This Other Eden

by

Paul Harding

Teachers and parents! Our Teacher Edition on This Other Eden makes teaching easy.

Matthew Diamond Character Analysis

Matthew Diamond is a white man who spends summers on the mainland across from Apple Island. Although he admits in a letter that he can’t get over his natural dislike of Black people, he claims to want to help the residents of Apple Island. Working with a relief society, he founds a school on the island, teaching children during the week, and giving sermons on Sunday to everyone. Matthew Diamond notices Ethan’s potential as an artist and sends him away to stay with Thomas Hale and hone his craft. Matthew Diamond is a complicated character who embodies the contradictions of racism in early 20th-century America. At times, he seems to genuinely want to help the Apple Islanders, defending them when committees comes from the governor to inspect the island. Ultimately, however, Matthew Diamond has a patronizing attitude toward the islanders, and his actions indirectly lead to their eviction by drawing attention to the island.

Matthew Diamond Quotes in This Other Eden

The This Other Eden quotes below are all either spoken by Matthew Diamond or refer to Matthew Diamond. For each quote, you can also see the other characters and themes related to it (each theme is indicated by its own dot and icon, like this one:
Family Theme Icon
).
Part 1 Quotes

So Theophilus poked around the shack and brooded over the pile of sleeping children like a mother robin, wearing the dress and shopkeeper’s apron, and whenever any islander passed by he paused at his aimless chores or rose from the chair outside the door and came to the edge of the dirt yard and wrung his hands in an old red rag he took from the apron’s front pocket, nodded at the passerby and said, What lack ye, Mr. Diamond? What lack ye, Eha Honey? To the children he asked, What lack ye, my little salted cods? What lack ye, my little oysters?

Candace Lark never liked housekeeping and was no good at it anyway. A particular squalor surrounded the Larks’ shack when she had been in charge of domestic order. Much of that had been due to the children, who arrived one after another for eight years, counting the five that didn’t live. But even considering mothering and scant means and the necessity of staying home while Theophilus fished, Candace lacked instinct for tending her kids and shack.

Related Characters: Theophilus Lark (speaker), Matthew Diamond, Eha Honey, Candace Lark
Page Number: 27
Explanation and Analysis:

MATTHEW DIAMOND PUNCTUALLY arrived at his summer home in Foxden, visible right across the channel, on the evening of each June 20th and signaled his coming to the islanders by raising a U.S. flag up a pole in his yard the next morning at dawn.

Related Characters: Matthew Diamond
Related Symbols: Flag
Page Number: 39
Explanation and Analysis:

Bernard Richardson happened to be in the store one day and saw the postcards made from his photographs. He demanded Art Dunlop remove them.

Those are my pictures, they’re portraits of those people—and official documents, he said. They’re not for you to turn into a bunch of dirty jokes.

Art Dunlop stood behind the sales counter adding figures on a pad. He looked up and said, I guess you’re free to buy the lot if you care to. At retail.

Well, you don’t have my permission to—

Otherwise, you’re just about trespassing if you say anything more about it.

Related Characters: Bernard Richardson (speaker), Matthew Diamond
Page Number: 56
Explanation and Analysis:

THE MORNING AFTER the feast, Ethan woke with bleary eyes and a slight headache from the beer. He took the small circle of mirror that had been his mother’s from its shelf near his father’s bed and sat on the rocks on the west side of the island and drew four self-portraits.

Related Characters: Ethan Honey, Matthew Diamond
Page Number: 97
Explanation and Analysis:
Part 2 Quotes

He was hot, probably sunburned, again, on his arms and nose and face and his neck, too. The hot sweet hay perfume mingled with the cigarette smoke and he wanted to sit down but there was no natural place to do so in the middle of the field.

Related Characters: Ethan Honey, Matthew Diamond, Bridget, Thomas Hale
Page Number: 119
Explanation and Analysis:
Part 3 Quotes

Matthew answered, Yes, certainly, a well would do wonders, new, sounder cabins would help with the cold, woodstoves, too. I know two men here who are marvelous carpenters, and I am half decent myself. A bridge would help the islanders feel more connected to the town, and help people on the main come here with their washing or fishing lines that need mending. They could have horses and wagons, even, perhaps. They could even attend a proper church. Well, I, perhaps not right in town, then. There’s a Negro meeting house—church—the—it’s called the Abyssinian Meeting House—in Portland—they could get to more easily.

