In this moment, Tom uses the very things that the townspeople usually hold against Kya to argue for her innocence. Rather than treating her reclusive nature as a bad thing, he calls upon it to explain why she wouldn’t want to stay at the Piedmont Hotel, thereby challenging the idea that the only reason she chose to stay at Three Mountains Motel is because it would have made it easier for her to return to Barkley Cove to kill Chase. In this way, Tom repurposes the prejudiced and disapproving narrative that the townspeople have created so that it actually works in Kya’s favor.