cordon off toxins completely to the so-called sacrifice zone. It’s elites’ blindness to the costs they pay that keeps pollution higher for everyone.

Related Characters: Heather McGhee (speaker)
Page Number: 213-214
Explanation and Analysis:
Chapter 9 Quotes

Over the years that I have sought answers to why a fairer economy is so elusive, it has become clearer to me that how white people understand what’s right and wrong about our diverse nation, who belongs and who deserves, is determining our collective course. This is the crux of it: Can we swim together in the same pool or not? It’s a political question, yes, and one with economic ramifications. But at its core, it’s a moral question. Ultimately, an economy—the rules we abide by and set for what’s fair and who merits what—is an expression of our moral understanding. So, if our country’s moral compass is broken, is it any wonder that our economy is adrift?

Related Characters: Heather McGhee (speaker)
Related Symbols: Public Swimming Pools
Page Number: 222-223
Explanation and Analysis:

In the absence of moral leadership, there are just too many competing stories. For every call to become an activist for racial justice, there’s a well-rehearsed message that says that activists are pushing too hard. For every chance to speak up against the casual racism white people so often hear from other white folks, there is a countervailing pressure not to rock the boat. If you want to believe that white people are the real victims in race relations, and that the stereotypes of people of color as criminal and lazy are common sense rather than white supremacist tropes, there is a glide path to take you there.

Related Characters: Heather McGhee (speaker)
Page Number: 223
Explanation and Analysis:

“Because no one wants to think that they are benefiting from a system that hurts other people. It’s much easier just to pretend like you don’t know.”

Related Characters: Angela King (speaker)
Page Number: 226
Explanation and Analysis:

Equality, freedom, liberty, justice—who could possibly love those ideals more than those denied them?

Related Characters: Heather McGhee (speaker)
Page Number: 242
Explanation and Analysis:

For all the differences among the world’s major religions, they all hold compassion and human interconnectedness as central values; they all subscribe to a sacred vision of a world without racism.

Related Characters: Heather McGhee (speaker)
Page Number: 252
Explanation and Analysis:
Chapter 10 Quotes

“I didn’t even know at the time that we had Africans in the city who spoke French. I had no clue, none.” The first man she spoke with, Edho, had just followed his wife and children to Lewiston from Congo. After a timid “Bonjour” from Cecile, she and Edho launched into the longest French conversation Cecile had had since her childhood, with Edho helping her recall long-gone words and phrases. By the end of the first session, she was exhausted but thrilled. “Just as an interested and curious person, when I was meeting these people, I just fell in love with them.” She laughs, knowing what that sounds like. “Not that I really fell in love with them, but I felt like I belonged with them.”

Related Characters: Heather McGhee (speaker), Cecile Thornton (speaker)
Page Number: 262
Explanation and Analysis:

The big and small public works our country needs now should be designed explicitly to foster contact across cultural divides, sending urban youth to rural areas and vice versa, and explicitly building teams that reflect the youth generation’s astonishing diversity. An analysis Demos did in the middle of the Great Recession found that one hundred billion dollars spent directly hiring people could create 2.6 million public service jobs; spending the same amount on tax cuts trickles down to just one hundred thousand jobs.

Related Characters: Heather McGhee (speaker)
Page Number: 274
Explanation and Analysis:

Wealth is where history shows up in your wallet, where your financial freedom is determined by compounding interest on decisions made long before you were born.

Related Characters: Heather McGhee (speaker)
Page Number: 277
Explanation and Analysis:

“It’s a powerful, liberating frame to realize that the fallacy of racial hierarchy is a belief system that we don’t have to have. We can replace it with another way of looking at each other as human beings. Then, once you get that opening, you invite people to see a new way forward. You ask questions like ‘What kind of narrative will your great grandchildren learn about this country?’ ‘What is it that will have happened?’ Truthfully, we’ve never done that as a country. We’ve been dealing with the old model, patching it over here, sticking bubble gum over there.”

Related Characters: Dr. Gail Christopher (speaker), Heather McGhee
Page Number: 287
Explanation and Analysis:

Everything depends on the answer to this question. Who is an American, and what are we to one another? Politics offers two visions of why all the peoples of the world have met here: one in which we are nothing more than competitors and another in which perhaps the proximity of so much difference forces us to admit our common humanity.

Related Characters: Heather McGhee (speaker)
Page Number: 288
Explanation and Analysis: