This Tender Land

This Tender Land

by

William Kent Krueger

This Tender Land: Chapter 13 Summary & Analysis

Summary
Analysis
Odie and Albert go into town to buy shoes. Odie worries people will be suspicious that they have so much money. In a small department store, they encounter another customer Odie calls the “one-eyed pig scarer” (One-eyed Jack) because of his eye patch and mean demeanor. A saleswoman asks what they are looking for, and Albert clams up. Odie realizes his brother cannot lie, and so he speaks up on Albert’s behalf, claiming Albert has a speech impediment. He tells the woman their father sent them to buy new shoes and groceries for the week. A salesman joins the conversation, trying to sell the boys expensive boots. He seems less trusting than his coworker, questioning Odie about his father and the $15.
Although Albert is good at solving practical problems, he is incapable of willful deception, and this makes him a liability for the group of fugitives. Odie, on the other hand, puts his slyness to good use in this scene, easily fooling the salespeople with a fabricated story to get what he wants. The brothers represent two sides of an ethical dilemma: can immoral action be justified if it achieves some greater good? Here, Odie lies to good people in order to protect himself and his family. Albert, on the other hand, struggles to see such unethical behavior as forgivable.
Themes
Family, Community, and Home Theme Icon
Hardship, Injustice, and Compassion Theme Icon
Coming of Age and Personal Growth Theme Icon
Acceptance and Forgiveness  Theme Icon
Odie continues to lie, saying their father recently found a job in town and their mother is dead. Playing on the saleswoman’s sympathy, he shows them his worn-down shoes. Eventually, Odie wheedles enough that the man gives them a discount on three pairs of boots, socks, and a sewing kit. Albert dislikes how easy it is for Odie to lie, and he’s worried Odie will turn out like Brickman or DiMarco. Odie’s anger at this assessment turns to fear when a police car drives by. He and Albert return to the river, but Mose and Emmy are gone, along with the canoe.
Here again, Odie uses his talent for storytelling to deceive rather than inspire hope. Still, his lies enable him to care for his found family, thereby (potentially) justifying the deception. Despite this, Albert disapproves of Odie’s methods, worried that dishonesty will become his primary mode of interacting with the world. That Odie takes offense at this (and that he hides his hurt from Albert) demonstrates that he deeply values his brother’s opinion and longs to be considered “good” by his standards.
Themes
Family, Community, and Home Theme Icon
Hardship, Injustice, and Compassion Theme Icon
Coming of Age and Personal Growth Theme Icon
Storytelling, Music, and Hope Theme Icon
Acceptance and Forgiveness  Theme Icon
Quotes