Previous
Part 3, Chapter 7
Themes
Key
LitCharts assigns a color and icon to each theme in Harlem Shuffle, which you can use to track the themes throughout the work.
Crime, Class, and Social Mobility
Identity and Duality
Community, Change, and Loyalty
Systemic Racism, Injustice, and Power
Betrayal, Vengeance, and Integrity
Summary
Analysis
Carney drives with Pepper down Park Avenue, noting how, as street numbers decrease, money increases exponentially. Bench told Carney to meet him at an unfinished Van Wyck building, where they will exchange the briefcase for Freddie, who they captured outside Aunt Millie’s house. Carney wonders whether Van Wyck’s men will actually return Freddie. He and Pepper grab some Chinese food to kill time before the meetup, looking through the briefcase’s papers, which contain love letters to Linus and a piece of paper with bank account numbers. Carney can only speculate what Van Wyck wants so badly. They return to Carney’s old truck, which he keeps because it feels like a disguise. He and Pepper arm themselves.
Again, the city mirrors its residents, showing clear class delineations based on wealth. Having captured Freddie, the Van Wycks have made it clear they are willing to resort to violence to get what they want. Carney cannot tell if they are the kind of criminals who will double-cross him or not. That Carney cannot guess what paper is so important to the Van Wycks emphasizes the distance between their stations and their criminal activities. Carney seems comforted by his father’s old truck, suggesting he not only accepts his crooked inheritance but puts his faith in it, too.
Themes
Heading into the unfinished Van Wyck building, Carney feels hopelessly outmatched. Pepper tells him he’s settled on the Egon recliner and a standing lamp as payment for the job. The lone security guard directs them to the elevator. Carney briefly considers abandoning Freddie to his fate, taking the account numbers, and making a run for it. He knows Elizabeth would leave him. Carney finds Bench and the two men who attacked Pepper on the 15th floor, in a recently finished conference room. Bench remarks that Van Wyck will be pleased to have everything returned to him. Carney demands to see Freddie. Pepper and the other two men hold guns on one another while Carney follows Bench’s instructions to the window.
The distribution of power strongly favors the Van Wyck family. Pepper’s remark about the recliner is glib, perhaps intended to ease Carney’s distress or imply that he does not expect to survive this confrontation. Not for the first time, Carney considers betraying Freddie, who has unintentionally betrayed him time and again. His dedication to his family wins out. The Van Wyck building, though unfinished, emphasizes the Van Wycks’ scope of influence—they are the city’s builders.
Themes
Carney remarks that Ambrose Van Wyck must be upset about his son, but Bench claims Linus was always disappointing, hanging out with a “bad element.” On the street below, two men carry a limp figure and dump the figure into Carney’s trunk. Bench says Freddie is alive, but Mr. Van Wyck decided to punish him for introducing Linus to narcotics. Carney knows this accusation is a lie. The narrative flashes forward briefly to two months after this night, when Pepper explains his actions were a matter of principle. Though he thinks the riots were ultimately pointless, because the police officer went unpunished, in the Park Avenue building Pepper shoots Van Wyck’s men as a way to “start small and work your way up.”
Ambrose’s flippant dismissal of Linus’s death shows that he, unlike Carney, does not value his family as much as his status. Van Wyck unfairly blames Freddie for introducing Linus to harder drugs, though Carney knows that Freddie never did heroin. This injustice is amplified by Bench’s racist implication that Freddie is a corruptive “bad element.” By flashing forward to get Pepper’s reasoning, the novel emphasizes the theme of racial retribution and justice. Pepper describes his decision to shoot Van Wyck’s men as a small act taken against an oppressive system. In comparing his actions to the riots, he implies that systemic change will likely be gradual instead of immediate.
Themes
Back in the present, Pepper shoots both of Bench’s men, killing them. He himself takes a bullet to the hip. Bench goes pale. Carney hands the briefcase over, seeing it as the only way to be permanently rid of the Van Wycks. He and Pepper take the dead men’s weapons and leave. Freddie is in the truck bed, his face beaten bloody. Pepper drives while Carney holds his cousin, looking up at the stars the way they used to do on the roof of Aunt Millie’s building. Carney feels that he, like the stars, has a place in the world. On a stretcher at Harlem Hospital, Freddie murmurs that he didn’t mean to get Carney in trouble.
Bench’s reaction suggests he is unaccustomed to violence. Pepper’s actions have given Carney the upper hand, yet he willingly hands the suitcase over, sensing that the powerful family will not take kindly to denial. This moment also underlines Carney’s personal integrity, proving that he only cares about power insofar as it ensures his family’s safety—since the briefcase actively endangers Freddie, he does not want it. Carney’s recollections of his and Freddie’s shared childhood are emotionally resonant, hinting at the sorrow Carney feels for his cousin’s suffering. Freddie’s apology is heartbreaking, demonstrating that betrayal is not always intentional, especially in a society where hustling for money is prioritized over community.
Themes
Get the entire Harlem Shuffle LitChart as a printable PDF.