Related Characters: Matthew Diamond (speaker), Eha Honey, Zachary Hand, The Governor
Page Number: 155
Explanation and Analysis:

You have to leave the island.

Related Characters: Matthew Diamond (speaker), Ethan Honey, Esther Honey, Bridget, Eha Honey, The Governor
Page Number: 164
Explanation and Analysis:
Get the entire This Other Eden LitChart as a printable PDF.
This Other Eden PDF

Matthew Diamond Quotes in This Other Eden

The This Other Eden quotes below are all either spoken by Matthew Diamond or refer to Matthew Diamond. For each quote, you can also see the other characters and themes related to it (each theme is indicated by its own dot and icon, like this one:
Family Theme Icon
).
Part 1 Quotes

So Theophilus poked around the shack and brooded over the pile of sleeping children like a mother robin, wearing the dress and shopkeeper’s apron, and whenever any islander passed by he paused at his aimless chores or rose from the chair outside the door and came to the edge of the dirt yard and wrung his hands in an old red rag he took from the apron’s front pocket, nodded at the passerby and said, What lack ye, Mr. Diamond? What lack ye, Eha Honey? To the children he asked, What lack ye, my little salted cods? What lack ye, my little oysters?

Candace Lark never liked housekeeping and was no good at it anyway. A particular squalor surrounded the Larks’ shack when she had been in charge of domestic order. Much of that had been due to the children, who arrived one after another for eight years, counting the five that didn’t live. But even considering mothering and scant means and the necessity of staying home while Theophilus fished, Candace lacked instinct for tending her kids and shack.

Related Characters: Theophilus Lark (speaker), Matthew Diamond, Eha Honey, Candace Lark
Page Number: 27
Explanation and Analysis:

MATTHEW DIAMOND PUNCTUALLY arrived at his summer home in Foxden, visible right across the channel, on the evening of each June 20th and signaled his coming to the islanders by raising a U.S. flag up a pole in his yard the next morning at dawn.

Related Characters: Matthew Diamond
Related Symbols: Flag
Page Number: 39
Explanation and Analysis:

Bernard Richardson happened to be in the store one day and saw the postcards made from his photographs. He demanded Art Dunlop remove them.

Those are my pictures, they’re portraits of those people—and official documents, he said. They’re not for you to turn into a bunch of dirty jokes.

Art Dunlop stood behind the sales counter adding figures on a pad. He looked up and said, I guess you’re free to buy the lot if you care to. At retail.

Well, you don’t have my permission to—

Otherwise, you’re just about trespassing if you say anything more about it.

Related Characters: Bernard Richardson (speaker), Matthew Diamond
Page Number: 56
Explanation and Analysis:

THE MORNING AFTER the feast, Ethan woke with bleary eyes and a slight headache from the beer. He took the small circle of mirror that had been his mother’s from its shelf near his father’s bed and sat on the rocks on the west side of the island and drew four self-portraits.

Related Characters: Ethan Honey, Matthew Diamond
Page Number: 97
Explanation and Analysis:
Part 2 Quotes

He was hot, probably sunburned, again, on his arms and nose and face and his neck, too. The hot sweet hay perfume mingled with the cigarette smoke and he wanted to sit down but there was no natural place to do so in the middle of the field.

Related Characters: Ethan Honey, Matthew Diamond, Bridget, Thomas Hale
Page Number: 119
Explanation and Analysis:
Part 3 Quotes

Matthew answered, Yes, certainly, a well would do wonders, new, sounder cabins would help with the cold, woodstoves, too. I know two men here who are marvelous carpenters, and I am half decent myself. A bridge would help the islanders feel more connected to the town, and help people on the main come here with their washing or fishing lines that need mending. They could have horses and wagons, even, perhaps. They could even attend a proper church. Well, I, perhaps not right in town, then. There’s a Negro meeting house—church—the—it’s called the Abyssinian Meeting House—in Portland—they could get to more easily.

Related Characters: Matthew Diamond (speaker), Eha Honey, Zachary Hand, The Governor
Page Number: 155
Explanation and Analysis:

You have to leave the island.

Related Characters: Matthew Diamond (speaker), Ethan Honey, Esther Honey, Bridget, Eha Honey, The Governor
Page Number: 164
Explanation and Analysis: