My Brilliant Career

by

Miles Franklin

My Brilliant Career: Chapter 14 Summary & Analysis

Summary
Analysis
Sybylla writes to her sister Gertie, revealing she has tried to write seven letters prior but keeps getting distracted. She tells Gertie about the kindness of Mrs. Bossier, Aunt Helen, and Uncle Julius, and wishes Gertie could hear the beauty of the piano. She asks if Possum Gully has seen rain, since Caddagat is facing a drought––though it is nothing like the droughts the Melvyns suffered near Goulburn. She describes her grandmother’s house as “the dearest old place in the world” and tells Gertie about her feelings for Harold Beecham. Harold is her favorite of the men around her, and she emphasizes that the area has more men than she’s ever seen in one place. She tells Gertie to think of her, adding that she is “just as ugly as ever.” She closes her letter again asking Gertie to remember her.
The way Sybylla gushes about Caddagat highlights how much she sees the estate as a paradise. Even when it faces difficulties, like a drought, Sybylla perceives those difficulties as superior to those at Possum Gully. Sybylla’s requests that Gertie remember her also continue Sybylla’s tendency to seek love from Gertie. The lack of confidence apparent in Sybylla’s craving for love is made more apparent by her claim that she is “just as ugly as ever.” Even though Aunt Helen has helped Sybylla like her appearance more, Sybylla still feels the need to emphasize her ugliness.
Themes
Ambition, Respectability, and Pride Theme Icon
Love Theme Icon
Sybylla writes another letter, this time to Everard Grey. She thanks him for the books and magazines he sent her and supposes he has forgotten all about the family at Caddagat after so long away. She anxiously awaits her visit to Sydney, where she plans to keep Everard and Aunt Helen dancing all night and all day. She wants to see everything in the city and to learn all of Sydney’s truths. Here, Sybylla stops writing, realizing the sentimentality of her letter would cause Everard to call her a fool. She tears up the letter and burns it in the fire, replacing it with a formal thank-you letter for the books and magazines. Everard never replies to this letter, though he writes to Mrs. Bossier about how busy he is and how much he travels.
Sybylla’s insecurities usually manifest as a dislike of her personal qualities: her appearance, her ambition, and her perceived uselessness. However, as she begins to mature and spend time with new people, particularly men, Sybylla’s insecurities extend to her social skills. Everard has sent Sybylla literature, which demonstrates an understanding of Sybylla’s passions and a genuine care for her. Sybylla refuses to accept that care, and instead chooses to believe that Everard would spurn her for being open with him. The opposite proves to be true, as Everard stops investing his energy in Sybylla when she responds to him without emotion.
Themes
Womanhood Theme Icon
Ambition, Respectability, and Pride Theme Icon
Sybylla has a few chores at Caddagat, one of which is to extend hospitality to visiting vagrants. Anyone who comes to Caddagat is offered food free of charge. The house sees about 50 men every week, all “hopeless, homeless, aimless, shameless” as they seek work. These men are a diverse group, and in some of them Sybylla detects a resentment of the Bossiers’ wealth. She takes this to mean that these men have failed in their lives and hate to see others succeed.
Mrs. Bossier’s charity to the vagrants initially seems like another aspect of the utopic perception Sybylla has of Caddagat. The number and diversity of the vagrants speaks to the prevalence of poverty in Australia, and Sybylla’s description of the men as “hopeless, homeless, aimless, shameless” emphasizes the many troubles they face. The rhyme and rhythm of the description also grant it a poetic quality, as if Sybylla is bringing these traveling laborers into the realm of her beloved literature. That perspective is more personal than the one that drives Mrs. Bossier’s philanthropy, and it accepts the vagrants as people instead of objects of pity.
Themes
Class and Poverty Theme Icon
Quotes
Sybylla worries about the cause of the widespread poverty she witnesses. She wonders why Australia, with its vast resources, cannot produce statesmen who care to help their countrymen. Her relatives, on the other hand, are not concerned about the beggars’ origins, and simply consider the men “a lazy lot of sneaking creatures.” Sybylla asks Uncle Julius if they could employ some of the beggars, or if some law could be made to help them, but Julius only laughs at her and asks if she would have him give his property to a tramp.
The Bossier family’s perception of the vagrants as “sneaking creatures” dehumanizes these men. Sybylla recognizes that poverty is too pervasive to be the fault of the poor, but her family members prefer to blame the vagrants for their own misfortune. This lack of both empathy and social awareness is the first indication that Caddagat might not be the flawless sanctuary Sybylla wants it to be. Although Sybylla loves her family at Caddagat, they have never experienced poverty as she has. When Sybylla suggests helping the beggars on a larger scale than simply feeding them, Julius’s unsympathetic response  highlights the upper class’s disregard for the poor.
Themes
Class and Poverty Theme Icon
Get the entire My Brilliant Career LitChart as a printable PDF.
My Brilliant Career PDF
Sybylla’s conversation with Uncle Julius is interrupted by a beggar. Julius responds to the man rudely and tells him that Sybylla is the boss. Sybylla serves him food and tobacco, but he refuses a glass of milk. As the man leaves, he wishes Sybylla God’s blessings. Sybylla watches him go, wondering if this man––her brother in humanity––truly believes in God. This sort of thinking rarely troubles Sybylla at Caddagat, since she has so many pleasures that she is happy simply to be reckless and young.
Caddagat’s role as a safe haven takes on a more insidious note as Sybylla reflects that the privilege she enjoys there allows her to forget about the injustices facing her countrymen. Her interaction with the beggar is a brief confrontation with reality, and it forces her to contend with the worries about religion and justice that plagued her at Possum Gully. However, the privilege of life at Caddagat has not entirely robbed Sybylla of her empathy for the lower classes. She does not mimic Julius’s rudeness to the beggar, and she regards the man as her brother.
Themes
Class and Poverty Theme Icon