This elderly neighbor of Elishva and Hadi’s is Umm Salim’s husband. He spends his days on his balcony, observing other people’s lives. This gives him a privileged position to identify suspicious events, such as when a strange figure—the Whatsitsname, whom he assumes to be a criminal—enters Elishva’s apartment. He also witnesses the departure of the officers who savagely beat up Hadi and stole his belongings. This leads him to take part in an action of solidarity toward the junk dealer: he calls out to various men in the neighborhood and, together, they bring medicine and supplies to Hadi, helping him recover from his beating. This demonstrates the links of friendship and generosity in the neighborhood of Bataween. Although the “writer” later recognizes Abu Salim’s voice as the voice of the Whatsitsname on Mahmoud’s digital recorder, the novel presents no additional information to give credibility to this link, thus suggesting that the resemblance between the two voices might be nothing more than a coincidence.