Previous
Part 1, Chapter 5: First Cell, First Love
Themes
Key
LitCharts assigns a color and icon to each theme in The Gulag Archipelago, which you can use to track the themes throughout the work.
Oppression and Totalitarianism
Survival and the Human Spirit
The Dangers of Ideology
Power as a Corrupting Force
The Value of Religion and Spirituality
Summary
Analysis
In June of 1945, prisoners at Butyrki Prison hear bands playing outside every morning and evening. Rumors circulate: a massive Victory Parade is being prepared for June 22. Inside, Solzhenitsyn and his fellow inmates grapple with the bitter irony. Triumphant music fills the air, yet the prison teems with men labeled as traitors. Many of these so-called “traitors” are Russian prisoners of war who survived against impossible odds, only to face disgrace and punishment.
The contrast between the Victory Parade’s celebratory music and the suffering of prisoners labeled as traitors exemplifies the Soviet regime’s hypocrisy. By imprisoning soldiers who survived captivity, the Soviet government betrays the very people it should honor.
Themes
As the weeks pass, the prison becomes a gathering point for men with ties to Europe. These are not just POWs but also laborers forced into German work camps, émigrés returning from decades abroad, and Red Army officers arrested for being too perceptive or independent-minded. Solzhenitsyn notes that many of these prisoners belong to his own generation—the “twins of October,” those born alongside the Russian Revolution, who had once shouted slogans of Soviet unity and fought fiercely at the war’s outset. Now, they are pariahs.
The “twins of October,” who once embodied the spirit of the Revolution, find themselves condemned by the very system they once championed. However, as Solzhenitsyn continues to reinforce throughout the novel, such a system eventually devours itself—no matter how loyal they might be to Stalin’s cause, even war heroes are eventually discarded.
Themes
Solzhenitsyn recalls seeing lines of captured soldiers, broken and dejected, marching in formation as they returned to Russia. The sight puzzles him at first. Why, he wonders, would these men voluntarily line up, forming ranks as if still under military command? Later, he understands: this submission is a deeply ingrained habit. They have absorbed the Soviet demand for order, even in defeat.
The soldiers’ instinctive obedience, even after capture, demonstrates the profound psychological control the Soviet regime exerted over its people. The Soviet state managed to create citizens who prioritized obedience over autonomy, even in situations where the state had clearly betrayed them.
Themes
The prisoners are branded “traitors of the Motherland.” Solzhenitsyn points out that it was not the prisoners who betrayed their country but rather the country that betrayed the prisoners—three times. First, on the battlefield, the government’s incompetence leaves the soldiers to face a crushing defeat. Then, in captivity, the state abandons them, leaving them to die in German camps. Finally, the government deceives them, promising forgiveness only to arrest them as they cross the Soviet border. Solzhenitsyn describes how the system forces these men to prove their innocence using witnesses who are often dead or unreachable. If they fail, they receive harsh sentences and are branded traitors, doomed to years of forced labor.
By abandoning its soldiers on the battlefield, in captivity, and upon their return, the Soviet state demonstrates that its only concern is its own survival—it does not care about the welfare of its people. This cycle of betrayal reveals a regime that views its citizens as disposable. Solzhenitsyn’s account highlights the Soviet Union’s moral bankruptcy, as it forces people to prove innocence despite their obvious loyalty. There is a clear irony in this system, as the Soviet government demands loyalty, only to backstab its most loyal followers in return.
Themes
Get the entire The Gulag Archipelago LitChart as a printable PDF.
Solzhenitsyn also tells the story of the Vlasovites—Soviet soldiers who join the German army out of desperation and a profound hatred for Stalin’s regime. Vlasovites get their name from General Vlasov, the most famous man to switch sides. Vlasovites sew the insignia of the Russian Liberation Army onto their sleeves, knowing full well that they will never see mercy from either side. Despite General Vlasov’s hopes, the German leadership never allows a truly independent Russian force to emerge. Vlasov’s men eventually make one last stand in Prague in May of 1945, fighting the Germans they once allied with. However, their fate is sealed. They surrender to the Americans, hoping for protection, but the Western Allies hand them over to the Soviets, leading to mass executions and imprisonments.
The story of the Vlasovites is an example of the complex and tragic choices that Soviet soldiers disillusioned with Stalin’s regime faced. Their decision to join the German army, while desperate, reflects a profound rejection of Soviet oppression. Solzhenitsyn’s depiction of the Vlasovites’ fate—betrayed by both the Germans and the Allies—emphasizes the cruelty of political expediency, where ideological and personal loyalties are sacrificed for political gain.
Themes
The forced repatriations target more than just soldiers. The British trick Cossack units that fought alongside the Germans, falsely promising safety before betraying them to the Soviets. Entire families, including women and children, endure brutal treatment, with some choosing suicide over returning to the USSR. Russian émigrés who fought in the French Resistance or lived abroad are also arrested. Many return home, hoping to find safety, only to end up imprisoned.
The forced repatriation of Cossacks and other émigrés reveals the tragic fates of those who resisted Soviet rule or sought refuge abroad. Solzhenitsyn uses these stories to critique both the Soviet regime and the complicity of Western governments, emphasizing how political calculations often override basic human decency.
Themes
