Poverty in My Brilliant Career drains the life and spirit from all the characters it affects. By emphasizing the physical and mental toll of poverty, Franklin reveals the tangible hardships of poverty to her middle-class readers. The narrative specifically critiques upper-class perceptions of poverty through the characters at Caddagat. Though Mrs. Bossier and the residents of Caddagat provide meals to the homeless men who visit, Sybylla is the only member of the household who feels any real empathy for the them. She views the poverty that afflicts these men as a failure of the nation to protect its citizens, while the other residents of Caddagat believe poverty is a result of laziness. Uncle Julius laughs at Sybylla’s suggestion that Caddagat should open employment to the vagrants, exclaiming that work is the “very thing the crawling d[e]vils are terrified they might get.” His demonization and dehumanization of the poor reveals that Sybylla’s family only helps these people out of a sense of morality, not out of genuine compassion for their fellow human beings. Sybylla later criticizes this mindset, describing the elite class who profits off of traveling workers as “blood-suckers” who profit from “human sweat and blood and souls.” With this description, she dehumanizes the rich and explicitly focuses on the humanity of the people whom the rich exploit.
Throughout the novel, even as Sybylla complains of her life as a peasant, she makes clear that she does not disdain the peasant class––in fact, she respects them greatly as the backbone of the nation. However, Sybylla often correlates peasantry with ignorance, which complicates that respect. After she turns down Harold’s proposal for the last time, she has “nothing but peasant surroundings and peasant tasks, and [has] encouraged peasant ignorance—ignorance being the mainspring of contentment.” Sybylla indicates that the ignorance of peasants is not due to an innate lack of intelligence, but a lack of access to education. The connection she draws between ignorance and contentment also suggests that peasants cope with the difficulty of their lives by willfully ignoring information about a better life.
Class and Poverty ThemeTracker
Class and Poverty Quotes in My Brilliant Career
In flowery language, selected from slang used by the station hands, and long words picked up from our visitors, I propounded unanswerable questions which brought blushes to the cheeks of even tough old wine-bibbers. Nothing would induce me to show more respect to an appraiser of the runs than to a boundary-rider, or to a clergyman than a drover. I am the same to this day. My organ of veneration must be flatter than a pancake, because to venerate a person simply for his position I never did or will.
Hard graft is a great leveller. Household drudgery, woodcutting, milking, and gardening soon roughen the hands and dim the outside polish. When the body is wearied with much toil the desire to cultivate the mind, or the cultivation it has already received, is gradually wiped out. Thus it was with my parents. They had dropped from swelldom to peasantism. They were among and of the peasantry. None of their former acquaintances came within their circle now, for the iron ungodly hand of class distinction has settled surely down upon Australian society—Australia’s democracy is only a tradition of the past.
What a great army they were! Hopeless, homeless, aimless, shameless souls, tramping on from north to south, and east to west, never relinquishing their heart-sickening, futile quest for work—some of them so long on the tramp that the ambitions of manhood had been ground out of them, and they wished for nothing more than this. [...] In a wide young country of boundless resources, why is this thing? This question worried me. Our legislators are unable or unwilling to cope with it. They trouble not to be patriots and statesmen. [...] Why does [Australia] not bear sons, men of soul, mind, truth, godliness, and patriotism sufficient to rise and cast off the grim shackles which widen round us day by day?
I had been poor myself, and knew what awaited him in the world. He would find that they who fawned on him most would be first to turn their backs on him now. He would be rudely disillusioned regarding the fables of love and friendship, and would become cynical, bitter, and sceptical of there being any disinterested good in human nature. Suffering the cold heart-weariness of this state myself, I felt anxious at any price to save Harold Beecham from a like fate. It would be a pity to let one so young be embittered in that way.
Mrs M’Swat was a great, fat, ignorant, pleasant-looking woman, shockingly dirty and untidy. Her tremendous, flabby, stockingless ankles bulged over her unlaced hobnailed boots; her dress was torn and unbuttoned at the throat, displaying one of the dirtiest necks I have seen. It did not seem to worry her that the infant she hold under her arm like a roll of cloth howled killingly, while the other little ones clung to her skirts, attempting to hide their heads in its folds like so many emus.
Silence, you ignorant old creature! How dare you have the incomparable impertinence to mention my name in conjunction with that of your boor of a son. Though he were a millionaire I would think his touch contamination. You have fallen through for once if you imagine I go out at night to meet any one—I merely go away to be free for a few minutes from the suffocating atmosphere of your odious home. You must not think that because you have grasped and slaved and got a little money that it makes a gentleman of you; and never you dare to again mention my name in regard to matrimony with any one about here.
After Mrs M’Swat it was a rest, a relief, a treat, to hear my mother’s cultivated voice, and observe her lady-like and refined figure as she moved about; and, what a palace the place seemed in comparison to Barney’s Gap! simply because it was clean, orderly, and bore traces of refinement; for the stamp of indigent circumstances was legibly imprinted upon it, and many things which had been considered "done for" when thirteen months before I had left home, were still in use
Oh that a preacher might arise and expound from the Book of books a religion with a God, a religion with a heart in it—a Christian religion, which would abolish the cold legend whose centre is respectability, and which rears great buildings in which the rich recline on silken hassocks while the poor perish in the shadow thereof.